I also love Vamp Willow, Vamp Xander, and Randy :)

I see that Angelus is currently tied with "Engaged to Spike Buffy". She would have been my second choice.

And also Soldier Xander, but I can't add two...

Can't decide. Just wanted to remind people of the Halloween transformations.

oh I'll add them :P

I just love buffy's conversation with Riley when he sees her looking at dresses :P

I changed my choice because I was just watching a video and I saw all the amazing quotes from Randy :P

"Randy Giles??? Why not just call me horny Giles or desperate for a shag Giles? I knew there was a reason I hated you!"
I've made my point.

:Comment above: the reason why 'Randy' is my second choice

Angelus

I also love Angelus, Vamp Willow, Engaged Spike & Buffy, Joan and Dark Willow

... and Randy.

actually willow is a really good actress and brought out all of her characters really well

Angelus most defiantly! such a dark, delicious character!!
Vamp Willow- wow! I never dreamed that Alyson Hannigan could act soooo bad, prefer Vamp Willow over scary, veiny Willow lol.
Randy - i had trouble keeping a straight face as i couldnt stop laughing :p
Vamp Xander - didnt see that coming!
Engaged to Spike - dream come true...hmm i wonder what angel would think? LOL