Гарри Поттер

Ответить на этот вопрос

Гарри Поттер Вопрос

Is Penelope Clearwater a muggle-born или a half-blood?

Is Penelope Clearwater a muggle-born или a half-blood?
In COS Penelope was one of the last victims to be petrified by the Basilisk. That would mean that she was a muggle-born. Then in DH when Hermione, along with Harry and Ron were caught by Snatchers they lied about who they were. The name Hermione chose to use was Penelope Clearwater and сказал(-а) that she was a half-blood. The snatcher then сказал(-а) that she was not on the Список of muggle-borns. So is Penelope a muggle-born или a half-blood?

I have always been confused about this! :)

*
I just remembered something else! In COS Tom Riddle tells Harry: "She (Ginny) set the serpent of Slytherin on four Mudbloods, and the Squib's cat." Hermione, Colin and Justin are definitely muggle-born, so this leaves Nearly Headless Nick and Penelope. Nearly Headless Nick could be muggle-born too. So who was the fourth "mudblood" victim? Penelope или Nearly Headless Nick?
linhousepotter posted Больше года
 linhousepotter posted Больше года
next question »

Гарри Поттер Ответы

othobsessed92 said:
She's a muggleborn. They make that pretty obvious in COS. In DH Hermione just сказал(-а) the first name that would come to her head and then lied about her blood line cause telling the snatchers that she was a muggleborn would have gotten her killed right there. But the real Penelope is a muggleborn because the basilik ONLY attacked "mudbloods"
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
yeah, Ты are right. It's just that I got a bit confused in DH. Thanks for the answer! :)
linhousepotter posted Больше года
*
She wouldn't be killed on the spot, one of the snatchers was muggleborn himself!
martemora15 posted Больше года
jdsfjdiosa said:
Penelope Clearwater was never meant as a victim because she was a half-blood. Hermione, leaving the библиотека and knowing about the Basilisk, ran into Penelope and told her she should check around the corner with a mirror to be safe. Hermione was the intended victim (at least in the book, I don't think Penelope was even attacked in the movie)
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
tweetygirl9786 said:
She is half. It states in the 7th book that Hermoine claims to be her and later she explains she chose to fake Penelope because her mother was a muggle and father was a wizard :)
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
ScottishChic said:
I think she's half. Cause the Basilask didnt only attack Mudbloods it attacked Nearly Headless Nick. And in the last book they do say she is a Half- Blood otherwise she would have been on the lists
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
yeah, it makes sense too. I don't know what to think anymore. Thanks for answering!
linhousepotter posted Больше года
*
Lol. I think Ты would be able to look up the correct answer on Wikipedia. And you're welcome about answering. Glad to help. xx
ScottishChic posted Больше года
BlackHound said:
It's not specified.

link
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!