what about SmallPaw? :(

Cloudtail??? Seriously????

cloudy is to goofy and doesnt belive in starclan ,reamember?

Tigerstar In his current state would be a better med. Cat than Cloudtail.

who the heck is sootfut >.< don't remeber i'm so bad

i know who sootfur is, but i dont remember his personality because i havent read the new prophecy in a while. but cloudtail is agressive, stubborn, and inpatiant.

roadkill would be a better med. cat than cloudtail!

Cloudtail doesnt believe in starclan!!!!! but sootfur does... *mischevious grin*

sootfur even though he's dead :p

cloudtail X3

cloudtail doesn't even believe in starcaln, remember? Sootfur was just more gentle...

ugh my kitten likes to type and i was bored when i picked two but some people like cloudtail better

Anyone but Cloudtail!

lol cloudtail isnt the medicine cat kinda type.. but he's awesome too! i love him as cloudkit... so caring!

Well, though Cloudtail has a lack of belief in StarClan, he is very smart. After all, if Mothwing could do it...

Both.

Cloudtail, in my opinion, has more of the fire to be a warrior than a medicine cat. Then again, just look at cats like Yellowfang.

Cloudtail is aggressive impatient and does not have a strong faith in Starclan. Sootfur is fierce, ya.... Both of them would not be starclan's choice. But if I had to choose, Sootfur would try, Cloudtail would fail. Sootfur? Fierce, patient loyal, good enough! Better than Jayfeather....

why sootfur thats so random

Sootfur is stupid. Cloudtail would be more responsible and loyal.

Cloudtail's an atheist!