Диснеевские принцессы
Диснеевские принцессы Smartest DP Countdown: день 7! Pick the princess Ты think is the LEAST smartest. Elimination based on comments, not percentages.
This question is now closed
38 fans picked: |
Belle
|
|||
жасмин
|
|||
Tiana
|
|||
Мулан
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
well, it's either her or Tiana
Oh, well, still the same reasoning - her or Tiana. Both are good at thinking on their feet, but that'S it. Belle on the other hand is good in using words to get what she wants.
seriously, give me one reason why belle is smarter than them...she reads, yes...what else?
i'm tired of these biased countdowns
And Tiana? At least we know that she can read, though she is interested in nothing aside from her cook books. But she inicially falls for Naveen's lies, nearly falls for Facilier's false promises and doesn't get Mama Odies message although she more or less spells out for her what she really needs. Yeah, really smart there.
Rapunzel is smarter than Belle, but she already got voted out based on feeble excuses. Mulan is smarter. But I have the feeling that Belle gets now so many votes based on the typical "Just because she reads that doesn't mean she is smart" nonsense. Belle does much more than reading to prove that she is smart - and the fact that she reads is a point for her, even if reading alone doesn't necessarily make someone smart.
and yes, jasmine is smart. she discovers that aladdin is prince ali, she gets a way to trick jafar and she learns things very easily, as we can see when she climbs the wall
Climping a wall is not smart, the question is not which Princess is the best in sport (than I would vote her on place three, behind Pocahontas and Mulan). She needs ages to figure Aladdin out, and then she falls for the dumb "I pretended to be a beggar" line, although Aladdin told her how much he was dreaming to be rich and free when they first meet. Yes, she distracts Jafar, by using her womanly charm - I said that she is a good actor. And because she can think on her feet, I didn't vote her out earlier. But it's now really time for her to go.
We never see Jafar hypnotize the Sultan in front of Jasmine except once; maybe he never did it in front of her before.
Belle's comebacks aren't that smart. They're just obvious statements.
"Gaston, you are positively primeval!" wow, how witty.
"But...but...I just don't deserve you." Oh, I am so struck down by her cleverness.
Tiana is at least resourceful and thinks on her feet, people have different definitions/opinions of what smart is. Belle has a brain.
Jasmine DID figure out who Aladdin is; and didn't Aladdin also say he PRETENDS to be a beggar? Wouldn't saying he dreams of riches / freedom be part of his act?
On the other hand, witty or not, the simple use of the word "primeval" shows a certain level of education. And yes, it was clever to go through the room and lean against the door, causing Gaston to lean over her. She would have never gotten him out of the house otherwise.
And yes, Tiana is resourceful, hence my decision to vote out Jasmine first. But she is also very dumb at times, and less educated than Belle or Rapunzel.
But you do have some very good points about Jasmine, I hadn't picked out myself, probably b/c I've been watching the movie so long I just avoid the plotholes.
Войди или зарегистрируйся для того, чтобы добавить свой комментарий