Rory & Hayden were the best. I was surprised by Hayden, I've never been a fan but she was awesome!

Hayden was my favorite character (Kirby) for sure, but Emma did a great job.

Erik and Hayden and Marielle

i didnt think emma was good at all :(

^ Me either. I thought she was terrible, especially in the final act.

I agree, I don't think Emma was all that good. I don't think she was especially bad, but definitely not good either.

Hayden by far, she definitely stood out amongst the new cast.

I loved the ending when Jill was revealed as being the kiler.
Not a fan of Hayden but she really pulled it off

emma was not believable enough..her acting was eh

Hayden & Emma acted EPIC!

Strictly performance? Panettiere by leaps and bounds (but she also gets the most to work with in terms of range). Jill is actually my favorite character, but that's despite Roberts' horrible acting, not because of it. I also think Knudson and Tortorella do well, even though the latter didn't have all that much material to work with.

Culkin is lifeless, and Jaffe is so dead the corpses seem lively