no fence to ppl but i don't like her much. i've liked her in s5, s6 but she means nothin to me, i just don't like her past/personality. as long as i had Peyton i could live through the show ;)

i love brooke, my red medal will show that. but her storylines are more separated from the other five, so it makes sense.

if not then both nathan and haley, or lucas and peyton. would have to go.

WATCH EVERYONE PICK PEYTON LIKE THEY ALWAYS FUCKING DO. THE SHOW WOULD BE NOTHING WITHOUT HER!

HAHAHAHA the show would be nothing without SEYTON? right then guy, the only publicity it gets is for soph! (&chad). I PICK BROOKE, I DON'T WANT SOPH FIRED I WANT HER TO QUIT! SHE IS TOO TALENTED & GORGEOUS TO BE WASTED ON PUCAS TREE HILL. OTH HAD ITS GOLDEN YEARS, NOT ITS GONNA GET WASHED UP. I WANNA SEE SOPHIA IN MORE MOVIES!

omg cause i fucking hater her and somee ppl knows how much i am...grr i cant stand her fucing voice

i don't know who to pick... i want to pick hilarie because i hate peyton and don't want her on the show but i love hilarie and i don't think she should be fired or i want to pick bethany because i like all the other characters better so yeah im undecided as of right now

I can't choose. I don't like Lucas, but without him that wouldn't exist Leyton. I would choose Brooke 'cause as Amy said her storylines are more separated from the other five, but I love her so much!

I guess if I had to pick it would be Brooke since Naley are happy together and there is NO WAY IN HELL would I pick either Peyton or Lucas. Don't get me wrong but I do like Brooke.

omg, poor brooke, i look forward to the brooke sl's too much to pick her, i love peyton too much to pick her, i enjoy naley too much to pick them and well i could just imagine the mourning if one of them left, so im choosing lucas caus i feel like this season hes not even there anyway. mise well just make it official, plus what better way to end the bl/lp fights, brooke can have julian and jake can come back to mend peytons heart.

shes the only one that can be removed from the plot and have very little effect on any storyline playing out...she's the most easily removable...i mean the only character out of the main 5 she's even seen with for the most part is peyton....so if she wasn't there who cares.

plus i hate her

I live for Leyton and love Naley. I like Brooke, but she would be the only one that would make sense since she is separate and the least effective on the plot.

i agree with deanwastedyou brooke's personality just annoys me all around, always has, always will....though all the characters make we want to smack them..luke's my favorite so i can't live without him and that means we gotta have peyton, luke wouldn't do well without haley so we gotta have her which means we gotta have nathan...brooke can leave town and ship out with owen or whoever(just not julian, i like him and want to keep him around) hehe and she can take millie and mouth with her as far as i'm concerned

We have our couples Leyton and Naley. Brooke is an extra character,it makes sense that if one had to be fired it should be her.

i agree, i like mouth and millie but mouth has been and ass and millie is ok.

I hate him.
Brooke's storylines are amazing!!!

wow i can't believe sophia is first choice now i feel how all hilarie/peyton fans used to feel when she got chosen for all of these

i'm SHOCKED too! i think they're just biased, who would seriously want brooke off the show? just think about it for a sec! shes the show stealer! i only voted her because she was already in the lead & i would love for her to leave to do bigger, better things because i only watch this crapfest for her!<333

For the same reasons as many stated for Brooke, I'd see Peyton go in a second, even if I couldn't get my Brucas happy ending. Peyton annoys me more than life no matter who shes around as a general rule. I mean no offense to her fans, just my opinion. However if I couldn't have that...Lucas and his squinty eye drama queen act would be next in line

Brooke is the only one who could be removed and the show would go on. You can't have Leyton with out Luke and Peyton and you can not have Naley without Haley and Nate. Also Brooke was an add in in season one so she really wasn't that important then. True in the past two season she has had some good storyline but I would live without her.

so if she wasn't there who cares.

Me! LMAO

I don't like answering these kind of polls. I love the main5. I say, fire Owen or Chase. Do it and do it now. Thanks.

Well, she kinda lifts out...

CheeryEllen93 YOU NEED TO BACK OFF A LITTLE! Nobody cares if you hate Peyton and if your life is so boring so you have nothing better to do it's anyone's fault! We're supposed to be here not to bash character so if you wanna go on get the hell out!

Well..NO ONE but if i had to pick then Brooke!

ONLY because she is the easiest to take out.....

well GOGFEK i find it interesting that III need to back off, what about elinochka? what the brooke bashers? stfu dont tell me what i can & cannot say ftard!

omg brooke seriously wthpur brooke it would jus be a show of 2 cheesy couples and there kids lol i love peyton and i love lucas just not together nathan is vboring im sick of his basketball i really dont care lol

Wow this pick makes me sad. I love Brooke, and I don't want her to leave the show! lol

Ellen, you have to calm down. We love Brooke and they hate her, we all just have to deal with it. Though there will come a time that I might just flip out from all these Brooke hating. :) Georgia is amazing.

How about let's just fire everyone and have Mark act on his god damn show all by himself?

That was so hard. I mean i love Brooke but i love the others more. So i voted for Brooke to be fired. But recently i haven't been enjoying Nathan's storyline with the whole basketball thing, so Nathan would be my other option.

I didn't really understand.. Fired from the show, or fired from their works? Cause if it's fired form the show, their characters names should't have been there.

Not an episode goes by that Lucas doesn't annoy the hell out of me.

Fire DAn thats my PICK

haneck cheeryellen you made me laugh.

people arent voting sophia of cause they don't like her, they are voting her off because THE TV SHOW WOULD STILL MAKE SENSE IF SHE WAS GONE!

Honestly I Wouldn't Pick Any Of Them To Get Cut Out But If I Had To Choose It Would Be Peyton - I Would Have Said Lucas But Considering The Show Was Mainly About The Scott Brothers It Seems A Bit Stupid

As For People Who Don't Like Brooke - Voting The Most Talented Actress And Most Interesting Character Off The Show Seems A Bit Stupid IMO But Then Agin I Will Never See How People Can't Like Brooke Haha

But Hey OTH Is Getting Worse As The Seasons Go One So I Wouldn't Be Surprised If Mark Cut One Of The Main 5 Out

i think they're just biased, who would seriously want brooke off the show? - YOU ARE REALLY PISSING ME OFF! STOP CALLING EVERYONE GUY - YOUR NOT FUCKING LILA - OR ARE YOU? THERES A THOUGHT!
WERE BIASED? AS ARE BRUCAS FANS PICKING PEYTON FOR EVERY SHITTY PICK, THEN ALL THE GOOD ONES BROOKE! LISTEN UP - WERE ALLOWED TO BE BIASED COS WELL ITS OUR OPINION- STOP BEING SO DAMN HYPOCRITICAL - COS YOU OBVIOUSLY DO IT TOO!
AND BTW YOUR COMPLAINING BROOKES WINNING! SO WHYD YOU PICK HER? OH THERES A THINKER FOR YA! MIGHT TAKE YOU ALL YOUR LIFE TO FIGURE IT OUT - THAT WAY ILL NEVER SEE YOU AGAIN!






huh - calm laura ... i dont want brooke off oth - i love her too much! peyton and brooke are my favourite characters so neither of them! though i get the others saying it would make sense her going cos her life is not tied in with the others! like leyton together, lathan brothers - there the scott family! brooke is tied in by friendship and well friends move away! however i deffo dont want this too happen!
so i based it on the weaker actor in my opinion - i love naley and nathan but id rather him go than anyone else!
obviously we need lucas for leyton - and im starting to like luke again now! haley i really like her - after my haley hating days passsed shes like my 2nd/3rd favourite!

They actually should fire Jamie...

BORINGFARTEllen93 no need to be rude about peoples names (i know i was then, but what you said abut G~gogkef
was out of order!
(GOGFEK) :|
jezz & theres no need to start a fight about it!
anywayss brooke & jamie take up to much screen time.

and yeah i think you ARE shocked, now you know how lp/peyton fans feel when you ALWAYS bash them/her.

This question is silly...I couldn't pick the others...they are all special, people need to get a life and stop with the hatred. One day you will grow up, and life won't be so black and white.

If there was no show, then you would have nothing to bitch about.

Just love the show, and the actors and leave your petty judgments at the door. I would hate to think of Sophia, Hilarie, or Chad to read any of this. It is insulting to the talent and work they put in for us...so just deal with it.

I agree..... I would be sad if any of them would have to go ESPECIALLY if it were up to the fans!...Yes I will miss some more than others but all the characters were here from the beggining and I've grown to love them all BUT the reality is that the actors will never be in that position where the fans decide their fate on the show!....That would be up to Mark...and everyone else on OTH and the CW!

I chose nathan because i think he's really boring and doesn't show much emotion. I would like it better if he just gave up basketball and move on like everyone else.

EWW you pucas fans are really pissing me off! laurra: are you talking to me? you sound like you're virtually talking to yourself. i bet you're a real cool kid..NOT! and ADDIE you're just a big stinky piece of seyton CRAP! brooke rocks, you all love brooke! peyton sucks ass, NO ONE off this site likes that heshe. i don't understand why all you dweebs are bashing ME for bashing a CHARACTER! goddam EMOS i'm just done like ewww man

Brooke can't fire herself so I'd pick her. That way nothing will happen =)

Well the fans on here wuld pick brooke cuz most of them hate her. but i dont even care anymore, i cant even belive this question. all i kno is tht if Brooke wasnt on the show, more then half of the viewers wuld stop watching cuz well, pple love her. even tho on fanpop ther are more peyton/lp fans, everywhere else pple just seem to love brooke. and IMO this show wuld suck ass with out brooke. if shes gone i kno im not watching. peyton and lucas are by far some of the weakest characters on the show but unfortunatley they do make up about 80% of it. this show shuld just be called One Leyton Hill, cuz well naley nor brooke get much screentime. well this show sucks latley anyways, its lost all its charm tht made me love it in the first place. soo agan i just dnt really care anymore.

i love hilarie but i hate peyton more than i like hilarie

Everyone needs to chill. Seriously. Ellen you have to be careful with your words.

This is seriously messed up, stop hating.

I am with Nem on this one

yeh ellen calm down seriously

this was outta line
again
if you're not able to have a discussion based on arguments, then you shouldn't be having one

well that ellen chick need to fucking stop! shes fucking out of line! this could of just been simple if she wasnt her! god wish shed just leave already!

laurra: are you talking to me? you sound like you're virtually talking to yourself. i bet you're a real cool kid..NOT! - mmm yeah, didnt you figure out i was talking to you? shame? are you kinda slow? figured as much!

look at it my way - a 'pucaser' starts stalking shit about all your little brucaser friends! not actually trashing there opinions but actually them too! what would you do? just stand back and watch them do it! cos if you would thats totally pathetic! im sticking up for my friends - and if you plan on making any on here i would stop! k thanks!

we arnt bashing you for bashing a character .. did you not read any of my comment? oh yes cos you cant read! sorry! :| we started on you for trashing FANS!


omg what a retard!

...well CLEARLY it's all a big typo



NOT!

AHAHA omg s- you always have to slip your sarcasm in somewere dont you!

I wasn't even talking to you, laurrawhatever
but if you feel spoken for, be my guest

Sarcasm always comes in handy when their is tension

vanhulle im not saying you were talking to me .. i was just adding to your comment! :) k thanks!


sure Dermer - is your comment trying to do that too! PMSL! look ive tried to email her and start afresh .. with a love for brooke! if she doesnt respond then at least i tried and took the high road! its not me whos gonna suffer on here! :/

k sorry then

I can't pick I mean I don't like peyton but I don't want her to leave. Brooke is one of my favorites. Lucas is alright at times depending on what the story line is at the time. Nathan I dunno I kinda wish he'd go back to the bad boy thing for a lil bit the nice guy thing is a bit played but him leave? nooo. and Haley I love most of her scenes and she brings fun and seriousness to it. So I can't choose and I believe some of you have broken the spot rule "LOVE NOT HATE AND NAME CALLING" x]

Don't like Peyton!!!!!

Well she's my least fav of the core 5.

hate her, the show has been so much better since she left!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lucas, Peyton & Haley are my favourite characters so they are out of the question. As a character I'll vote Nathan because his storylines are so boring, revolving too much about basketball & I prefer Brooke better than him. BUT no Nathan means no Naley & I love their love stories. So if really had to chose I'll have to vote Brooke.
1. Peyton
2. Haley
3. Lucas
4. Brooke
5. Nathan

.. but LEYTON & NALEY.