Do Ты think that Twilight is a copycat from Harry Potter..??

I totally agree with you! this is exactly what i've been trying to explain to everyone, on here that think there the same!!

Ok, so I'm new to this site and only really came across it when browsing through the web to find out whether 'Midnight Sun' (in the Twilight series) was from Edward's point of view. I must admit, Ты guys come up with some interesting theories, but all I can say is that both authors - J.K Rowling and Stephanie Meyer are magical (no pun intended) writers. I am HUGE Фаны of both series - although new to the Twilight series, but I am enjoying the Книги and thoroughly enjoyed both films. I've followed Harry Potter since день one, and the thought of this Фэнтези world coinciding with our reality is a wonderful thought, however it is just a fantasy. I understand that we get heated up when we feel SO strongly about something as - sorry to say, trivial - this. I do get really involved with the characters when Чтение the books, and shamefully admit I get upset when I finish a book, but I think that that is all down to the way the authors portray their writing, both convey Обои in out minds that we feel a part of and therefore get heated up about when arguments such as these crop up, but all I wanted to say is that it is quite upsetting to see that many of Ты are falling out over somthing Ты are all so passionate about.

Some points are the same though. Ex: Character moves to different place. S/He is atoumatically liked by some people because they are beautiful/famous. Both have to fight through villian after villian. Finally they reach they're goal. Ex2: Lavender (Sp?) and Hermione both like Ron. Edward and Jacob both like Bella. But I see your point. They are different series.

Ты ROCK!!!!!! Everything Ты сказал(-а) was so true!!!!!

I agree except for the teenage lust thing. Edward would have to be a teenager for that to be true and he's like 100. That's creepy, bro.

And this Вопрос was answered a год ago. How are Ты to know if my feelings towards it have changed или not?

harry potter STINKS!!! and i was a Фан way before the movie came out and half the people in my school (who r fans) were too. and ive got a friend who is a Фан and she hasnt even seen the movie yet

I have to admit, I didn't read all comments, just the original post by 'renrae' and I wasn't a Фан of Twilgiht until the films came out -no! Lol. but I've followed Harry Potter since день one. :-)

i was a twilight Фан before the movie, too.

TRUE!!!!!!SO TRUE!!!

I give up. Ты people (renrae, november99, bbshipper...) win. This fight`s been going on for far too long, and I just give up. I`ve already apoligized for some things, but I am sorry for everything I сказал(-а) that was mean, или possibly, immature. Ты win. Congratulations. But to be honest, I don`t even know what the hell the fight`s about anymore (or how it started). I mean, we all agree about the answer to this question, so forgive me if I can`t quite understand why you`re fighting, или how this fight started. That`s all. I have nothing else to say. Only that I resign/remove myself from this fight/war/battle.

That is just a matter of opinion.

lies. There ARE vamps in HP. And they are COOL vamps. no sparklypoos for us!

'r-pattz' thank Ты for posting this, I've always wanted to know where she got her idea from :)

Mrs-Grint, no, his name's Sanguini, and from what I remember from Harry Potter Lexicon, the meaning of his name has 'blood' in it.

Hear, hear!

agreeing. But, labi-has-cold, Ты keep saying you're getting out. Dude, seriously, we get it XD

Just had to put it here, TeamEdward сказал(-а) that Twilight won nest book of the год at Kid's Choice Awards. THe Kid's Choice Awards is a voting competition. When it's something like that, whoever wins is the most popular, not techincally the best,

actually, there are quite a few vampire books. But, I'll agree that although Twilight probably did ruin the image of Вампиры and did several other things, it did not copy from harry potter.

im getting out of this fight not, i would like to appologse to anyone i have insulted или offended, i honestly didnt mean too. i respect that everyone is different, were all entitled to out own opinon and to like different things without getting bashed and yelled at if for. so we can agree to disagree on our thoughts about twilight and its characters and everything! thats fine, we should all be able to voice our opinion on things in a civil, friendly manner, and im soryy to anyone who i called names или was mean to while on here.. i got a bit worked up defending Друзья and retaleating to things others sad, but i dont want to fight anymore and im sick of coming on here and getting angry so im sorry and i respect everyones opnion..:)

How is Twilight a romeo and Juliet story? Just curious, because it didn't come across to me as that.

I do beleive the original post, Twilight is a Romeo and Juliet Любовь story, as are many Любовь stories in our contemporary literature, but I think that Twilight could be acused of playing upon girls emotions, I mean come on, do Ты know a guy THAT amazing? Guys are only humans and shouldn't feel inferior to a fictional character. Don't get me wrong though. I Любовь TWILIGHT :) but have been a Фан of Harry Potter since день one.

Twilight hasnt messed up my emotions, and how do people know it has?

In my opinion! LOL

im getting out of this fight not, i would like to appologse to anyone i have insulted или offended, i honestly didnt mean too. i respect that everyone is different, were all entitled to out own opinon and to like different things without getting bashed and yelled at if for. so we can agree to disagree on our thoughts about twilight and its characters and everything! thats fine, we should all be able to voice our opinion on things in a civil, friendly manner, and im soryy to anyone who i called names или was mean to while on here.. i got a bit worked up defending Друзья and retaleating to things others sad, but i dont want to fight anymore and im sick of coming on here and getting angry so im sorry and i respect everyones opnion..:)

Ты guys, I really don't think Ты should be using chatspeak if Ты want people to take Ты seriously. No offense.

Hear, hear!

Why isn't it original??

I no i dnt get it!!!

Ive read all the HP and its еще about a boy finding himself...and the only "love" is just the friendship love....nothing like the Любовь between Edward and Bella.

Yep. Hermione and Ron are just friends. So're Harry and Ginny.//sarcasm

Soo .. it dsnt mean its a copy cat!

Yeah. When my neighbor first moved here (he's Australian), I forced him to give me the definition of everything Australian he said.

im getting out of this fight not, i would like to appologse to anyone i have insulted или offended, i honestly didnt mean too. i respect that everyone is different, were all entitled to out own opinon and to like different things without getting bashed and yelled at if for. so we can agree to disagree on our thoughts about twilight and its characters and everything! thats fine, we should all be able to voice our opinion on things in a civil, friendly manner, and im soryy to anyone who i called names или was mean to while on here.. i got a bit worked up defending Друзья and retaleating to things others sad, but i dont want to fight anymore and im sick of coming on here and getting angry so im sorry and i respect everyones opnion..:)

haha awsum!! :)

twilight really doesnt like harry potter also harry potter is a bit exaggerated and twilight is better . because that made lyke totall senc. <- OMG what a change!

She was being sarcastic.

Энджел (The hottewst vampire in the world. Not even sparkly!Edward can defeat his hottness. Because that is how hot he is!), from Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel, drank animal blood. The superpowers thing, not so much, but he had a сердце and didn't abuse his girlfriend. (Okay, that is debatable, but STILL!) We had an argument somewhere that talked about MANY different things that it looked like Steph had copied from. It seems like she took every superhero, vampire, and romance novel in history and then just melded it all together. BTW, I loooove your icon. :)) So, yeah, Twilight could have copied lots of things.

im getting out of this fight not, i would like to appologse to anyone i have insulted или offended, i honestly didnt mean too. i respect that everyone is different, were all entitled to out own opinon and to like different things without getting bashed and yelled at if for. so we can agree to disagree on our thoughts about twilight and its characters and everything! thats fine, we should all be able to voice our opinion on things in a civil, friendly manner, and im soryy to anyone who i called names или was mean to while on here.. i got a bit worked up defending Друзья and retaleating to things others sad, but i dont want to fight anymore and im sick of coming on here and getting angry so im sorry and i respect everyones opnion..:)

I give up. Ты people (renrae, november99, bbshipper...) win. This fight`s been going on for far too long, and I just give up. I`ve already apoligized for some things, but I am sorry for everything I сказал(-а) that was mean, или possibly, immature. Ты win. Congratulations. But to be honest, I don`t even know what the hell the fight`s about anymore (or how it started). I mean, we all agree about the answer to this question, so forgive me if I can`t quite understand why you`re fighting, или how this fight started. That`s all. I have nothing else to say. Only that I resign/remove myself from this fight/war/battle.

Jumping on the Комментарий bandwagon yet again.... I AGREE!

yeah many mnay times !

im getting out of this fight not, i would like to appologse to anyone i have insulted или offended, i honestly didnt mean too. i respect that everyone is different, were all entitled to out own opinon and to like different things without getting bashed and yelled at if for. so we can agree to disagree on our thoughts about twilight and its characters and everything! thats fine, we should all be able to voice our opinion on things in a civil, friendly manner, and im soryy to anyone who i called names или was mean to while on here.. i got a bit worked up defending Друзья and retaleating to things others sad, but i dont want to fight anymore and im sick of coming on here and getting angry so im sorry and i respect everyones opnion..:)

Well if we all agree?

Then... OK.

I give up. Ты people (renrae, november99, bbshipper...) win. This fight`s been going on for far too long, and I just give up. I`ve already apoligized for some things, but I am sorry for everything I сказал(-а) that was mean, или possibly, immature. Ты win. Congratulations. But to be honest, I don`t even know what the hell the fight`s about anymore (or how it started). I mean, we all agree about the answer to this question, so forgive me if I can`t quite understand why you`re fighting, или how this fight started. That`s all. I have nothing else to say. Only that I resign/remove myself from this fight/war/battle.

agreed :)

Actually, the plot was very clear from the begining in Harry Potter.

labi-has-ocd er...um... ok i guess, its just so Книги after all

Harry Potter has no story line?? XD lol. Ты made my day. ;) But however, I kinda like the idea of HP being an action или horror book... well... it's not completely wrong in a way...

ooh i Любовь LJ!!!

Just asking, beacsue some people think that Twilight copied HP, thats all

I'd like to point out that "beautiful" is your opinion. Not trying to start a fight.

^Yeah Tom Felton rocks :)

I did give Twilight a chance. It had many flaws, Mary Sue's, plot holes, flat characters, and was Edward was abusive. And personally, I'm not too obsessed with either. I have other things to do, these were just Книги I liked/disliked.

Sweet_But_Dead i still like Edward too!!! :) He's fictional after all and thats ok..

I agree...

Did Ты know some people here were born on Sicilly and speak fluent Italian? And why say they both are good, if Ты then insult Harry Potter?

Oh, yeah, Книги were better. I pressed "enter" too soon, sorry!

LOL Italians

Not at die hard Фан of either. I just hate Twilight.

Haha Meyerama, Ты Комментарий made me smile :) LOL i guess we are funny, but it was stupid

hahahaha ino i was pissing myself at this XDXDXD

I agree.. :) xx

haha :).. when u say elders, it makes 'us' sound like 60 год olds.. and dont worry i can read what Ты are saying, use chatspeak if ya wont :)

bahaha

hahaha olamba...

"In the end, only one will go down in history..." (GoF) :)

good ans

Whatever.

whatever

Haha :)

lolzz thats sooo true and lilyallen i Любовь Ты it was good of Ты to ans the twilight haters like this they dont get it

I think Ты guys are the ones that don't get it... We all know there is no comparision... It would be insulting if there was...

Ты dont have to use fuck sweety Ты can just say simply ''NO'' no offence

chagrin no offence, but Ты have kinda changed :/

lolzz am sorry but i know felicity

How was i insulting him?

uhhh youre in Любовь with a fhuckin fictional character xD and Ты think twilight Фаны are dumb

wtf no. I never сказал(-а) I was in Любовь with Harry Potter. I was referring to HP books.

By comparing him to Twilight, of course.

LOL