Ответить на этот вопрос

Гарри Поттер Вопрос

Conspiracy Alert! Do Ты think Cornelius помадка, выдумка chose the unorthodox punishment of the dementor's Kiss to finish off Barty Crouch Jr. so he couldn't tell everyone Voldemort was back?

Contrary to common belief, The dementor's Kiss was not the usual way to punish someone. But помадка, выдумка had his bodyguard dementor finish Barty off right away? Did he have another motive?
 Conspiracy Alert! Do Ты think Cornelius помадка, выдумка chose the unorthodox punishment of the dementor's Kiss to finish off Barty Crouch Jr. so he couldn't tell everyone Voldemort was back?
 Unspeakable posted Больше года
next question »

Гарри Поттер Ответы

BlackHound said:
"Conspiracy Alert! Do Ты think Cornelius помадка, выдумка chose the unorthodox punishment of the dementor's Kiss to finish off Barty Crouch Jr. so he couldn't tell everyone Voldemort was back?"

Oh, absolutely. помадка, выдумка was paranoid and desperate to keep himself in power.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
i agree
twilighter4evr posted Больше года
LadyNottingham said:
That's exactly the reason why he did finish Barty. It was easy to have a Death-Eater escapee (he had been locked up in Azkaban) being Kissed off.

As помадка, выдумка could not do the same with Harry and Dumbledore, he tried to make Harry appear as a liar and Dumbledore as someone that had Остаться в живых his marbles.

As Remus put it in the OotP movie (I know, it's not canon) : Fear can make people do stupid things.

But whatever efforts one may put into hiding the truth, the truth will out one день или the other.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
simpleplan said:
I do belive he did. помадка, выдумка did not want to be the minister if Voldemort was back. Fear makes people do stupid things.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Jamie_Blue said:
I didn't even know that Barty Crouch was kissed by the dementors! Where did it say that (out of curiosity)? But yeah, помадка, выдумка was just in denial and he didn't want to be pulled out of his lovely fantasy. I think.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Yep! Chapter 36 of Goblet of Fire!
Unspeakable posted Больше года
Rodrick12 said:
Good point.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
LiseBrouillette said:
That, of course, plus he did not want the mess about Bertha Jorkins and Barty Crouch Snr's murders, and Crouch Jnr's escape from Azkaban to come out in the open.

Rita Skeeter would have had a field день with this. A big Название in the Daily Prophet would have been a bit embarassing.

помадка, выдумка was always very self-absorbed and power-hungry, he had come to fall in Любовь with his position, and his first priority was always to cover his own ass.


select as best answer
posted ·6 дней назад 
next question »