Ответить на этот вопрос

Гарри Поттер против Сумерек Вопрос

Why didn't Jasper kill Bella in Twilight?

On page 461, Edward tells Bella, "After I pulled [James] off you, Emmett and Jasper took care of him." This implies that Emmett and Jasper were in the studio. Bella was severely injured, both in her leg and her head before James bit her. In New Moon, Jasper tries to kill her over a paper cut. So why didn't he at the studio?
*
I'm someone can give me a legitimate answer, instead of "Because Meyer's a sucky writer."
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
Good question.....
Karipoof posted Больше года
 bri-marie posted Больше года
next question »

Гарри Поттер против Сумерек  Лучший ответ

GemonkDruid said:
Jasper was wearing a noseplug.

... What? It never сказал(-а) he wasn't.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Hahaha!
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
LOL Perfect answer :P
Ms_Mea posted Больше года
*
Nice XD
xDark_Angelx posted Больше года
*
Haha...awesome answer....lol....lmao! :D
Karipoof posted Больше года
next question »

Ответы

Lord-Voldemort said:
Maybe he was too preoccupied with James? или maybe Emmett was holding him back? или he was too scared of Edward?

I can't think of any logical reasons, but I think if Jasper had killed her there, the Книги would have been much better :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Haha. But the whole "him being afraid of Edward" doesn't make sense either. If he's that afraid, why'd he go after her in New Moon. And, also, they had to drag him out in New Moon (I don't think it was just Emmett).
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
I don't even pretend to understand Twilight :P
Lord-Voldemort posted Больше года
*
Yes the Книги would have been way better if he had killed her then......
Karipoof posted Больше года
boolander25 said:
I can't think of any logical reason for why he didn't and I know Ты don't want someone to say "Oh, Smeyer sucks at writing", and I'm not going to say that. This kind of Вопрос can pop up in anything, not just Twilight so I'm not going to say Smeyer is a crappy writer, just this is probably a mistake anyone could make. But honestly, I have no idea why he wouldn't have killed her. Maybe because Edward would've protected her if Jasper had tried?
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Edward being there didn't stop him in New Moon.
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
Well maybe the combined force of Alice, Emmett and Carlisle stopped him. I don't know.
boolander25 posted Больше года
*
They were all there in New Moon too.
venvargie posted Больше года
mdedrick said:
When I read it, I figured that he had been taken outside. Only in the film does it say/show that he was killed in the studio.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Yours makes way еще sense than mine LOL
boolander25 posted Больше года
*
The way I read it was "I realized James had bitten Ты and handed him over to Emmett and Jasper to take care of." I can't believe that Edward realized she was that badly injured and bitten, and walked James outside to Emmett and Jasper.
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
Actually, it does say the fight continued in the studio. On page 453, Bella describes hearing "snapping" sounds and a "high keening sound suddenly breaking off."
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
What she's hearing is Jasper and Emmett ripping James to peices.
bri-marie posted Больше года
cullenROCKz said:
Thats a good question.. :) This is just my opinion.. It could be her emotional aura.. It was so painful at the studio.. This could have prevented him from going to her.. At the same time, the revenge and hatred coming from James would have made him pay attention to him rather than Bella...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
But wouldn't those feelings (Bella's pain and Jame's anger) have made him еще unfocased on controlling his instincts?
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
*combined
bri-marie posted Больше года
*
Yeah.. ok however, put aside his aura and lets think about his thoughts... He could have been determined to not drink her blood.. He was protecting her a couple of hours ago.. It was his responsibility so maybe he still felt obliged to destroy the very thing that threatened her..
cullenROCKz posted Больше года
yemi_hikari said:
Jasper's mind was preoccupied with fighting and killing someone else, thus satisfing the killing desire.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
SpeedyGonzalez said:
Perhaps Jasper expected that Bella will be hurt and possibly bleeding so he knew what was coming so it was easier to resist. In New Moon it was completely unexpected so he just went for her without thinking about it.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
i-am-mariella said:
I didn't really concentrate Чтение the Книги but I guess I back up what everyone else has said; Jasper must have been pre-occupied fighting James (I think that's the right one?) He can control emotions so maaaaaaybe.... his emotions can also control him?
Wow. Pyschology right there, guys.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
LifesGoodx3 said:
Well, I've never noticed this before. The best thing I can come up with, is that Jasper was too occupied trying to kill James to notice Bella was bleeding so badly. Ты know, an adrenaline rush? In New Moon, there was no threat nearby, and he probably was not prepared to control himself if Bella was bleeding. Maybe he knew Bella would be bleeding in Twilight, so he could mentally prepare himself to deal with the smell. In New Moon, he wouldn't be able to mentally prepare himself.

That's the best I've got.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
lakota_spirit said:
Because there wouldn't have been a sequel. Would have made a good ending though.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
DracoLuver said:
The way I see it, I think Jasper was preoccupied.
Remember how when James was tracking Bella, he didn't drink any other blood? I think Edward did mention that when fighting или drinking, your mind goes a bit blank and that's the only thing Ты focus on. In Short секунда Life of Bree Tanner, Bree сказал(-а) she "shut her mind off" and was a tracker now. I think this could be applied to Jasper too. He was too busy dealing with James to notice the stench of the blood, and when he burned James, the smoke made Bella hard to smell.
I could be wrong, but that's how I percieved it. :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
jodarchy said:
surely the answer is because if he had twilight would have been over and s meyer would have made less money and they wouldnt have had enough stuff to make lots of Фильмы and make lots of money LOL
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »