Would have said Jessica, but she's dead of course. *sigh* Why must all the female characters DIE?!!!!

She is by far my favorite girl for Sammy :))

I just liked him with Jessica, thou my second pick would be sara:)

Ruby 1.0 is my first choice, then Sara.

Who would pick Ruby?? :O Seriously guys!!

And Dean?? Well...no comment. lol

i love Sam with Sara but it seems like he's like his dad when it comes to relationships he just can't move on from his first love...Jess. I thought they made a cute couple they shouldn't have let her go so fast it would have made a great storyline about her accepting Sam's gifts & the "family business"

I love Jessica, i know she was in like 2 eps but her and sam are cute and look good together. Plus the love he had for her was amazing, just like his father. But if not Jess then Sara

I pick Madison. Even though she was only in that one episode (and she died), they had total chemistry in that one scene. Unf, just thinking of Sam and his ripped body xD

Ew, Ruby >.<

loved jessica:)

Or Jessica

I really wish they would have kept her around as a recurring, I just adored her and think she and Sam would have been a perfect couple.

I HATE how things ended for her. Total BS.