This should be the best tiebreaker so far! Really unpredictable, since they're both so popular!

In Top 4 are Jimmy, Trish and Richard!

And lets just say that whoever passes has an ace up their sleeve!

So, VOTE as much as you can today!

How can we vote as much as we can in one day? We're only allowed one vote unless people are setting up fraudulent accounts.

^agreed

becca85: I meant vote in as large number of people possible. Of course each has only one vote, but I'm saying 'Please people, don't be lazy to vote, please vote in a large number, because it's more interesting then when only 5 people vote'. Hope I made it clearer:)

Obs gonna vote Abby!

Obs gonna vote Sully! -.- :D

Haha, Abby til da end!

Aww, I didn't get on yesterday so I wasn't able to vote, however it looks like it's another tie, but either way my vote goes to Abby <3

OMG, it's a tie upon tie, what now??

We COULD include HarpersIslandFan's vote and make Abby the winner OR we can repeat the tie OR we can eliminate both and skip to top 3.

Please tell me what to do! Thanks in advance:)

PS. In case of elimination of both, both Sully and Abby would be credited as Fourth:)

Yeah, just put them both fourth TIED

I guess it's not a bad idea, I just have to check with HarpersIslandFan, JimmyManceLuvr, Katie11 and others, but I like the idea.

I think we should make Abby winner, since HIF didn't have a chance to vote

Maybe, IDK. It would be nice to her:) Thanks for commenting Katie. I actually like both ideas better than another tiebreaker, cause maybe it would turn out the same and it would get boring.

I actually think that the person most entitled to decide, besides me, is HarpersIslandFan and I'm really interested in what she'll say.

I actually think I'll either do:

A) Let Abby pass, but with a catch that she has to pass without a tiebreaker into Top 3 or she's out

B) Make both eliminate, but title Sully as 5'th and Abby as 4'th


What would you think of either option?

I think both eliminate and make Abby 4th, cause HIF didn't get to vote, and she would've voted Abby. Everyone is entitled to decide

I know, but in that case I meant to eliminate both, but credit Abby as fourth and Sully as fifth and continue with semifinals with Jimmy, Trish and Richard. What do you think about that?

Or I can keep Abby, but with a catch that if she's in any tiebreaker next time, the other person automatically wins.

IDK yet:)

Abby fourth Sully 5th i think

I am fine with whatever is decided, but I think I like the idea of eliminating them both and making Abby 4th and Sully 5th because technically the question was closed so I was a little late. But I'm okay with whatever is decided ;)

Thank you:) I'm sorry that you weren't able to make the vote. I hope you had some great time instead. I'll probably skip to Top 3, but still have to decide. Your opinion means alot to me:)

But I think I'll make Abby a Top 4 Poster anyway, cause Top 4 Posters are amazing and work alot better as four set than three set.

However, they're only for good looks and Abby's recognizal as 4'Th, not actual invitation to vote, so I'm kinda sorry.

On the other hand, if I decide to make actual top 4, it might be handy.

IDK what to do...

I think you should go ahead and create a Top 4 Poster for her anyway and then list her as 4th and call it good and not have her open to vote for. It is all up to you though, I am absolutely fine with anything, thanks for asking my opinion too (:

not agreed because people who would have voted for sully might now vote for abby or vice versa, so redo or count HIF vote and continue on.

Thanks, Harper's Island Fan! Of course I'm very interested in your opinion.

Sorry Indeedcoffe, but majority said it, so we'll skip to semifinals this year!