Ответить на этот вопрос

Critical Analysis of Twilight Вопрос

Does anyone else feel that they can't STAND Renesmee Cullen? Do I sound really tight?

 Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Ответы

Nicoleandjames said:
I can't stand her either she is a verry unessicary character. There was no need to even put her in it she just ruined twilight even еще then it already was. Does any body else feel that she was imposible to begin with.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
yea I think so too-I really thought she was gonna die
summerfrog posted Больше года
*
YES!
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
*
she does really ruin twilight and i hate her so much! edward and bella should've get rid of that little thing!
mommylove123 posted Больше года
cassie-1-2-3 said:
Lol, no. She's just a child, she doesn't do much either way. There's not much to hate about her.
Most of the reasons people give for hating Renesmee are too funny. Especially "She's well behaved" или "she;s not a normal baby". She's not supposed to be a normal baby. I wouldn't find it so humorous if the Bella DID have a normal human baby who was supposed to behave like a normal human baby.


As for the "she shouldn't exist" argument, I just think most people haven't really thought about it enough. It's plenty plausible in my head.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Especially considering all the other dhampirs that came before her. I don't like Renesme, but I wholeheartedly agree with everything Ты said.
November99 posted Больше года
*
Renesmee isn't a bad character, it's just in the movie they chose the wrong actress to portay her. Otherwise, she seems nice in the movie, but WAY TOO perfect in the book.
doremi1234ify posted Больше года
jacob4ever57 said:
Oh the ways I hate that child...How shall i start? Hmmm the choices.
Well one like everybody else said, it's so impossible for her to even exist it's not even funny. There's no way on earth Edward could've have had a kid with Bella. (I say Bella cheated. LOL jk jk).
But yeah and then she grew up in like 2 weeks! Wtf? that was just....ridiculous!!!! And oh Jacob imprinting on her?! That's what really got me. THAT'S SO SICK!! SHE'S NOT EVEN A день OLD AND HE'S IN Любовь WITH HER!!!! I am so team Jacob, but i really don't like him after he imprints. He doesn't seem as fun anymore. (Same with Edward he seems еще annoying in BD)
*Sigh* I just hate that demonic little thing so much. The vultri should've killed her...Excuse me. It.
OHH!!! And i forgot! Another thing is the way Bella wanted to keep the little thing!! It was so stupid! She could've died, but yet "Oh no it's not a thing!! Shut up! I Любовь the little monster!" Good God get real.
Woooo that was a long rant! Alright well I'm done now! I usually just block the whole Renesmee thing out of my mind anyway and just forget BD ever happened, and that Eclipse ended with jake coming back, and imprinting on someone, oh i don't know someone a little еще realistic than a half vampire - half human!

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Ah such true points.
Free_Spirit posted Больше года
*
i still got a creepy feeling that so many pedophile rejoice watching the imprinting scene in the movie...
ClaireVoyant posted Больше года
*
u r so right she is alittle monsyer
khaliah107 posted Больше года
*
Ты hate her for a bunch of things she didn't do?
cassie-1-2-3 posted Больше года
PlaceboEffect01 said:
Yes. Besides the fact that (and I know this has been repeated so many times) Renesmee is physically IMPOSSIBLE to conceive, (EDWARD HAS NO SPERM) she is PERFECT and those characters always annoy the hell out of me.

I remember this.

Renesmee: It's my fault isn't it.
Everyone else in the room: No, no! Of course not!

Yeah it ain't your fault, Ты demon baby Mary-Sue but it's your creators. Bella, Edward and Stephenie Meyer.

Renesmee is cute, Renesmee is smart, Renesmee is adorable, Renesmee is complete bull.

That is all.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
*applauds*
kellysimona posted Больше года
*
I agree. I always thought Renesmee was еще Mary-Sue than Bella. The 'perfect' little girl from the 'perfect' couple...
katiecain posted Больше года
*
Haha thank you.
PlaceboEffect01 posted Больше года
Indi124 said:
Dude don't be a bitch. If Ты read the WHOLE book without skimming it like a lazy asshole Ты would understand How Nessie became what she is. Her father is A Vampire, A smart one at that, so why not make her smart? Stephanie Meyer is like any other Автор Письмо a book just for the hell of it. No one cares that Ты don't like Renesmee, we'll live. How does a vampire on twilight have a baby? Men don't don't have a woman's body dead или not. Men can have a freaking a freaking baby when ever they want 100 или 13. Unlike a woman who, menopause. There are also many other character's in Фильмы like twilight that has Vampire and half Human Children Like blade. No one cares how he was born. Your only Актёрское искусство like a douchebag because it's twilight.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
dinglebell14 said:
no and yes. no because she sounds really cute ! but yes because she is from twilight -.-'..... and she sounds ... well... never mind... XD
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
she's a little demon who needs to be slayer by buffy
vampiressJazz posted Больше года
*
Ha ! That would be funny! XD
dinglebell14 posted Больше года
*
She would be wed to Lucifer...
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
renrae said:
I like the anti-fanfiction version of her еще than her.

(fanfic version: lesbian, runs away from the Cullens, changes her name to Rena, and finds a way to stop glowing in the dark.)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
YES thats a way better story!
summerfrog posted Больше года
*
OH MY GAWD! 'Mazing! :)
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
*
okii dokii i have other words!
Myf_1992 posted Больше года
snoznoodle said:
She's the last straw of sanity which snapped. I had no problem whatsoever with the Книги until her. "Renesme Carlie"?? are Ты serious?! And there's been plenty of discussion - it's not possible for her to exist in the first place! Maybe I should thank SM - if it wasn't for the wrongness of Renesme I would have never realised that the whole series was extremely bad. No I realy CAN'T stand her.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Not the only one then. :)
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
*
She's created vampire laws just to completely went against them!
Vikitoria posted Больше года
*
YES!!! FINALLY!!!!! OMG YES!! THIS IS EXZACTLY MY POINT OF VIEW TOO!!!!!
jacob4ever57 posted Больше года
summerfrog said:
I think everything about Renesmee is ridicules! its like S.Myers got so excited that everyone liked her book that she had to take it further! and Edward doesn't even to the bathroom how did he make a baby?! it was еще like S.Myers wanted to make a teen drama than a vampire story by making Nessi
but thats just me
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I know! I thought Вампиры were dead. And everything, and I mean EVERYTHING is supposed to be dead, but, oh! Wait a minute, these Вампиры don't burst into a fiery flame when they're in the sunlight, no. They SPARKLE, with diamondy elegance....... THUS ANYTHINGS POSSIBLE!
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
*
The first HP book is my fav. Sorry I didn'y answer earlier...
Phoebe_Gabriel posted Больше года
*
lolzz its okay even i havent been on Fanpop alot these days
chagrin91 posted Больше года
chagrin91 said:
i really cant stand her either i mean who is she? i hate her alot i cant stand her coz she is only 2 или three years old in just one week wich is impossible and she already knows that her mom and dad are in stress and she is calming them by saying everythn will be okay i mean wtf i hate her i really do ( though am a big twilight Фан but renesmee kind of ruins it for me some time)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
HA! "i mean WHO IS SHE?" Gigggggggggles!
Mrs-Grint posted Больше года
*
lolzz yeah true she acts like a 60 год old being hardly three год old
chagrin91 posted Больше года
Myf_1992 said:
Renesme is annoying to me because she is so illogical. SM ignores obvious impossibilities to play happy families.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Free_Spirit said:
NO i am totally with you. Renesmee is so annoying. She's too perfect. Why can't one of the Вампиры have a flaw. Anyway she's actually a little bit hm i can't find the word, but i feel she wants to be the best at everything like when she getsupset when she see's Bella as pretty.

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
exactly Ты just took that from my mouth i mean that tooo
chagrin91 posted Больше года
kellysimona said:
I hate her! Maybe еще than I hate SM! Ok, definitely not еще but she's second. She spoiled the whole book (not that the horrible Письмо was helping Meyer!), it was just awful! I mean one moment Jake hates her and than he's all lovey-dovey ??? Puh-lease! Him and Leah are way better, but that goes agains Meyer's policy that Любовь happens at first sight, and Ты can't Любовь someone Ты hated! Woman, read Pride and Prejudice, the people who fight are usually like that because they have feelings for each other! Renesmee ruined the book for me mostly because of Jake, but also because she's a spoiled little brat! When Nahuel came I was jumping up and down and scraming "Take that, you're not really one-of-a-kind are you!" And I know she's a baby (oh, and fictional), but she shouldn't be so perfect, she is half human! I'm perfectly all right with Rosalie for instance или Emmett because they have character flaws (vain,childish) but Edward, Bella and Bratsmee are way to perfect to be not annoying!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
He he Bratsmee!!!!! lol!!!!! I totally agree with everything Ты said. I mean who is she? She's half Bella correct? And the human Bella did have flaws. But Renesmee... no she has to be perfect just because SM is obsessed with children. And SM has always wanted a daughter right? If I was one of her SONS I would never talk to her again!
Phoebe_Gabriel posted Больше года
*
lolzzzz its soooooooooooo true renesmeee did ruin the whole book for me tooo
chagrin91 posted Больше года
horsemad1110 said:
I absolutely loathe Renesmee. Not that I don't adore Jacob and the Twilight Saga, (Though I wish James had killed Edward and Bella...) No-one can be perfect. Stephenie Meyer made her sound like a Goddess, which she is clearly not, and obviously, ruined Jacob's life. SM added a completely unnessasary and impossible chapter to B.D. as Edward, a vampire, is dead, has no beating сердце and no pulsing blood, had a baby with a living, breathing, moronic girl named Bella. Then there was the disgusting part of Renesmee breaking bones, causing bruises and mentally ruining Bella. I agree that Renesmee is a total fantasy.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
sm made renesmee like that daughter of corner in Энджел series in wich she takes over the world and everybody likes her and everythn
chagrin91 posted Больше года
shriekingshack said:
I really can't stand Renesmee. I mean a half-vampire/half-human baby? That ridiculous. And first of all, how was she even created? I mean how did edward and bella manage to make her? Edward's a vampire. And she grows sooo fast. It's actually quite annoying and .. weird. And jacob imprinted on her?? That is so weird. So if he can't have bella he'll have her daughter? And S Meyer made her seem so perfect and beautiful that it's so annoying
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
mommylove123 said:
Yeah I know!! ITS FREAKING WEIRD!!!!! what the hell is a half human half vampire?????? She's making twilight not my favourite series anymore!!!!!! And what's a name called "Renesmee" ? I know Edward или bella gave her the name.. I don't blame these two.. All I'm thinking about is renesmee and he way she smiles and she Показать her teeth!!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
khaliah107 said:
I заяц that little devil she is so ugly that every time I see her the trash can screams but let me make a Список of all the stuff that I hate about renesmee.1.she is a mistake to begin with 2.she is a horriable little monster 3.she украл, палантин my man cause I'm team jackup and I saw a Предварительный просмотр and she was all cuddle with my man and that just made me mad and made me want to gp to Hollywood and go up to her face and start punching her face until it bust open and she dies
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TriaRose said:
I really, really, really loathe her, even еще than I hate Bella (and I hate Bella a lot). She is obviously Meyer's perfect daughter. I really hate how she's all "Renesmee was beautiful, she was so smart, she was so talented, everyone who laid eyes on her loved her" especially the last one. Seriously! And the fact that she NEVER cried или did anything wrong! She was such a Mary-Sue, and she was soooo annoying to read about! And I won't even start on the imprinting или the fact that she really shouldn't exist. Yes, I do hate her, and I think a lot of other people do to.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Дети cry because they can't talk. They have no other way of telling people what they need. Renesmee didn't need to cry because she had the power to tell anyone whatever she wanted by touching their face.
cassie-1-2-3 posted Больше года
*
I didn't hate her just because she didn't cry. I hated her because she was a Mary-Sue, and she was boring and pointless and annoying to read about. Her perfection really bugged me, because I really hate Mary-Sues and she was the definition of a Mary-Sue, even еще so than Bella.
TriaRose posted Больше года
*
The point of Renesmee is so she can be the protagonist of the Далее book.
cassie-1-2-3 posted Больше года
*
Please God no, don't tell me that there's going to be another book!
TriaRose posted Больше года
alexisn10 said:
I don't see why everyone hates her so much. Like Cassie said, she's just a child. I found her character enjoyable. But then again, I haven't read the Книги in years. Maybe I'll change my mind if I were to read them now...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
graystone said:
Yes, count me in. She is way too perfect, the perfect hybrid of perfect parents. Oh, everyones loves her too(even the enemies). She's portrayed as being еще mature for her age, can take her of herself and grows at an exceptional rate( so that Jacob doesn't have to wait long).
Summary: Annoying
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
ayygurl said:
I don't like her either, I Любовь Bella and Edward's Любовь story not her.... I mean she is okay but I only want to watch the movie because I Любовь Bella and Edward's connection!!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TEAMEDWARDFOEVA said:
This might just be me, but, I don't like her b/c when Bella is thinking about her, it kind of takes the Edward away from Twilight...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »