I'd choose Regulus because he seems more shy (which i like) and he doesn't seem as wild as Sirius. Plus he grapples with being good and/or evil, like I do. :)

Regulus please.

Regulus. You can tell a person's true character by the way they treat their pets or those lesser than themselves. Regulus was kind to his house elf which contrasted a great deal with the way Sirius treated Kreacher.

yes BUT the only reason Sirius was mean to him was because Kreacher was a little ass first (copying his master;Sirius's mother) who was upset about her son being in Gryffindor and hanging out with less than pure bloods.

Sirius because he is soooo handsome.

He was never a Death Eater, which proves he has morals, values.

Far braver than his brother (far smarter too) and not a complete ass :)

@epcjll: But, as we found out in DH, all it took was a little kindness for Kreacher to come around. Something that Sirius never even considered doing.

And I still prefer complete asses.
Sirius was smart enough - just remind yourselves how easily he took all his exams - and brave enough - he survived Azkaban. The fact that he wasn't kind to Kreacher... well he had a Freud-reason for that, plus Kreacher was not that fluffy little cuteness. Sirius was loyal and loving to those close to him, he was handsome, fun, wise, smart and yes a little ass too (adds some spice) what else would anybody want? Plus we don't even know too much about Regulus' character.

Its always gonna be Sirius :D

Regulus may have been less handsome than Sirius but looks aren't everything. Siris was a jerk. Regulus was shy and not as out going as Sirius and I like that.

Sirius was a jerk,but i like Regulus:D

Sirius for sure & i supprt delamico in wat she said.

Just imagine snogging with Sirius *too many fanfics* it would be so passionate... just thinking about it makes hippogriffs in my stomach fly!

Regulus, because he actually had the strength to drink all of the potion in the cave, which even Dumbledore couldn't do (True, Dumbledore probably saw worse things, but it would still take amazing strength).

Sirius is a tad bit too scraggly...