|
Asvini said:
I'm glad the Показать doesn't just mimic the books. I haven't read past the first yet, but I fully intend to, and I wouldn't bother if they and the Показать were identical. I understand people liking the Книги more, but no matter how good the Книги are, recreating their story exactly is pointless. That story already exists, if people want to experience it again they can just read the Книги again. What point или need is there to exactly duplicate an already existing story? I'd quit watching and just have the Книги if it was just them all over again. An exact recreation can work for a book-to-movie (sometimes) but not for a book-to-tv Показать in my opinion. Not to mention that дана the amount of Книги in the series it would be hard for them to do a book a season without ending half way through the story. Most even very successful shows either run out of steam или end by the 10th season, usually earlier, and the Книги are already 10 with еще to come last I heard. They'd probably have to eventually either cram multiple Книги into single seasons (which would seem rushed and ruin в общем и целом, общая arcs) или simply end before the story did to follow the books. I think people should judge the Показать on it's own merits without automatically hating anything changed. Sure, compare, and thinking the Книги did it better is completely valid, but some write off plots they may otherwise have liked as a knee jerk reaction to change. To me that's like throwing away your season 2 dvd and buying a секунда copy of season 1 if Ты liked it better. Sure, liking s1 better is completely valid, but that doesn't mean Ты need it twice. Though for the record I think there's a difference between changing events and changing message, so things like making Sookie seem еще naive, stupid или quick to forgive Bill than I hear she is in the corresponding book (not up to that book yet), I completely understand Фаны being angry, and don't think they should make that sort of change. I'm fine with them changing the events to make a new story, but I do agree with book Фаны that changing a character to have them send a worse message is wrong. If Alan Ball wants Bill/Sookie he'd need to remove the 'Bad Bill' plots, rather than just removing Sookie's reaction like he currently seems to be. While I'm fine with changing events I think changing message and weakening the heroine just to serve your liking of a character is wrong, and understandably annoying for Фаны of both the Показать and books. I'm fine with him altering events somewhat, but don't turn Sookie Stackhouse into Bella лебедь for heavens sake...Sookie Stackhouse is better.
|
|