Гарри Поттер против Сумерек Club
Присоединиться
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by cinnominbubble
20
Logical reasons...
why Harry Potter v.s Twilight

*WARNING SPOILERS*

Hi! I'm Cinnominbubble and I have noticed the war between fandoms have been going on for a while with no clear outcome. There is a reason to this-We are stubborn. Twihards want to stick up for Stephanie Meyer, whilst Potterheads want to do the same for J. K. Rowling. But, I have noticed something. Many of our reasonings aren't exactly logical. I mean, not to be offensive, some of our strongest points are downright idiotic!(from both sides) I'd like to come up with some smarter points to help people see our side of the story, whatever that side may be! It would do well to expect еще of these in the future because of all the idiocy going around.(Again, not to be offensive)

I am a Фан of Harry Potter but I'd like to acknowledge both sides to the story. People will be yelling at me at the end of this, so in advance, I say sorry for anything offensive.

-First off, I'd just like to say to Ты twihards, Harry Potter came first in 1998, whereas Twilight came out in 2005, I believe. So J.K Rowling did not copy Stephanie Meyer. I am in possession of both these series' and though Jacob and Sirius both have the same last name, and can both transform into dog-like figures, that is where the similarities stop. Sirius Black is a prisoner escaped from the wizard prison, Azkaban, where he was placed under false pretences. He is an old friend of Harry's parents, and is also Harry's godfather. He is only able to become a dog because he is an animagus, a witch или wizard with the ability to transform into a certain animal at will. He became an Animagus illegally in order to help his friend, Remus Lupin, who was a werewolf, through those bleak nights where there was a full moon. Волколаки only attack humans and so Sirius was only безопасно, сейф while in his dog form. Jacob Black on the other hand, is not a real werewolf. In Breaking Dawn, his species is called Shape-shifters as Aro says himself. He is only a shape-shifter because it runs in his family and... Yah. That subject all cleared up? I hope so.

-I have heard people saying that Twilight is a better Любовь story but there's an easy answer to that... Harry Potter isn't a Любовь story. Sure, if Ты are into that genre, go for Twilight, but is not fair to say that Harry Potter is a bad book just because it's not a romance novel.

-Yah, ok the Harry Potter characters have flaws! Bella and Rosalie seem to be the only ones with flaws in the entire series, Bella's being her disability to understand what goes on around her sometimes, and Rosalie's being over-the-top-jeolosy... Those don't even seem like flaws! Harry's cast on the other hand, has plenty of flaws. Hermione with her buck-teeth and bad posture, Mrs. Weasley with her over-protectiveness et cetera. But as someone in history said, Flaws are what give your character, well, character! There are plenty of people in Harry Potter with less flaws(Cho, Cedric, et al.) but flaws none the less. So again, if Ты prefer Книги where Ты characters are close to perfect, be my guest and read Twilight. I personally found the characters еще relatable,(mainly Hermione) with their flaws and anger management issues.

Now I know I haven't addressed most of the major questions, but I honestly can't remember anymore(it's 10:06 PM, I just came Главная from piano! Cut me some slack please...wow I whine a lot!) Feel free to give me feedback, Вопросы and requests for my Далее article(this is my first for Logical Reasons) Go ahead, tell me how bad it is, cant get any worse than what I (or Ralph[inside joke]) tell myself:D I will Редактировать to accommodate all new questions, unless I get an overflow of questions. I will create an Статья for any point, if logical and/or if I understand/know of it. Since this is my first, I don't expect much. Just, if Ты have any negative comments(Twihards, if I wrote something wrong etc.)tell me in non Трофеи form(don't be angry)

Yours in demigodishness, and all that. Peace Out!
Cinnominbubble >.<
posted by harrypotterbest
8
Dolores Jane Umbridge… can ANYONE forgive her? And yet, despite being so horrendously evil, she is a very interesting character.
She is very loyal, because we know how she remained on Fudge’s side through the whole dilemma. She is also very easy to hate, for she gave Harry countless detentions for telling the truth. We know very little about Dolores; surely Rowling knows more. She has always planned her characters to the death – one reason why Harry Potter makes a very interesting read.
Back on the topic of Umbridge, we have to accept that she could have had a childhood like Snape –...
continue reading...
added by KateKicksAss
1
added by youknowit101
18
added by lakota_spirit
2
added by lilcherrywine
added by lilcherrywine
2
added by KateKicksAss
1
added by hollywoodluv
Source: unkown
34
added by mr-cullen
added by TeamSiriusBlack
17
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
3
added by lakota_spirit
17
PREFACE - THE JEALOUS-FALLACY IN ITS MANY FORMS

Alright, I have already dissected one very common fallacy invoked by some Twilight Фаны and a few Harry Potter Фаны as well, the Edward-fallacy. I shall not discuss that one but instead I will be moving on and examine another common fallacy invoked by some fans, using what I believe is the two most common forms of it.

"YOU ARE JUST JEALOUS, THEREFORE YOUR ARGUMENT IS INVALID"

Firstly, let us examine the logical reasoning behind "You are just jealous, therefore your argument is invalid".
It is invoked when any Фан post an argument and employes this...
continue reading...
added by LoveforSeverus
10
added by youknowit101
Source: andthepixiebroughthope@tumblr
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
2
added by KateKicksAss
Source: The Internet
3
added by KateKicksAss
Source: The Internet
4
added by Renesmee_XD
Source: Found it heretwitpic.com/23svxa
6