It still pisses me off how rude Peyton was to Haley when Haley came back.

To the person above me why does it 'piss you off'? Didn't it piss you off when Haley left Nathan to go on tour?

ok why did some add Brucas they actually add a good storyline in season 3 and I agree with Ellies. But Dan obsession drove him to murder i really hated this.

It was completely uncalled for and none of her buisness.
I was really dissapointed in her. I know she was having problems with Ellie but Haley is her friend too, along with Nathan and she should have been much more supportive.
Rachel's storyline was pointless, and although it could get very frustrating and irritating I wouldn't really want to take that storyline away.
I also would want to take away Peyton and Ellie because I thought that was pointless, and only caused Peyton more pain.
Dan trying to find out who killed him managed to get him so worked up that he actually murdered his own brother in cold blood, so I would like to remove that, too.
ASS FACE.
I also want to remove brucas, because although I loved them, I got all attatched and then I loved them and had to watch them not be together :(
And the last thing I would like to remove from season 3 was Nathan not accepting Haley's return.
He had every right to be upset, I just hated watching it :(
And to Rachelsboy- I'm sure both things pissed her off.

BRUCAS IS THE BEST PART OF SEAOSN 3 PPL:]

IDK mizzfelisha, the results say the oposite...

Rachelsboy, treehillfan said it all.
I was pissed when Haley left, but not just at Haley also at Nathan for giving her that stupid ultimatum and not supporting her more. But, I don't want to dive back into that argument.
Peyton's attitude was uncalled for she direct all her aggrevation onto Haley and that was rude and unfair,even Peyton admitted she was being a bitch. I just wish Peyton had never acted that way in the first place.

So i take you all thought it was none of Haleys buisness to be mean to Peyton in season 5 when Peyton kissed Lucas right?

lol SG1-090 you are right!! Naley fans always blame Peyton but she was only defending Nate, who is one of her best friends...Haley did the same thing to Peyton in s5 but that's ok to you cuz Haley is Lucas best friend. Some people can be very contradictory...if Peyton attitude was uncalled and mean then Haley's was it too!!!

Actually, sg1, I don't think it was any of Haley's buisness.
Just because I thought what Peyton did was wrong doesn't mean I thought that Haley wasn't wrong. Or that I don't like Peyton. Cuz I do like them both.
Anyways, alessandra, just because I like naley doesn't mean i immediately think that haley wasn't wrong when she butted in into the peyton and lucas kiss.
Especially since I didn't even mention that, and this isn't even about season 5.

Again, I agree with 1treehillfan. I didn't think it was Haley's business, but she didn't take it nearly as far as Peyton did. Haley had a problem and she confronted Peyton, Peyton was just a totally bitch for half the season.

half a season - more like a quarter of a season! and haleys always butting in when it concerns leyton! lets see -she fell out with luke s1 over the library kiss, she had a go s4 when the shooting kiss came out and then s5 where she was also mad at PEYTON! NOT LEYTON BUT PEYTON! FOR THE KISS WHEN LUKE KISSED PEYTON BACK!! SHE DIDNT WANNA KNOW PEYTONS SIDE OF THE STORY ABOUT THE PROPSAL!! AND SHE TOOK FUCKIN MANFACE'S SIDE! YEAH LEYTON WERE IN THE WRONG MOST OF THOSE TIMES BUT IT WAS NONE OF HALEYS BUISNESS IN ANY OF THEM!

PEYTONS MAD AT HALEY 1 TIME AND EVERYBODY GETS PISSED OFF OVER IT!! SHE WAS LOOKING OUT FOR A FRIEND - SHE WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO TOOK AN INTEREST IN NATHAN WHEN HALEY WASNT THERE! NOW WHEN HALEY CAME BACK ALL SHE WANTED TO HEAR WAS THAT SHES GONNA FIGHT FOR NATHAN!! AND THAT WAS THE END OF IT!!! IT WASNT THAT EASY FOR PEYTON WHEN HALEY WAS MAD AT HER .... THEY WASNT THE REAL PALEY AGAIN UNTIL HALEY REALISED THAT LUKE LOVES PEYTON! PEYTON DIDNT HAVE ANY CONTROL OVER ANYTHING WHERE HALEY DID!

anyway im over that now - cause now paley are friends again! and everythings good with them! - so i think we should just let everything go! cause its kinda annoying everything keeps being brought up again! it was good debating about it the first time but this sort of thing gets old especially when most of the debates are people having little digs about peyton! and im telling you now i always have and will continue to defend her!

i only picked this cause this is the one thing that i didnt like in s3 - i do believe everything happens for a reason - so if there was a none choice i would pick that! im just being petty picking the brucas option cause if the leyton options gonna be picked in the s4 one i want this one to be picked! :) im childish i know lol!!

Dan trying to figure out who tried to kill him and running for mayor - this lead to him killing keith and having power over everybody in TH lol
Peyton being a mean to Haley - lead haley to say shell fight for nate!
Peyton and Ellie - i just thought this was a really good storyline - even though i was upset by the ending :(
brookes clothing line - she started doing something for herself and it lead to her career in s5!
rachel - lol loves rachel, shes awesome!
brucas - i dont really know i good reason for them but i know they had to happen so they could get it out of there system and leyton could be together - im biased i know :D

woo that was a long comment!

Brucas is gr8!
Leyton is... hmmm ... not os good xDDDD

THAT WAS STUPID!

Yep ( =
And I actually LOVED the whole "Dan running for mayor" part ( : Dan and Deb were HILARIOUS! xD ("Can you see my ass through this?" xD)

Since I'm a Paley fan I didn't like this storyline obviously but I can understand Peyton. She was upset about Ellie [People leaving and coming back when they want to] an d took it out on Haley. Is this right? No but I think everyone understand where she was coming. Besides, since Nathan was her friend Peyton find the way Haley acted was wrong [kissing Chris Keller and leaving] just like Haley thought Peyton acting wrong in regards of Lindsey & Lucas.

Besides, if Peyton was a bitch in S3 what exactly was Haley? Peyton just helped Haley out with her music, she figured Lucas proposed to Lindsey and what does Haley do? Ohh right! She tells Peyton 'I am going to be the maidon of honor' and accused her of lying and cheating. Peyton was a bitch but Haley is definitely not a saint and too judgemental.

Hate this storyline :( Peyton & Haley are my favourite characters