Ответить на этот вопрос

Болталка Вопрос

So I want an option on this scenario I was contemplating

Say person A has been kidnapped, locked away, and tortured ever since he was a two год old kid by some crazy maniac. He is now twenty-two and grew up being used to this.

Now, person B gets brought in. Person B has lived a normal life, with a normal family and normal friends, and a full twenty-two years of a completely normal life. Suddenly, Person B is subjected to the exact same life Person A has been living since he was two as he gets locked away and tortured on a daily basis.

дана this situation would the past experiences of the two people change who is suffering more, или is the idea of suffering an objective idea regardless of past occurrences?

Would Person A, due to his past and amount of time to get used to it, at that very moment be suffering less than Person B who had no time to?
 So I want an option on this scenario I was contemplating
*
I personally believe that suffering is, in fact, subjective. I believe this because suffering is a sensation - a feeling - an experience. Our feelings are determined by what is currently happening, yes, but at the same time how we interpret them and the information we are taking in by what we have experienced in the past. That added onto sensory adaptation, most of the torture would have become much еще monotonous and usual for Person A than Person B. Perhaps it would even become just as normal of a thing as eating или going to school is for us. To them, the suffering would have likely become much еще dull that it was before and thus it wouldnt be too strong. However Person B, who knows everything he had Остаться в живых would have to take that into consideration for his suffering. He would loose all his close relations at the same time be subjected to a level of suffering he has likely never seen outside of Фильмы and his imagination at most. дана this, it would be like the world is ending. So дана the different perspectives of the same scenario, I feel that Person B would suffer еще as for him it would be еще like a major event while for Person A, it would appear almost like another день if not perhaps a good день since there is finally someone else down there with him
Riku114 posted Больше года
*
или in a еще common или еще realistic scenario, say there was someone who was struggled with depression and mental health throughout most of their memory and life VS someone who suddenly got hit with depression due to a family death или something similar. I feel that while they may feel the same depression, the first person had a longer time to get used to it, assimilate, and learn how to manage and cope while the other person would be brought into a darker world than they are used to and find it much еще painful
Riku114 posted Больше года
*
A media example. Danganronpa, for those that know it. All the characters were put into the situation. Most of them freaked out however Togami notably didnt. Relating to his past and his high stakes competition with his siblings that he already went through as well as the constant high stakes competition he is used to, he did not care but rather found it fun. Meanwhile, other characters, such as Aoi who have yet to be exposed to such an environment, found it almost terrifying. This could probably also be attributed to personality and preferance differences rather than backstory and thus invalidate the example, but I feel such an example holds some value.
Riku114 posted Больше года
 Riku114 posted Больше года
next question »

Болталка Ответы

wantadog said:
Short answer is yes, Person B would be suffering more.

It's pretty much the same basic idea for a scenario as one person being pampered and spoiled his whole life and the other having to constantly work for everything. So when that pampered person is put in the shoes of the hard worker, they find it much еще difficult. So they do the same work, but one person struggles more.

In another example, if two people got together with one having had alot of exposure to being asked out или courted while the other had never fallen in Любовь или even had any of those considerations before, I feel the emotions of the person who had not experienced it before would actually be factually stronger than the other. But that's the kind of thing that a whole other Вопрос could be made from.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
SeraphOfTheEnd8 said:
Person B would suffer more
something shocking
unexpected
lack of strength
Person B can probably lose his mind because everything happened so quickly
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TheLefteris24 said:
I'll try to keep it brief as well.

I believe that they would share the exact same level of suffering. What is different, is the endurance they are going to display. On the outside, Person B will be notably much еще expressive than Person A. For the former, it is a whole new experience. Besides torture, what he/she has to deal is the fear of the unknown which only amplifies the tension that is being received by torture. The heat of the moment can play a crucial role. That being said, I don't think that the latter could get used to something like that no matter how much time passes. The same applies for every living being. Of course, that is unless they are BROKEN. Not sure if that counts as living in the end. Depending on the kind of torture, someone might not even survive for that many years. Well, since Person A has, I believe he/she'll still provide much less of a reaction. Ты could say that it is a form of adaption. Ты cannot stop the pain but Ты build the necessary resistance to keep going. Again, these are matters of one's Outer Self. When it comes to the Inner one, I don't believe there is any difference in the amount of suffering both of these people are undergoing !!!!
select as best answer
 I'll try to keep it brief as well. I believe that they would share the exact same level of suffering. What is different, is the endurance they are going to display. On the outside, Person B will be notably much еще expressive than Person A. For the former, it is a whole new experience. Besides torture, what he/she has to deal is the fear of the unknown which only amplifies the tension that is being received by torture. The heat of the moment can play a crucial role. That being said, I don't think that the latter could get used to something like that no matter how much time passes. The same applies for every living being. Of course, that is unless they are BROKEN. Not sure if that counts as living in the end. Depending on the kind of torture, someone might not even survive for that many years. Well, since Person A has, I believe he/she'll still provide much less of a reaction. Ты could say that it is a form of adaption. Ты cannot stop the pain but Ты build the necessary resistance to keep going. Again, these are matters of one's Outer Self. When it comes to the Inner one, I don't believe there is any difference in the amount of suffering both of these people are undergoing !!!!
posted Больше года 
*
That is would agree with this. This is why I would choose them to be equal at times.
Riku114 posted Больше года
8theGreat said:
I don't think the two should really be compared honestly, because in what real-world examples we do have, actually trying to decide who was suffering еще is pretty damn impossible.
I mean, who had it worse, link[/b] или link[/b]?

Both are horrific accounts of human depravity and all of the victims involved undoubtedly endured a lot of hardship and have had emotional scars that they'll never be fully able to get over. Deciding who suffered еще at a particular point is not only a tough call to make, but just downright unfair.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
XD I know but I like the theorize stuff like this.
Riku114 posted Больше года
*
I realise that but for me it's just as impossible to theorise in a fictional scenario than a real one. I have just as difficult a time even starting to think who is suffering at a particular moment between person A and person B as I would for Genie или the women Castro kidnapped. Like it's not even conceivable to me on a conceptual level.
8theGreat posted Больше года
next question »