All depends on story, characterization, and quality of animation. As far as Pixar goes, I don't really care for the way they draw people but I can flow with it due to how lovely the rest of the package normally is coming from them (with the exception of Cars and Ratatouille). At any rate, Pixar does 3D a million times better than Дисней on their own.
In the end, though, I much prefer the look of "2D animated magic." It's stylish, classic, and tends to look much еще beautiful as far as the actual characters themselves look; sometimes the environment can be lacking, but only sometimes.
As an artist in the field of Анимация i have a distinct appreciation for both traditional and 3D generated animation. Pixar is a wonderful company who has brought the world a whole new style of Анимация that i think is just as magical as the old Дисней Фильмы were. The stories are heartwarming and are just as memorable as the greatest Дисней stories. 2D Анимация will always be there and i think the newest Дисней movie The Princes and the Frog will keep that magic alive if that's what people are worried about, but it's good that Ты guys know that Дисней has been using computers to animate since The Little Mermaid, just not to the extent of complete computer rendering. As long as the story is great and the Анимация compliments that story I have no problem with 3D animated movies. Just my two cents :)
posted Больше года
I agree. I'm just sick of all the Pixar-hating retards bad-mouthing Pixar. Pixar's Фильмы are just as great and unforgetable as Disney's 2D classics.
While for me the story is еще important than the way it is animated, on a general basis, I do agree that 2D Анимация is superior to 3D. I haven't watched too many Pixar films. Other than Toy Story, I generally found them forgettable after watching them five years ago.
Classic Disney, from Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs to Tarzan, had a different and unique magic and charm that I very much appreciate. I find that the stories are generally еще creative, and to me it is nice to find voices that Ты hear in multiple classics, (i.e. Verna Felton, Phil Harris), but don't distract from the story by being so well known.
I greatly miss Classic 2D Дисней Animation, and I hope The Princess and The Frog will do well so Дисней can be encouraged to make еще high-quality 2D animation.
posted Больше года
Ты know what, i have no doubt that Princess and the Frog will do well!! It's original, it's a fairytale, we know its gonna be funny and romantic!!! This movie is the breath of fresh Дисней air we've all been waiting for!!!
CG Анимация isn't soulless; it takes just as much hard work, heart, and dedication as hand-drawn Анимация and stop-motion. Pixar puts a ton of сердце into their amazing Фильмы and short films, and they've never made anything bad. Also, they are SO not overrated; unless overrated means better than every other movie company but in equal ranks with Disney? Meh, either way, Pixar and Дисней are both insanely great.
I much prefer the beautiful hand drawn classic Фильмы which brought everyone to Любовь and cherish Дисней in the first place. They were never 3D and made millions. Besides, when i watch a 3D movie all the dark scenes are extra dark because i'm wearing huge tinted glasses.
I personally Любовь pixar! They are super creative and the Анимация is beautiful! That doesn't mean I don't like classic 2D. Most of Disney's classic's are 2D. 50 years from now I don't imagine people remembering Disney's 3D, live action, или the lame Дисней stars. I would probably choose 2D but I still Любовь Pixar.
posted Больше года
Great point. Glad to see someone sees how spectacular, creative, funny, and romatic Pixar's Фильмы are. Right on, man! Right on! :D