What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Гарри Поттер If Ты could rewrite HP, would you?

86 fans picked:
No
   52%
Some of it
   40%
Yes
   8%
 simpleplan posted Больше года
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

30 comments

user photo
Vixie79 picked No:
The books were perfect IMO.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
LifesGoodx3 picked No:
I would never be able to make them as... magical :) Well I do wish Sirius had lived, but everything in the books happened for a reason!
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
simpleplan picked No:
^ true
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
xElvenPiratex picked No:
The books I wouldn't change at all (well, except maybe Hermione's whole SPEW crusade, which ultimately went nowhere, haha). But there are many things I would change about the movies.
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked No:
Even though I'd love to bring Bellatrix back I wouldn't know how to do so, she's so attached to Voldemort and would be depressed without him and I can't toss her in Azkaban. And besides what happned happened I wouldn't change it.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
scrubby21 picked Some of it:
one word: editing
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
smoore23 said:
I love them, and even if there are some aspects about it I'm not too keen on (see icon) I wouldn't change it.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
scrubby21 picked Some of it:
haha, i gather you're not a Hinny fan then? (don't know their shipper name so sorry if it's wrong)
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Magmashift picked Some of it:
I'd keep all the good ones that died alive. LONG LIVE MOONY AND PADFOOT!!!
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
karosama picked Some of it:
I wouldn't let Severus die
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
glelsey picked No:
Probably not. I really wish Dobby didn't die, and like xElvenPiratex has already said the whole SPEW thing didn't need to be there, but these things don't bother me enough to want to change it.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Lackson4ever85 picked Some of it:
i have save Remus,Tonks,Fred,Dobby,Severus and Bellatrix and Lily Potter,but im pretty glad and happy for rest of it,Love all the couples some end up together,The friendship,the familys and everything else was pretty good.
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года
 
user photo
Sandfire_Paiger picked No:
I would never be able to write the same exilence!
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
delamico picked Some of it:
I would probably earn less money for me and less fans for Alan Rickman, but if I could edit HP, there'd be no Silver Doe, no Always, no Look at me, no Sev, no any other disgustingly sugary and sweetie story about poor Severus and his dark childhood and adolescence traumas.
Arthur Weasley or someone just as little clichéic would be Teddy Lupin's godfather, and Tonks or Lupin would survive, so that we woN't have a whole new little baby who lived.
And Dumbledore's past would remain as misty and miraculous as it was till book 7. I am so not interested in yet another troubled childhood. But of course I love HP and no offense Ms Rowling. Love you.
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года
 
user photo
HouseofNightRox picked No:
I'd like to save some people,(Bellatrix, Severus, Lupin, Tonks) but I dont have to writing talent to do so
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Narusasu4EVER picked Yes:
I'd change a lot of it!!!
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Summer_Song picked Some of it:
Assuming I had the writing ability, I'd save Fred, Remus and Tonks, and change some of the final pairings.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
FriendsIsMyLife picked No:
I didn't like it when Dobby or Fred died, I think George's ear being cut off was plenty for the twins! I hated the fact that Serious died, but ah well, if I changed little parts like that the whole book would be different, and it's too good as it is!!!
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
D_J267 picked No:
^ I agree.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Leviski picked Some of it:
I would change the way Hedwig died and make the epilogue longer. Nothing else.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
SevSnapeForev picked Some of it:
Severus would've never died, and would be friends with Lily again somehow, and he would be reedeemed in the wizarding world.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
InvaderStickly picked Some of it:
I would bring Fred back, definately. How could you have George without Fred?! I also would've made Dudley less of a brat.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
foopetsrule picked Some of it:
More Romione moments, and Lupin and Fred wouldn't have died.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
ecpjll picked No:
no it's PERFECT the way it is...if it wasn't there wouldn't be so many weirdo HP fans
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
NarutoFangirl picked Some of it:
Yes, perhaps changing the pairings around would be a nice thing for me.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
BellaLovett picked No:
even if i don't want Bellatrix to die but for the respect of JK Rowling .. i say no .. Jo is brilliant and probably she knew what should be in the story more than me and everybody else
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
crazychlo picked No:
Harry Potter is perfect and to be honest I wouldn't change one thing about it. Not even the deaths, because for me, I have always liked the deaths because I HATE it in movies, TV shows and books where every character lives after some massive war. That isn't reality. Chances are, someone is going to die, if not multiple people, so I think it is great when an author is able to make those sacrifices to make the book even better.

I know that I like to write, but I also know that I will never be able to, or even begin to write on the level of JK Rowling. So in short, no, I would not change and I would definitely not rewrite anything from the Harry Potter series.
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года
 
user photo
iloveejasper picked No:
I would of only made a little bit of changes:
1. Harry ending up with Hermione.
2. Ginny dying instead of Fred.
3. At least keep Tonks or Lupin (preferably Lupin) alive for Teddy.

Although then I rethink these changes, and with these changes Harry, Ron, Hermione and Ginny wouldn't all be related thus they would hardly ever see eachother. But by being related, they celebrate Christmas, birthdays and Easter ect.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
dannylynn92 picked No:
not a word
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Bangel90 picked No:
Nope.
posted Больше года.