add a link

'Twilight': 10 reasons 'Breaking Dawn' should not be made into a movie

save

8 comments

user photo
I think that while some of that is crap, the author does have some valid reasons. To be honest I just think it shouldn't because
A) Three main points are Bella & Edward on their honeymoon, Bella giving birth and Jacob falling in love with Renesmee, all of those would have to be edited massively to be made into a PG-13 movie.
B)I think Eclipse makes a better movie ending, all of us obsessed Twilighters wanted to see Bella & Edward marry etc but Eclipse has the perfect typical movie ending. Bad guys are dead, couple live happily ever after. The majority of people who go to see the movie won't have read the books so it will be a better ending for them.
C)I think lots of Twilighters would refuse to watch a Breaking Dawn movie, I personally thought the book was ok but I know hundreds of people who hated it so it would make better sense money wise to just do three.
D) The cast are only signed on for three movies anyway, if someone gets sick then they wont do a fourth and then what would they do?
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
sorry to say but i find alot of these reason s are stupid.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
BD wasnt a horrible book, (IMO) it would be hard to keep it pg-13 and still be worth watching. They'd have to cut out (or change) basically all the good parts. End it with 3
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
that was the stupids reasons ever Edward DIDN'T USE HIS TEETH! my gosh he used a medical knife but like every one says the birth would be hard and the jacob thing Xp

meanwile all the actors and acresses only signed up for 3 movies so there may noght be a 4th but who knows
also besieds the rating they would have to keep it to 2-3 hours so some pars would have to be shortend anyway (but added as deleted parts on the DVD) if it was made into a movie but Right now
theres only 3 Twilight, new moon, elcips
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
i want it to be rated R if it's made into a movie. i loved BD and think all those reasons the author gave was complete crap.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
TriineA said:
I really hope BD is made. There will be some difficulties - but then again, they are gonna have to find a way to make wolfes in New Moon. I bet they can find a way to make BD (:
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
god am i the only one who as an avid twilight reader HATED the movie? the flow sucked, that weird chick who plays bella does not even remotely act like bella in the slightest, edward.. eh he was ok but they could have done better. the books are so amazing and the movie takes away that magic
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
I agree with countrygirl2008
These reasons r stupid
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года