It was so amazing. So touching, heartbreaking, happy (BJu♥) and a few funny moments. Eveything oth should be. Maybe its just me but I loved it, even though it was horribly sad

Specifically the James part....R.I.P. Lydia James!

The last 10 minutes was pretty much all that impressed me. Other than that, like every episode, it had it's good and it's not so good parts.

Joy's acting was amazing, as always. Her character doesn't particularly keep me interested... but acting wise, she's always great. I thought Lydia and the rest of the James girls (especially Lydia) over-acted a little too much for my taste. their situation this episode was obviously sad, and I got teary eyed at times... but the over-acting killed the moment for me a couple of times. the whole thing with Lydia passing away right as the slide show ended... I thought that was a little much. I think it was more of the situation in general, and the music playing in the background that made me sad, not so much the acting. The part at the end where Haley put on the apron and kind of "took over" her moms role in the family was sweet though.

Brulian was SO cute tonight! I was getting so tired of the whiny Brooke drama, I'm glad that was finally put to rest tonight. It was so refreshing to see them finally be happy again. Hopefully it'll stay that way.

Clay and a psycho Sarah look alike?? Spare me lol... so dumb. Clay and Quinn admitting that they love eachother? Don't care. Again with Alex crying and being depressed? Predictable and overdone. A Skillls, Lauren, Mouth triangle? Already over it. Victoria and Alexander? random. weird. ew.

so as always, I thought this episode was ok... with a few decent parts thrown in towards the end

Amazing ♥

Amazing :)

OMG, how sad was that??? I cried like a baby...I really couldn't stop!!! )';
The acting was so incredibly amazing!!! Joy did such a wonderful job! Even Quinn made me cry this time...and especially Taylor! When she was talking to Lydia in the hospital...that was simply heart-breaking! I really don't think ANY of them over-acted...not at all. I mean if you put yourself in their position...omg, how can you NOT over-act???
All in all...one of the most touching and amazing OTH episodes imo. Honestly, I didn't even cry that much when I watched 3x16 =P

Oh, just one more thing...the next episode on april 26th??? WTH??? >.<

It was absolutely amazing! I so enjoyed it! It was perfect every bit! Loved the music, shouted "Yeah!" when Brooke punched Alex, cried with the James sisters, wished I had some chicken dumpling soup, screamed with joy when Brulian kissed... Loved this ep!!!

I cried the hardest at this episode than any other one, not the most just the hardest. The scenes that got got me were the Taylor and Lydia one and then of course the whole Lydia dying/the funerel. It was AWFUL. I was literally crying so hard I couldn't even breathe.

I also really enjoyed the Brulian getting back together and it also seems that Victoria really likes Alexander a lot.

The only thing I have to complain about is how the episode ended, I did not like that at all. I think they sould have ended with all of the James/Scotts/Clay at the dinner table eating the soup, that would have been perfect ♥

Brulian got back together, Alex proved that she's human afterall, the Scott/James family had so many great moments, I cried pretty much the entire episode, the music was amazing, it had a little bit of everything great, hands down one of the best episodes this season!!!

It thought the episode was AMAZING! *____*
Really really good <3
It sucks we have to wait so long for the next one. =[

But i do agree with Kelly on this part:
Clay and a psycho Sarah look alike?? Spare me lol... so dumb. Clay and Quinn admitting that they love eachother? Don't care. Again with Alex crying and being depressed? Predictable and overdone. A Skillls, Lauren, Mouth triangle? Already over it. Victoria and Alexander? random. weird. ew.

Psycos: We already had two.
Clay and Quinn: *sighs* Still not a fan. xD
Skils/Lauren/Mouth: OMG NO! Waste of screentime all over the place!
Victoria and Alexander: Talk about random.
Alex: We already had a sex tape and it was WAY better. xD

I really don't understand how could somebody pick 1 - awful??
People, you don't have a heart or something???
1st of all i wanna say that this episode had a brilliant actor's performance.
2nd one was really great script! Mark made a great job!
Thank you so much for that!

How someone could pick 1/2? LOL.

love it!