I think that everyone is making a big deal over it.

-_-
seriously people, there are better competitions
simpsons vs family guy, maybe?

yes.--It's.obvious.what.the.better.one.is
but.I.don't.care

(My.spacebar.isn't.working)

Maybe because both are very famous!

yea but both of the fandomes are amazing and I think that people are making a big deal about it! Harry Potter and Twilight auothers are amazing and geat!

No, it's only online that people argue over this. In the real world most people don't know what the hell twilight is.

Yes. And it's all very unnecessary. It's obvious that Harry POtter's better.

But I don't care. It's all in good fun........well......most of it.
x

Twilight and HP aren't the same category. They are both famous and that's all.
I like these books but not the same way.

I am 100% with alkonyat's comment

Yes!agree with alkonyat!XD

Who was the douchebag who put "Move over Harry Potter" on the back of Breaking Dawn. They shouldn't be compared, yes, but they also shouldn't be posting untrue crap like that on the back of bad books.

Sorry *calm* the whole thing is stupid but I like the debate (when it stays friendly and civil). There's nothing wrong with that.

A big what? You didn't finish the question.

It's more the media in my opinion. They're the ones who sparked the whole disptute. I agree with ToyletGnome, I was so pissed when I saw that on the back of the book.

Here's my thing with this;

I don't think Harry Potter's the best. I also don't think Twilight's the best. There are no facts stating that one is better then the other. Because in the end, it's all gonna be based on OPINIONS. And opinions are not facts.

I sometimes think this debate (and in some situations, war) is exhausting, because there isn't going to be a concrete solution. It's based on what we all think, not how the books are written, how the authors write the stories, the characters, the characters' love for one another, the plot etc.

As some have said before; Sometimes we can only agree to disagree. :)

as HP is in a league of its own and in a few years it will be twilight who??? where as HP will live on :)

Well, it's pretty obvious HP won this thing so...
And if the Twilight fans are going to attack us for not liking Twilight or saying that it's not the best book in the world, and say HP isn't very good, well, we have to defend ourselves, don't we?

I didn't understand the question.

Yes, but it's honestly something fun to debate about.

And I love it.