Гарри Поттер
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
Гарри Поттер Harry and Snape,who do Ты think is responsible for Sirius's death
107 fans picked: |
None of them
|
|||
Harry
|
|||
Both of them
|
|||
Snape
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
Also, lets not forget the blame to be placed on Molly Weasley. If she didn't insist on treating Harry like a child and keeping him out of the loop when Sirius wanted to tell him everything he would have known exactly what Voldemort was up to and probably wouldn't have fallen for that trick. She knew what Harry would eventually have to do, so there was no way to protect him from his fate, yet she still insisted on trying to coddle him and all it did was hold him back. I'd say she was more responsible than Harry or Snape. Snape was being a good spy, Harry at least had the excuse of being concerned and out of the loop, she was just meddlesome and that meddling got Sirius killed. I'm not saying I don't understand her concern (though in cases like this it annoyed me like hell) but she took it too far without thinking it through. You can't hold back info from the one who needs it most like that, it's stupid.
As for Snape, he was just trying not to be obvious in front of Umbridge. He had an important image to keep, and in the long term it would have been a pretty big problem if he let it show that he was somehow on the Order's side.
So yeah, I think Voldemort and Bellatrix (obviously) are the only ones to blame for that.
Overall, I totally agree with Priscilita22
Drunk drivers don't mean to kill people, but they still do. Are they blame free because they had no bad intent? Voldemort and Bella are the only ones who should be held accountable, and what Harry and Molly did is understandable in both cases but if your mistakes lead to a death that wouldn't have happened if you had thought more then you are in part responsible for that death, even if you had good intentions. They aren't bad guys and shouldn't be punished or disliked for it, but it's not exactly unreasonable to feel they are in part responsible for not thinking their actions through.
Sorry but that's just the way I feel and no one's gonna change my opinion. Oh and it sounded better in my head by the way lol
sorry but its just the way i feel
Войди или зарегистрируйся для того, чтобы добавить свой комментарий