Гарри Поттер против Сумерек Club
Присоединиться
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
I'm adressing the rabid Twilight Фаны if they would listen. I'm also adressing the common Фаны of both sides of this debate.

There are some things one may and may not do in a formal Дебаты unless one wants to look like - pardon the language - a freaking donkey.

Nr 01: One may not argue against the debaters points by attacking him или her. This is called argumentum ad hominem and is a fallacy. For example: If I am to argue that free elections is wrong and states that the arguer is an imbecile that does not deserve the right to vote, then I have committed a severe personal attack and will be frowned...
continue reading...
posted by Athiya
Many of Ты might have noticed that the golden trio from Harry Potter (Harry, Ron, and Hermione) had always been paired up to fight with the not-so-golden trio of Twilight (Edward, Jacob, and Bella). Now, XDRoseLuvsHP had pointed out a great deal on why HP trio would win against the Twilight's (you can find it link), so I figured perhaps it's time for the villains to battle.

My first thought was off course, James and Voldemort; but then, it didn't seem fair on the Twilight side. James was not a very good villain; his character was poorly underdeveloped and his powers weren't very outstanding...
continue reading...
This is a (long) rebuttal to KatiiCullen94's argument, the Название of which is in is article's title. (Though you've probably all seen that by now.) I haven't included her points in this, so it will be necessary to read her Статья first.

1. The majority of people in this world cannot relate to Bella. Tell me, how many people can go to a new school and automatically be the prettiest and most Популярное girl there? How many girls can say that they have FIVE males lusting after them?

Bella does care for people other than herself - her boyfriend. That's it. She was perfectly happy to hurt her father...
continue reading...
This is my last Статья and as Ты may know I never really came here to argue, just to figure out what was going on in Twilight-Haters heads.


Bella- Whiny and Moany ?
Everyone says that Bella is so whiney and the point is so what if she ? I am sure if we went into your heads ,you would be as moany as her. She complains about the attention she is recieving from boys. I would too it would totally creep me out if suddenly I moved to a new school and everybody likes me.
The friend problem: Jessica is not a good friend after being to 9 schools so far I have met people like this and only can I comment...
continue reading...
posted by DivyaHarry
Firstly, this is not my article. I found it over the internet and pasted it here because I find it really hard to believe that there are people like this in the world who are completely ignorant или just plain stupid.

The e-mail was apparently from Kayla Patterson, a die hard Twilight/Taylor Lautner Фан upset about Universal Pictures ripping off the werewolf idea from Twilight.

To whom this may concern:

This movie was a complete waste and I feel that it offends ALL Twilight Фаны around the world, that including myself. For one, it was a COMPLETE remaking of the волк Pack from the Twilight Saga:...
continue reading...
Hmm... this could take a while. Haha, I have a lot of reasons for my strong dislike of Twilight. Before I start, I'd just like to explain that I was once a Twilight fan, so I've read all the Книги and stuff, but I just can't stand it anymore. Therefore, I can give a еще complete explanation of my views. Sorry if it's really ridiculously long.

First reason I hate Twilight: the media. Twilight, in all honesty, isn't a great book. I have read worse Книги (though not many... Twilight was pretty bad). However, if Twilighters and Twilight Статьи and such weren't all "OMG ITS THE MOST AMAZING SERIES...
continue reading...
Voldemort is notorious for his fear of death. To avoid death, he is willing to kill innocent people and destroy his very soul.

Now, everyone with any sense knows that Bella is a Mary Sue, and Stephenie Meyer desperately wants to be Bella. I even personally know quite a few Twilight Фаны who realize and accept this. And what does Bella want? She wants to become a vampire.

Here is some commonly known knowledge about Вампиры (according to Meyer):

-Kill innocents for survival
-Practically immortal
-Possibly lose their souls, though this is not known for sure

We see Voldemort killing innocents for survival....
continue reading...
Okay now I will begin off with something that has really begin to get on my nerve. How Twilight Фаны write out their Статьи on why they like Twilight. Not just Статьи other things too. I will give Ты and example of one: "For people.....blah blah blah." Like these. Who are they directing these too exactly? I know some the Название says it, but they expect only those sort of people to respond. Pff yeah right. I see that kind of Название I go in and see what kind moronic things they have to say.

Most Twilight Фаны I see on this site lack the skills in proper grammar. Okay first if Ты ever want...
continue reading...
This Статья was actually wriiten by an ex-twilighter(iloveyoudarling), not me, and i dont like the way she wrote it, cuz it is kinda rude, but i Опубликовано it so that maybe some twilighters here could consider giving harry potter a chance because the Статья proves that even though Ты Любовь twilight there COULD be a better book out there:
Dear Twilight fans,

I was Ты one day. Addicted to Twilight and couldnt ever stop Чтение it even if i had already read it 4 times. But trust me on this one will you. READ ANOTHER BOOOK!!! AFTER Ты DO THAT TWILIGHT WILL SEEM LIKE A STUPID ROMANCE STORY.

After...
continue reading...
So I have heard/read a LOT of arguments over this topic, and I find it ridiculous. Here are some reasons why they can't be compared with each other:

1- Письмо styles. Rowling writes in a descriptive third-person, whereas Meyer writes in a first-person account of a seventeen год old girl. Ты can't expect Bella to talk like a professional poet of some sort, I doubt many average teenage girls do that.

2- Plot. Harry Potter is mainly about wizards and fighting. Twilight is about Вампиры and romance... Totally the same (Major burning sarcasm).

3- Audience. Harry Potter is aimed for children. Before...
continue reading...
Both twilight and harry potter are very successful, especially among teenagers. Some people keep arguing about which is better, though in my opinion, THEY SHOULDN'T BE COMPARED!

Now, i have to admit i Любовь both series! I'd say harry potter is unisex and appropriate for all ages, whilst twilight adresses mainly to teenage girls. HP talks about friendship and love, while twilight is еще romantic! Also, hp gives lessons of life, although maybe in some cases, i would prefer Чтение twilight.

Finally, They are both written by two very talented and imaginative writers, j.k rowling and stephenie meyer. They wrote these Книги to give teens (and not only) inspiration and time of happiness. So, if Ты don't like one of these two series, don't blame them! We can't all have the same tastes!
I haven't read Midnight Sun so this Статья is from the 'Bella-point-of-view' books. Edward has been single for over 100 years. While this sounds riddikulus, funny sometimes, it somewhat makes him attractive (Twihards: attractive personality). His 'waiting-for-the-right-person' aura makes him mysterious. I couldn't care if Edward was played by Brad Pitt, Robert Pattinson или Dustin Diamond. So for now I am going to set aside the looks, sparkles, stalking, virginity, erections and anything that confirms или contradicts his vampire-ness and dissect his raw personality.

Twilight:
The first thing...
continue reading...
First part
link

She gestured to a row of wooden
chairs against the wall. The looked like they belonged with someone’s dinning room
table.
“Okay,” I agreed. I walked over to the chairs and sat right in the middle,
suddenly wishing I had a book. I hadn’t read anything for a while, outside of school.
And even then, when some ridiculous Любовь story was part of the curriculum, I would
cheat with cliff notes. It was a relief to be working on Animal Farm now. But there had
to be other безопасно, сейф books. Political thrillers. Murder mysteries. Grisly murders were no
problem; just as long as there was no starry-eyed,...
continue reading...
posted by victorodonnell
The World is flat!
    Well, I know Ты Вопрос my sanity, now. Obviously, the world is round and that’s a proven fact, from the moment Galileo stepped out of his ship. And now, there’s a Вопрос again. Is the World really round? I hate that word, really. The word which gives rise to a lot of Вопросы and seeks for explanations.
    ‘Imagination is еще important than knowledge,’ сказал(-а) a wise man once. And, it’s true. Well, Ты need not be aware of the complications of four-dimensional Космос fabric to accept this theory. What all Ты need to...
continue reading...
Вопросы Фаны and Ответы from Болталка people



Who is better: Harry или Edward? Why?

A: I think Harry is better. He has flaws in his character that make him relatable. He puts himself in danger and sacrifices himself for his friends. He may be a wizard, but he feels what normal kids feel: anger, betrayal, sadness, loss, joy, relief, confidence, and bravery.
-anonymous HP fan
A2-Edward. Edward would die for Bella, and tries to protect her in any way he can. He doesn't give up on her even when he hears she is with Jacob and saves her innumerable times.
Anonymous T fan.


Quidditch или Vampire Baseball?...
continue reading...
posted by ImBooOK
Before Ты read this, i must tell Ты something a little important. Ты may dilike my opinions, and i can deal with it. But this is just what i think, and why i choose both books.

Lets get down to the movie versus books.
Im talking Книги here people, not the movie stars who play them, not witch guy is hotter, who has еще abs. NOT talking about that. Im speaking about how good both Twilight and Harry Potter (or other way around because i have seen Фаны fight about who i type in first...witch in truth is really childish) is.
Harry Potter. Its a very detailed and continuous story. I like how the...
continue reading...
posted by sapherequeen
Hi, everyone :)

I first want to apologize for my leaving, and never telling anyone that I decided to go, why I wanted to go, any good-bye's etc. It's been something that has bothered me for a little while, and I truly apologize for that.

A friend of mine told me that someone asked about me on here, so I thought that I could write an Статья explaining why I left and why I decided to come back.

You see, around the time I stopped coming here, I was having problems with my life outside Fanpop. I don't want to talk about it, but I will say that it had a lot to do with friends, family, and school and...
continue reading...
PART FOUR:

Okay. Okay. I am a perfectly calm boy yes. That’s it. I will make myself forget what has just happened. There. All good. I forgot. (OH HERE LET ME HELP: HARRY, Ты JUST SET A SNAKE ON THAT JUSTIN FLICKEY KID AND NOW THE ENTIRE SCHOOL THINKS YOURE THE AIR OF SLYTHERIN!!!! ) Oh yeah. Thank Ты Emily. (YOURE WELCOME ) anyways because Emily is so eager to talk I should just let her share her point of view on things. Oh and Emily, its spelled h-e-i-r not a-i-r. A-i-r is what your head is full of. ( FINE, AND BTW Ты OWE ME A GALLION FOR THAT SMILEY. ANYWAYS, PEACE IS Актёрское искусство FUNNY, SHES...
continue reading...
Once there was a young teenage girl named Hadley. She was walking around at the local библиотека looking for some new Книги to read. While she was there, Hadley stumbled upon something. It was a black hardback book with two hands holding an яблоко with the word, "Twilight" on it. This interested Hadley and she decided to buy it. When she did, she got hooked. Hadley bought the other three Книги and after she read them, became a Twitard. She even started to think that Harry Potter and all the other Фэнтези Книги she liked weren't as good as Twilight. She drew pictures of the characters, wrote fangirl...
continue reading...
Alright, part II is here! It's still pretty bad writing, but it gets better.

Dear Peace's Diary,
Peace blacked out. I don't know why. She just did. She’s just laying down in the middle of the common room she looks kind of dead.
Me Crabbe and goyle are taking her to Madam Pomfrey.
~Draco Malfoy





I visited peace in the hospital wing. She still isn’t awake yet. Carsilile сказал(-а) she will be alright in a couple of days. But carsilile seemed a little nervous. Edward сказал(-а) it was just because I was giving him the "don’t Ты dare lay a tooth on my best friend" look. I dint know what happened, but I...
continue reading...