if tigerstar's dad is pinestar and firestar's dad is pinestar dosen't that make them half brothes?

Are Ты sure Firestar's dad is Pinestar?

someone on utube сказал(-а) that Tigerstar and Scourge were half brothers because there father was both Pinestar! but i've never heard of Firestar n Tigerstar bein half brothers! Pinestar was an elder wen Bluestar became a warrior! N Firestar was born many seasons after Pinestar left! I doubt that there even brothers!

Pinestar is DEAD when Bluestar is leader.And, in Firestar's quest, Cloudstar states that he is not decended from those Кошки who chased Skyclan out.
Scorge and Firestar are half-brothers, though

That's a trick qustion all Ты have to do is cheack this link
link

it says that firestar dad IS NOT pinestar for firestar was born of kittypets not a warrior kitty pet

Unknown She-cat-----Jake-----Quince
| | - -------- ----------
| | | | |
Unknown Tom---Princess Firestar---Sandstorm Socks Ruby Scourge
| |
--- ---------------
| | |
Brightheart---Cloudtail Squirrelflight Leafpool---Crowfeather
| |
--- ------------------------
| | | |
Whitewing---Birchfall Hollyleaf Lionblaze Jayfeather
|
----------
| |
Dovepaw Ivypaw
this is sandstorm's famliey tree


In a chat with Erin Hunter (on August 16th), it is revealed that Scourge and Firestar share the same father, thus Firestar is a half-brother to Scourge, Ruby, and Socks.
On Vicky's Facebook page, it was revealed that Firestar, Scourge, Ruby and Sock's father is Jake, a kittypet that appears in Bluestar's Prophecy.

MembersMate:

Sandstorm[3]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Daughters:

Squirrelflight[4]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Leafpool[5]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Father:

Jake[6]: Status Unknown
Sister:

Princess[7]: Living, Confirmed by Erin Hunter
Half-Brothers:

Scourge:[8] Deceased, Residence Unknown
Socks:[9] Living, Confirmed by Erin Hunter
Half-Sister:

Ruby:[10] Living, Confirmed by Erin Hunter
Nephew:

Cloudtail[11]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Grand-Niece:

Whitewing[12]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Great-Grand-Nieces

Dovepaw[13]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Ivypaw[14]: Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Grandsons:

Jayfeather:[15] Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Lionblaze:[16] Living (As of The Fourth Apprentice)
Granddaughter:

Hollyleaf:[17] Status Unknown






(fact-sandstorm's mom was brildleface her father redtail)