WHICH MOVIE DO Ты THINK WAS BETTER NEW MOON или ECLIPSE ?

I loved eclipse ! I feel like they did a good job of capturing the important things . I felt the Любовь jumping off the screen !

but new moon . . I loved the book I was alil disappointed in alot of things they left out. I know its a time but things that were important were left out.
Examples;
1. When bella went to stop edward from Показ himself . In the book she was trying to Переместить him but couldnt . He thought he was dead and had met her in an after life. In the movie she ran into him and pushed him out the sun and he hugged her and was so happy
2.The air plane scene , in the book alice tells bella she promises to turn her if edward refuses to and she talks about how much she loves jasper nd how they meet and stuff . Then she steals the yellow car. In the movie once they leave bellas house they go staright to them being in the yellow car
3.I dont think they showed her pain after edward left good enough . She felt like she wanted to die everyday but I didnt feel that from watching the movie
4.Didnt feel the Любовь she grew for jacob either