Ответить на этот вопрос

Игра престолов Вопрос

Why do people like Jon Snow so much?

I have not read the Книги (I'm sorry, I'm sorry) I am only basing my view and opinion on him from the Показать and Wikipedia.
Yes I know, he is one of the "good guys" on the show, and for no other reason; a likable character.
But a "fan-favourite"!?! I just can't заворачивать, обертывание my head around that. For the span of the Показать so far, I keep thinking to myself, "Why are Ты relevant? and How do Ты even come into any of the other plot lines?"

So I must ask, is there something in his character, или an event with Jon(I don't mind spoilers) that is so epically awesome that it would be impossible NOT to like him????
 hey287 posted Больше года
next question »

Игра престолов  Лучший ответ

daenerys said:
Yep, what Ala8ia said: we have read the books. He just continues to impress me еще & more. There have been some instances when I thought he was going to screw up royally but then he pulled it all back together. Had he had a еще vindictive nature, his story could have gone in a very different, dangerous, ultimately disastrous direction.

I think he should be a really горький kid but he's not. He makes the best of whatever situation he finds himself in. On the Показать we have seen him mature quite a bit, mostly due to the fact that he has a teachable spirit. What's not to love?

P.S. He doesn't have to be relevant to the plots (although he is, somewhat). The happenings at the Стена are a plot all on their own, with as much relevance to the story as a whole as the others.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I completely agree with everytihng Ты said.
D_J267 posted Больше года
*
thankyou! So the Книги make him a better character. Trust me when I say that I really, really, really want to read them but I can't find them :(
hey287 posted Больше года
*
After searching high & low I finally got mine from a second-hand bookstore. If Ты are really desperate they are available online, either as read-only или PDF.
daenerys posted Больше года
*
"What's not to love?" ... Everything.
FlightofFantasy posted Больше года
next question »

Ответы

Ala8ia said:
Because, xmmm...
Because, xmmm...
Because, we have read the books...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I don't get it. Shouldn't that make Ты LESS of a Jon fan? He's such an angsty Marty Stu!
FlightofFantasy posted Больше года
*
Well, I don't get your vitriol towards him. Such is life. The joys of differing opinions.
daenerys posted Больше года
ebathory said:
He's a very important character, as Ты have not read the Книги I suppose you'll just have to keep watching. Ты сказал(-а) Ты didn't mind spoilers, and without giving anything specific away he's one of the few 'original' (as in is in the Книги from the very beginning) who is still alive in the Книги to date.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
FlightofFantasy said:
I have to disagree with what the others are saying. Jon is a much, MUCH better character in the Показать than the books.
In the books, he's nothing but a whiny, angst-ridden Marty Stu. Over the course of the series, there are literally hundreds of pages devoted exclusively to his tortured, woe-is-me monologing. Add to that the fact that he is good at EVERYTHING, fighting, strategizing, spying, planning, everything, and you've got possibly one of the "best" examples of a Marty Stu ever.
Ты know how whiny and annoying Luke Skywalker is? Well, imagine if he had actually NARRATED звезда Wars, and you've got Jon Snow of the books. "Oh, no one loves me, I've got it so hard, I'm a bastard, I'm so handsome and clever and good at everything and I'm the only one in the world who has problems!" SHUT UP, SNOW.
Oh, and the only reason I say he's a better character in the Показать is we're not forced to endure his painful monologs, like we are in the books.

*ahem* Well, anyway. As Ты might have noticed, I'm not exactly Jon's biggest fan. xD
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Ha ha I actually feel kinda the same, I never liked him much in the Книги but was interested in the 'wall' storylines. However he annoys me much less in the show,
ebathory posted Больше года
nsk said:
ivent read the Книги yet so i can tell for the show.
I Любовь jon snow because first, of the actor who plays him: he is sweet and adorable
and i just Любовь him LOL , i dont know why , ive always had a soft spot for sweet but strong characters , i Любовь that he is a great fighter but also a great Друзья to rely on , he loves his family еще than anything and i Любовь when he make mistakes

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
OceanCoast said:
I read somewhere that the в общем и целом, общая story arch of the Книги can be broken down into 3 distinct 'sections' that are;

1. The struggle between the families vying for the thrown
2. The story of Daenerys,
3. What goes on at the wall.

As I have not read the Книги yet, I can't say for certain but it does look to me that Jon's purpose is to lead the story of #3. So far, excluding that opening scene in the premier, we've only seen the story develop through his perspective, so what goes on beyond the Стена had been limited up until the finale. I'm guessing the секунда season will spend a lot еще time exploring this storyline, since they spent all of season 1 establishing it.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
cigi90 said:
People like to identify with characters who are loners/outcasts/underdogs of a sort. (take Peter Parker, Harry Potter, Bruce Wayne, etc) Because Jon is a bastard he's an outsider, though at no fault of his own. He can't dine with the Stark family, can't have the Stark name или have any of the same rights of his half brothers and sisters, and his father's wife Catelyn loathes him (as if children chose their parents или even asked to be born).
Although we can tell this adversity bothers Jon, he tries to take it in stride and tries to be a man with integrity, a man his father would approve of. He remains a likeable character. I think the same goes for Daenerys, she's a loner in some ways but finds strength in struggleadversity.
In contrast, Theon Greyjoy and Viserys are also kind of loners but definitely еще UNlikeable.
Might also help that the actor who plays Jon Snow, Kit Harrington, is pretty :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
junoULka2678 said:
i haven't read the Книги yet...i don't think i understand the whole thing but almost all of my Друзья Любовь him because he's a pretty and they call him "nice fellow"^^i think of him like 50/50.he has some kind of charming или something like that.and everything he does smells like power.and of course he's just "a little bastard" so people can't stand of watching a poor guy suffering because of his unsuccessful origin.people just can't NOT feel about him so maybe that's why he's so popular^^ i'm so sorry for my poor eng
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Bashkim said:
Jon Snow is the lovechild of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
rlmannod said:
This is a spoiler: It is a Популярное opinion that he is part Targaryen, son of Rhaeger and Ned Stark's sister. He should be one of the riders of Dany's dragon's when she comes to King's Landing.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
joshosh2 said:
Jon Snow is hands down the protagonist of SoIaF. He is the quintessential "Hero", always trying to do good and constantly battles to find the greater good. He has all the characteristics of a hero: he is handsome, has great combat skills, and he has еще "honor" than anyone on the show, save Lord Eddard Stark. Some might argue that Robb Stark is еще like his lord father, and therefore is the honorable character in SoIaF, once Lord Stark is beheaded. I think that Jon Snow has еще honor than his half brother. He has to constantly choose between what is the right thing to do in the most difficult of situations. He always chooses the right answer, no matter what happens. Robb on the other hand goes with his gut on most matters, and makes many wrong decisions, such as marrying Jeyne Westerling even though he was betrothed to one of Lord Frey's daughters.
I think Jon Snow is liked so much because he is the only character in SoIaF that is truly "good". I think this is actually funny because he is a bastard, who in SoIaF are supposed to be hostile human beings. Well, hope this answered your question.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
CrystaldiAngelo said:
It's not impossible not to like him. But since that isn't the answer, I will just Переместить on.
First, it's his bastard birth. Most people Любовь those who had a hard childhood, или a tragic experience...well, Ты get the picture.
Secondly, he seems more...human. Eddard is too formal, Catelyn too rational, Sansa too proper. So Jon and Arya are the only ones that aren't that...uh, I just can't find any words to put in.
Thirdly, he's the odd one out, and attracts еще attention than the rest.
Hope it makes sense. Bye!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Clemency90 said:
I think the thing is he is so honourable, and considers things carefully. He is very kind and seems to help people that are weaker than him. I like he's the strong silent type but he also seemed very loving to Ygritte. In the TV Показать he's also very handsome.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
KokoBelle said:
I haven't read the books, just started tonight. Jon was raised in a well-known family as a step-child. Having been raised in a similar fashion myself, I feel he is relatable. I feel most people root for the underdog in stories and Jon is definitely that. He also is a noble kid who tries his best to make the right decisions with whatever knowledge he has. He's basically a good boy that Ты want to see grow up and succeed.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TheHound1 said:
I don't dislike him and I think that he is very relevant to the story (or the situation that he is in is relevant), as through him we get to see what's going on at and north of the wall.
But as Ты may have gathered (if Ты read my Jon Snow related question), I'm not quite sure what all the fuss is about surrounding him. He seems to be a bit of a stereotypical screen hero to me - dark haired, brave, agile, clever and everything really. He seems to have no bad traits, which doesn't make for a hugely interesting или realistic character. I haven't read the Книги so I can't Комментарий on whether this is George Martin's или the programme makers fault.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »