no because i hate him in every way to me when he wouldn't let go of Bella when he kissed her its like he wasn't letting her have her way either and then he goes and said oh look i imprinted on Bella only half way so now just to erk every one of im going to imprint on Resemee whole. i could go on and on about how many things i hate about Jacob but im not going to start all the way. if you want to here more just email me and I'll tell you.

I would have left her with all the Cullens well probably Rosalie considering she wonted a baby and now she can see how it feels.

no because he is a dumb smelly mutt!!!!!!!!!! i HATE him but Hate is a very strong word so... I VERY VERY STRONGLY DILIKE HIM! i wanted him to get his dumb ass mangy dog neck snapped in the book but no..... it didnt happen i would have left her with roaalie cuz rosali really wanted one

I picked Jacob because that's what Bella wanted.He is totally devoted to Renesmee and would die for her in a heartbeat.He had the best chance of saving her in the situtation they were in at the time.

Jake would die for Nessie. I can't think of anyone better for her to have chosen. And besides, I love Jacob too. I would want him to be able to survive(even though all of them did).

he wouldnt be able 2 b without her. even if you sent her 2 someone else he would take her away. i hate jacob (most of the time but not always) but he would take care of her so yes

jacob is bella's best friend!its not bad althought alice was just SO PERFECT!

because jake had imprinted on renesmee, he would do anything to save her, she couldnt leave her with better then that

As much as i hate him,he wouldnt hurt her... He imprinted on her fgs.
Although i like dogs, jacob should be put down ;)

I don't like Jacob but I still would have because he would've taken such good care of Renesemee and never let anything happen to her. xoxo

I would have left Renesmee with Rosalie. Nothing against Jacob (except for the imprint, kind of), but I'd trust any child with Rosalie. :)