Ответить на этот вопрос

Болталка Вопрос

Does anyone think stephanie meyer is a good writer???

*
thanx every1 4 ur thoughts
Crazy_NarutoKid posted Больше года
 Crazy_NarutoKid posted Больше года
next question »

Болталка  Лучший ответ

LadyL68 said:
not at all...
select as best answer
 not at all...
posted Больше года 
*
lmfao xD
louvreangel posted Больше года
*
XD
r-pattz posted Больше года
*
agree
darkwave posted Больше года
next question »

Ответы

xXhottieeXx said:
Yes.

In my opinion she is a VERY good writer. FYI just beacause she made her Вампиры sparkle doesnt mean she is a bad writer. Everyone has different view points on what Вампиры are supposed to look like, ect.
After all, Вампиры aren't real.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
HaleyDewit said:
I don't think so.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
ky-chan said:
NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! (i can't stress that enough)

She assumably brought on the whole "OMG-Sparkly-Vampires-Are-Sooooooo-Cool". Ugh. Please shoot me.
I was one of those people way back when, when any type of mythology book about vampires, shapeshifters, Волколаки and Драконы made me want to read them, but since Meyer's books, it's been blown out of porportion.
Frankly, what I think she intended to bring back was the mythology franchise, by adapting vicious, gory, blood-draining beasts and demons of the night, into petty, animal-sucking, sparkly...things that glitter like hell in the sun. No, don't bother bursting into flames, because I think my eyes just did from looking at the sparkles!
Whatever happened to chomp and bite? The rip and tear? The blood-splattered clothing, coffins, corpse-cold beings that I learned to love? Apparently they were дана a major redecorating to fit into every girls' vampire hotty boyfriend dream. Puh-leeze, not EVERY girl on the planet wants a chunk of that wussy. And I am one of those 5% of girls who's role modeled vamp became a sissy cute boy for the other 95% of sooks.
Don't get me wrong, I own the box set, read and re-read them and watched...umm, like half of one of the Фильмы and then I saw "Vampires Suck". Now that was ingenious. That movie alone drew out the main ultra bad plot-links and other stuff I couldn't follow very well, because I was tricked that Twilight was going to be a horror book: instead of the drama, queen-teen hearthrob romance it turned out to be. That alone made me gag.
And the Книги themselves were waaaaaay too obvious. The секунда that Bella saw Edward (no, even before that) I knew the ending. Guy is a vampire. Girl loves guy. Guy rejects her, so many times that her fat head can't comprend it, so finally he sends her mixed messages, which yet again she can't заворачивать, обертывание her head around until the
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
until they finally get together. Guy bites girl. The end. And, oh, yeah, there's always a треугольник in there somewhere. I guess Ты better throw in a werewolf too. And yet-*SPOILER ALERT* (to anyone who hasn't read the last one)-it turns out, Meyer let Jacob run around as a werewolf up until the point that the evil Вампиры say that he is a Shapeshifter. This fact alone had confused so many "sparkly-headed" girls that Волколаки do not transform whenever they want to. It's a gory, brutal process that revolves around the anatomy of both the human/werewolf and the cycle of the moon, putting man and nature in harmony. Ты want a werewolf movie? Try "The волк Man". That will put Ты in your place. Hell, "Vampire Diaries", made long before Twilight has a much higher rate of real Вампиры than Twilight will ever hope to have. Ты wanna argue, go ahead, I stand by it- and I am NOT a Vampire Diaries fan.
ky-chan posted Больше года
*
Case in point; Meyer, stay away from the vampire genre if you're not going to follow horror protocol. The Host was good though.
ky-chan posted Больше года
*
tl;dr
taytrain97 posted Больше года
xxXsk8trXxx said:
No.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
EgoMouse said:
I'll give a solid answer...after I do read it...which is probably not anytime soon...
..What were we talking about?
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
IlOvEbLeAcH said:
I only like one of her books, The Host. I hope she makes еще of them.
The others i dont like.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Monrose said:
Of course. She has managed to become one of the world's most famous writers because of Twilight. She has created a world where blood sucking Вампиры are cool and... well, sparkling... The whole vampire-culture ha been turned up side down just because of her.
I don't think Twilight is that good. That has nothing to do with how she writes, but how the world is responding. The Host is amazing, and it is my favourite book. And I read Stephen King, Dan Brown and Ken Follett, I should know what I'm talking about.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
r-pattz said:
No.

Her characters are boring and unoriginal. (No, Meyer, self-hatred is not an original trait.) In Twilight, it's like plot hole heaven или something. The stories are oftentimes anti-clamatic. Twilight is... cliche. Boy meets girl, boy and girl fall in love, boy and girl go through rough patch, but live happily ever after. The actual Письмо is... awful. She spends too much time describing things repetitively, things that don't always even matter, both in Twilight and the Host.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I totally agree with you.
louvreangel posted Больше года
*
Yeah, but Rowling has the same problem when describing. She describes too much, and allows no creativey.
Kadaj posted Больше года
*
Why bring up JK Rowling?
silverandgreen7 posted Больше года
KishuandIchigo said:
No.

I don't like how most of the book is describing how Edward looks (In Twilight, obviously.) And I've only read the first book in the series, but I don't want to spend my time Чтение how he looks. I like еще epic things, where lots of stuff happens. Most of twilight was just her thinking about Edward with small conflict every few chapters. James appeared about halfway through the book. (from what I remember)

I've not read the Host, but I might...
Maybe...
Probably not, but maybe...
Anyone want to get some sushi?
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Triscia95 said:
She's a fantastic writer though Вампиры don't sparkle. The Twilight Книги are amazing but the Фильмы is what turned them bad.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
MrOrange16 said:
If by "is a good writer" Ты mean "made formerly awesome vampire myths sparkle like faeries" then yes.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
drunksheep said:
I never read her books, no I can't say anything about it.
But i'm really not interested..
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
IHWTA said:
Never read her books.
But judging on what my sister says, The Host was good, but Twilight was bad, but that's my sister...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
LoopyLuna96 said:
No, not at all.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
NomyCake said:
Twilight was.... mediocre. Average. It wasn't "bad", but the characters were cliche and quite boring. And there were several plot errors in it. However, as an aspiring writer myself, I respect any piece of literature and anyone who has taken the time to put it down on paper, no matter how cliche или unoriginal.
I haven't read the Host, but my sister and my Друзья say that it's good, and I trust their tastes.
One thing that puzzles me is how Twilight got to be the big franchise it is. It is pretty unoriginal. And compared to franchises like Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter, which were both very unique and intriguing series, it looks completely dull. The fate of the world didn't rest in anybody's hands, only one vampire family, a werewolf, and some boring chick's happiness. And there was no climax, no goal, no point. And I was bored Чтение it. I guess just too many teenagers want bloodsucking faeries for boyfriends.
And in reality, boys that "sparkle" aren't all that into girls.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
colouredhazel said:
Hahaha No! her Письмо is horrible and the things she comes up with is in the mind of a toddler. i don't even consider her as an author. Even my 11 yr old cusion сказал(-а) twilight was boring and im relieved she сказал(-а) that.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Kadaj said:
I think that every Автор has their own way of writing. So, no, Meyer is good at what she does, which is writing, because it’s her own unique way.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
jrvampire23 said:
only read one of her Книги (NOT TWILIGHT) it wass The Host and it was a good book
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Im about to start Чтение that book after день of the scarab(my book...)
LunaShay posted Больше года
LunaShay said:
Eh,shes okay.Shes the one that made Вампиры glitter though....
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
BB2010 said:
NO!
select as best answer
 NO!
posted Больше года 
*
haha LOL
luv_warriorcatz posted Больше года
LinaHarrow said:
Yes.

Yes, personally I do. And I say this because I have read all four of the Twilight books. I believe she is a very talented writer, after all, she is the Автор of four bestselling books.

I think what some people have a problem with is the plotline. They dislike the idea of it, или story and it's details (note the great Дебаты of shimmering skin. Hey! I like things that sparkle!) but they don't actually pay attention to how well written it is или the rest of the author's role.

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, I know this, but quite a few of the people who say they despise the Twilight Series, haven't read it, или seen the movies, but simply heard other people's judgements. I mean no offense to anyone there.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Persephone713 said:
Ты kidding me? She is so bad she should not be called an author. If the press continues to compare her and call her the Далее JK Rowling. If I were Jo I would sue the stupid magazines and tell them to STFU. I like real Вампиры not sparklepires SMeyer created.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Ryoga_Rocks said:
Well, I don't know. I haven't read any of her books.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
tellymaster said:
Ugh, no. I think her Письмо is terrible. She did no research on anything when she started writing. Examples: She knew absolutely nothing about Вампиры when she wrote it, she's never even been to Forks, and clearly, she had no idea about the Great Depression in the 30's. Her characters are unoriginal and boring. They are too perfect and it's just annoying.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
MrsJonasLautner said:
Uhm.. HELL YEAH?!!!?!?!?!?!?!?!!? She's a New York Times Bestseller author, of course! She doesn't have 3 Фильмы out for NOTHING.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
taismo723 said:
Well, it depends.

I mean, my Mom's still Чтение the 4th Twilight Book, but she says the series is good.

The movies, they were OK. I think that all Книги are better than their movie. Even if the book is based off of the movie.

The only thing I hate about her:

Listen lady, I don't know what planet you're from или where Ты got the idea, but Вампиры DON'T sparkle. Don't go changing the way Вампиры are. Non-sparkling, blood-sucking Вампиры are what I'm talking about.

Thinks she'd make a good critic,
Kacey (taismo723)

P.S. Stephanie Meyer lives near me. She went to high school with one of my Mom's friends. Just thought you'd like to know that.

P.S.S. Funny thing is, my homeroom/science teacher brought up the Twilight Книги during Writing. Probably cuz we were discussing points of view, and it's Bella's point of view in the books.

(The pic is of Count Spankulot. If ya don't know him, he's gonna get ya. [And by get ya, I mean spank ya.])
select as best answer
 Well, it depends. I mean, my Mom's still Чтение the 4th Twilight Book, but she says the series is good. The movies, they were OK. I think that all Книги are better than their movie. Even if the book is based off of the movie. The only thing I hate about her: Listen lady, I don't know what planet you're from или where Ты got the idea, but Вампиры DON'T sparkle. Don't go changing the way Вампиры are. Non-sparkling, blood-sucking Вампиры are what I'm talking about. Thinks she'd make a good critic, Kacey (taismo723) P.S. Stephanie Meyer lives near me. She went to high school with one of my Mom's friends. Just thought you'd like to know that. P.S.S. Funny thing is, my homeroom/science teacher brought up the Twilight Книги during Writing. Probably cuz we were discussing points of view, and it's Bella's point of view in the books. (The pic is of Count Spankulot. If ya don't know him, he's gonna get ya. [And by get ya, I mean spank ya.])
posted Больше года 
sapherequeen said:
I can't say she's a great one, but I won't completely condemn her on that. Since she has just started writing, and admits she's inexperienced and therefore is evidenly not Актёрское искусство like she's the shit. :I
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
taytrain97 said:
I'm sure a few people think she's a good writer...but I'm not one of those people.
Sure, she has the ability to write beautiful stories, and I'm sure she could even write Поэзия if she tried.
But she sucks at coming up with original characters.
In the TWilight Saga:
-Bella is a serious Mary-Sue
-Edward is a stalkerish idiot
--(Bella is okay with this, and that's not good)
-Rosalie seemed to be out of the sexist regime for a while, until her story came out in Eclipse
--(Alice seemed like this also until New Moon, when her "obsession" with fashion started to get annoying)
-Half the characters don't even have fatal flaws, as if they're perfect human beings
And there are just too many errors in her Письмо to mention on here. I've heard The Host was a pretty good book compared to every other piece of trash she's written, but I'm just afraid I'm going to get let down again, so I'm not going to read it.
Twilight, honestly, was a very good idea. I just wish someone else had written it so it hadn't been so...botched.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
SnapeSoulmate said:
.....no.
select as best answer
 .....no.
posted Больше года 
*
OHHH! SNAPE....I purposely misbehave so I get detention with him. AND we dont study. WHOO. Sorry I am hornee right now. And Ты mentioned Snape.
Persephone713 posted Больше года
*
Well...Your name-LOL. Not really mentioned, but ya know. I want to kill that EFFING SNAKE NAGINI...Im sure Ты know why...***cries***
Persephone713 posted Больше года
*
I know.
SnapeSoulmate posted Больше года
harold said:
Yes, many people do. It really depends on what Ты mean by "Good writer," though, doesn't it? I don't think the Twilight Книги are well-written (nor well proofread или edited), but that doesn't necessarily mean that Meyer is not a good writer. In the marketplace, she is an excellent writer, because she produces not only wildly best-selling books, but she produces them quickly. Socially, she can be called a good writer, in that she makes many people (who didn't read before) want to read. Culturally, she's a good writer in that she has changed a lot of the dialogs about vampires, teen entertainment, and Любовь stories. On Fanpop alone, there is a very large amount of critical discussion about Meyer's books. The book publishing industry has changed to accommodate many еще stories "in the vein of" Meyer's Книги (people like the idea of a formula), which wouldn't have happened in the same way without Meyer. Similarly, the films based on her Книги have done monster business for both the film and Главная video industries, as well as spawned an apparently unending amount of parody in all media. A writer could do a lot worse than try for this kind of influence. Are the stories well-crafted and reflect a mastery of plot and the English language? I don't think so, but in virtually every other respect, Meyer's Письмо is a gigantic success. It's a good writer who manages to do all that without the benefit of skills in the craft of writing.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
smileypop9 said:
i actually do.
i know twilight is kinda a weird book, and the Вампиры and weird, but the book had me hooked and i actually enjoyed it. shes not as bad as everyone makes out.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
animegrl52p said:
Sorry! Not a fan!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
darkwave said:
no!!! she´s sucks
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Goldilottes said:
Yes, i think she is a very vivid and talented writer.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »