I think there's something fishy to it. Because it's horribly unreliable and through that horribly unfair and useless.
Some theorize that magical children are born with the Trace but I don't think so because the Книги talk about it as something that is put on people, as in a charm. And in magic it should be possible to make a еще specifically effective charm. Even the Magic Quill at Hogwarts lists the names of every magical inhdividual born. The Trace should be working the samw way but it isn't.
I've racked my brain with the Trace matters after I (in the Ответы part of thsi club) brought up the Вопрос whether it remains active until the 17th birthday even if a minor drops out of Hogwarts years before he/she turns 17. (Because the Trace seems to be placed only on verified Hogwarts students to begin with (as Hermione received nno warnings though she studied spells before she began Hogwarts) and expulsion seems to be the worst thing they'll do if taking action seems needed. As in the Trace seems to very strongly relate to literally studying at Hogwarts, so I wondered if they'd remove it when a person chooses to drop out.)
But then I figured it really doesn't make much of a difference if it is или isn't, because 95% of minors can get away with magic even with the Trace on. To some extent, everyone can.
Because if I've understood corerectly...To the Ministry of Magic, the Trace can only detect:
1. that magic has been performed nearby an underage wizard или a witch
2. which charm/spell/curse was used
3. the location
But it does not detect who the underage wizard was. They can only try to figure it out by the location.
This leads into it being completely impossible for the MoM to blame a minor living with one или еще magical adults, and thus (supposing the parents are not around или just dont' care) for the minor to perform any amount of magic at their own house without any consequences. But minors living with muggle adults are totally opposite case.
And a minor could walk into the area of сказал(-а) kind of minor and perform magic there, and this innocent minor would get the blame! (Much like what happened with Dobby the house-elf and Harry.)
And a minor could throw charms, even in the presence of a muggle, in any location that has numerous underage wizards living there, and then just flee from the crime scene before someone from the Ministry gets there to try and identify who it was. The Ministry would have hard time finding out who of the numerous minors living on the area, is guilty, if any as it mightr as well have been an adult in the company of a minor. And even if it was the unknown minor around whom the magic happened, they could've used someone else's wand and thus if the Ministry actually took time to go through all the houses with a minor living in, they'd never find out who it was или might end up accusing the wrong person.
And seeing to the fact that totally muggle-free areas are rare, it is likely there usually do live еще than one underage wizard или a witch on one muggle-habited area. Which again deeply affects the chances of the finger being pointed at the right minor, if the magic happened outdoors.
They obviously rely much on the parents enforcing the rules on their children for the sake of the secrecy and the child's safety. But if the Ministry really wanted to give their two cents to the cuase...Why did they make the Trace so gawddamn vague instead of making it detect the sourcerer's indetity? That way the effect would be maximum and it would be catching equally everyone. The way the Trace is, doesn't offer any real help whatsoever but on the contrary it picks on those and only those children with less pure blood and/or not so fortunate Главная location. And even if it did offer a little help, it's minus aspects are far еще numerous/significant.
Thus, to me it seems that with the Trace, the Ministry does not have the childrens' best interest in mind, nor do they care about the secrecy that much.
It seems to have a touch of attitude problem towards muggle-borns and favorism of purebloods and half-bloods. And also of a lust for power, (hence the 'we can accuse, warn and punish children based on our vague assumptions, and Ты have to live with it because there's no hihgher law to our society than us. Har-har-har!')
The law forbidding underage sourcery in presence of a muggle is of course all good and well and certainly out of right and respectable motives. But "the Trace" that supposedly enforces that law, really seems to be ill-motived and completely useless to far extent.
Do Ты think I'm on to something here, или that this is just Rowling's failure to pull together one aspect of her fictional world - или am I missing something crucial?
Some theorize that magical children are born with the Trace but I don't think so because the Книги talk about it as something that is put on people, as in a charm. And in magic it should be possible to make a еще specifically effective charm. Even the Magic Quill at Hogwarts lists the names of every magical inhdividual born. The Trace should be working the samw way but it isn't.
I've racked my brain with the Trace matters after I (in the Ответы part of thsi club) brought up the Вопрос whether it remains active until the 17th birthday even if a minor drops out of Hogwarts years before he/she turns 17. (Because the Trace seems to be placed only on verified Hogwarts students to begin with (as Hermione received nno warnings though she studied spells before she began Hogwarts) and expulsion seems to be the worst thing they'll do if taking action seems needed. As in the Trace seems to very strongly relate to literally studying at Hogwarts, so I wondered if they'd remove it when a person chooses to drop out.)
But then I figured it really doesn't make much of a difference if it is или isn't, because 95% of minors can get away with magic even with the Trace on. To some extent, everyone can.
Because if I've understood corerectly...To the Ministry of Magic, the Trace can only detect:
1. that magic has been performed nearby an underage wizard или a witch
2. which charm/spell/curse was used
3. the location
But it does not detect who the underage wizard was. They can only try to figure it out by the location.
This leads into it being completely impossible for the MoM to blame a minor living with one или еще magical adults, and thus (supposing the parents are not around или just dont' care) for the minor to perform any amount of magic at their own house without any consequences. But minors living with muggle adults are totally opposite case.
And a minor could walk into the area of сказал(-а) kind of minor and perform magic there, and this innocent minor would get the blame! (Much like what happened with Dobby the house-elf and Harry.)
And a minor could throw charms, even in the presence of a muggle, in any location that has numerous underage wizards living there, and then just flee from the crime scene before someone from the Ministry gets there to try and identify who it was. The Ministry would have hard time finding out who of the numerous minors living on the area, is guilty, if any as it mightr as well have been an adult in the company of a minor. And even if it was the unknown minor around whom the magic happened, they could've used someone else's wand and thus if the Ministry actually took time to go through all the houses with a minor living in, they'd never find out who it was или might end up accusing the wrong person.
And seeing to the fact that totally muggle-free areas are rare, it is likely there usually do live еще than one underage wizard или a witch on one muggle-habited area. Which again deeply affects the chances of the finger being pointed at the right minor, if the magic happened outdoors.
They obviously rely much on the parents enforcing the rules on their children for the sake of the secrecy and the child's safety. But if the Ministry really wanted to give their two cents to the cuase...Why did they make the Trace so gawddamn vague instead of making it detect the sourcerer's indetity? That way the effect would be maximum and it would be catching equally everyone. The way the Trace is, doesn't offer any real help whatsoever but on the contrary it picks on those and only those children with less pure blood and/or not so fortunate Главная location. And even if it did offer a little help, it's minus aspects are far еще numerous/significant.
Thus, to me it seems that with the Trace, the Ministry does not have the childrens' best interest in mind, nor do they care about the secrecy that much.
It seems to have a touch of attitude problem towards muggle-borns and favorism of purebloods and half-bloods. And also of a lust for power, (hence the 'we can accuse, warn and punish children based on our vague assumptions, and Ты have to live with it because there's no hihgher law to our society than us. Har-har-har!')
The law forbidding underage sourcery in presence of a muggle is of course all good and well and certainly out of right and respectable motives. But "the Trace" that supposedly enforces that law, really seems to be ill-motived and completely useless to far extent.
Do Ты think I'm on to something here, или that this is just Rowling's failure to pull together one aspect of her fictional world - или am I missing something crucial?
REGULAR
1 scoop of cool whip
ириски, ириска, светло-коричневый ice cream toppping mix till well blended
and cream soda <3 A&W
ICE CREAM BUTTERBEER
1 scoop of cool whip
ириски, ириска, светло-коричневый ice cream topping (mix till well blended)
cream soda A&W
1 scoop of vinallia ice cream
she made both for me today there her own recipes and they are so good Ты just HAVE to try the ice cream one its amazing ive got a pic of the ice cream one in my pics if Ты need to see what it looks like and make sure Ты have a spoon it sets fast but its good even when its set
<3 happy butterbeer drinking kids
1 scoop of cool whip
ириски, ириска, светло-коричневый ice cream toppping mix till well blended
and cream soda <3 A&W
ICE CREAM BUTTERBEER
1 scoop of cool whip
ириски, ириска, светло-коричневый ice cream topping (mix till well blended)
cream soda A&W
1 scoop of vinallia ice cream
she made both for me today there her own recipes and they are so good Ты just HAVE to try the ice cream one its amazing ive got a pic of the ice cream one in my pics if Ты need to see what it looks like and make sure Ты have a spoon it sets fast but its good even when its set
<3 happy butterbeer drinking kids
Some Harry Potter Фаны might disagree with me, but... THE NEWEST MOVIE SUCKED!!!! Sorry to say this but it did. It was a lot shorter than all the others, there was almost no plot, and almost nothing happened the whole movie. All they accomplished in the movie was to find the initials of some guy. I hope the Далее one does a lot better than that one. Although I suppose Dumbledore dying was an interesting thing that happened. The only good thing that came out of that movie was that it progressed the story. Other Фаны should agree with me, and if they don't it would surprise me. I am a long time Harry Potter fan. I have all the Фильмы and I have seen all of them in the theaters, and I have all the books. I'm not saying I am no longer a Harry Potter Фан или I don't look вперед to the Далее movie, but if Ты haven't seen the movie stick to the book.
Soft Harry Potters Фаны will expierience:
1. Ты will actually remember a few of the actual spells/curses/charms/hexes etc..
2. Ты will propably almost always turn the conversation to Harry Potter.
3. Ты would have named SOMETHING after a Harry Potter character/object.
4. Whenever Harry Potter is mentioned you'll listen straightaway!
Hardcore Harry Potter Фаны will expierience:
1. Whenever Harry Potter comes up in a conversation you'll feel as if they're talking about YOU.
2. Ты will accidently call someone at SOME POINT a character in Harry Potter.
3. Ты will propably name almost EVERYTHING after Harry Potter characters/objects
4. Ты would have read the whole series еще than three times. Ditto films.
5. Ты can quote long passages off by heart.
So dahlings, see if Ты have any of these symptons and you'll know wether your a fanatic или a just a plain fan. :)
1. Ты will actually remember a few of the actual spells/curses/charms/hexes etc..
2. Ты will propably almost always turn the conversation to Harry Potter.
3. Ты would have named SOMETHING after a Harry Potter character/object.
4. Whenever Harry Potter is mentioned you'll listen straightaway!
Hardcore Harry Potter Фаны will expierience:
1. Whenever Harry Potter comes up in a conversation you'll feel as if they're talking about YOU.
2. Ты will accidently call someone at SOME POINT a character in Harry Potter.
3. Ты will propably name almost EVERYTHING after Harry Potter characters/objects
4. Ты would have read the whole series еще than three times. Ditto films.
5. Ты can quote long passages off by heart.
So dahlings, see if Ты have any of these symptons and you'll know wether your a fanatic или a just a plain fan. :)