Shes Bella's and Bella loves her she belongs there!

They are both brilliant sets of parents but I agree with you, Lexiblack1998!

I honestly don't see why Renesmee shouldn't be Bella and Edward's daughter. Yes, Carlisle and Esme are great parents, but Renesmee belongs with and to Bella and Edward, in my opinion. After all, Bella loved her so much even before she was born! And, well, gave birth to her.

thanks oh and cullensisters-x ur awesome u both rockerz BYE!!!!

Carlisle and Esme have other children!!!!
I for example!!!
adopt me

I think Nessi belongs to Bella and Edward
but I think it would be great if they have one too

Hey thanks guys i love comments yo check out my profile!r u guys team eddie?

yeah!!!
I agree with you crazyvery!!!
Esme and Carlisle deserve!!!!
S2

Welll esme and carlisle should get a little baby like nessie!but ness is bellas

To atleast hide it for a while ....and it'd make more sence if it was that way anyway.

i'm carolinzinha

yea carlisle n esme deserve a baby but renesmee is sooooooooooo perfect to be the daughter of bella n edward

I would love to see Esme and Carlisle with a baby. But Renesmee is Bella and Edwards daughter