He's perfect! i love him! =)

I didn't like him at first, but he grew on me for sure. Anyways, I'm not in love with Edward... I love Jacob, and they got the perfect Jacob, so i'm happy :D

He seems to be doing a good job from what I've seen, so you know... whatever.

at first, when i found out he was playing it, i was like, "he's cute, but not right for edward. edward needs to be a GOD." but honestly, edward's shoes are nearly impossible to fill, and i think rob will do a pretty good job.

the one i picked xplains it all.

Did you guys see the first completed scene? It was pretty good but I was sort of upset with how Bella was played her emotions were just not right to me. Well, we'll see how it turns out when the actual movie comes out. Thanks so much for responding! =)

katinthehat1414 you got it right on the dot. He's okay, but DEFINETLY NOT Edward. NO mortal could EVER be Edward . . . 'Nuff said.

Yeah you guy's are right but exactly what you said no mortal could be exactly like edward because he's practically a god to us twilight fans but if we had to choose a character do you think he is good enough? I personally think he is!!!!=)

that explains it, i don't really care tho

He IS hot... But I still am a LITTLE skeptical, though I have to admit that the trailer gave me a bit of a crush on him. (when I say a bit of a crush, I mean I had a mini Twilight-gasm when I saw the trailer) I really hate what they've done with his hair, but he pulls it off as well as is possible. On anyone else it would book like shit.

I agree with the hair thing!! I don't think they should like spike it as much as they have!! But yeah!! He is SUPER H.O.T!!!=)

can i just say ppl don't say "cute" anymore! ppl say stuff lyk sexy or fit,buff, sex bomb, gorgeous, candy sweet (that's so dirty u hav no idea)! but seriously he is sssssssssoooooooooo candy sweet!

Ok! Who cares what we say and what we don't! I think he's fricken hot! Or sexy! Whatever! Some people don't think he's that good looking and that he's just cute!

Totally adorably cute, not what I imagined, but LOVE him in the role!!!!

he is cute, he is not how i imagined him but he is perfect for the role long live Edward.

A perfect actor for a perfect character.

-xo.

Robb is PERFECT... for Edward.... <3

robert is no where near how hot + great edward would be.

NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!
HE IS THE BIGGEST LOSER EVER!!

He's Perfect

i argee with lovely lola

He is awesome as Edward