Do Ты believe that because Bella was 18 when she had sex with Edward, who is 17, she raped him?

*
Edward is Холодное сердце at the age of 17 but everybody thinks that he is 18, if he wasent '18' he would not get married.
Cittycat19 posted Больше года
*
haha!! LOL
babina posted Больше года
*
hahaha that thought never occured to me LOL
hhgg22 posted Больше года
 edwardcullen23 posted Больше года
next question »

Рассвет Ответы

Cittycat19 said:
No, they are married.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Rape is sex with consent. It is completely possible to be raped by your husband.
Lunatic posted Больше года
Lunatic said:
Edward's body is 17, but his mind is 107. (So in my opinion, he is well over legal.)

On вверх of that, Edward was quite willing. There are many definitions of rape, but in most jurisdictions, it is sexual intercourse, или other forms of sexual penetration, by one person ("the accused" или "the perpetrator") with или against another person ("the victim") without the consent of the victim.

If anything, it would be pedophilia considering Edward is 89 years older than Bella.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
LOL i understood nothing!!
babina posted Больше года
*
Did Ты understand the word "Edward"? If yes, then Ты didn't understand nothing.
Lunatic posted Больше года
*
If They're Both Over Sixteen Then It's Not Pedophilia!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
Hellohoudini said:
16 is the legal age (for sex)...and it wasnt rape...they were married... come on...dont cheapen the making of Nessie!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
jannette_camou said:
W.T.F Thats a wierd ? no i dont think she raped him Edward waz not forced to do anything
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
How Could He Be Forced To Do Anything? He's A Vampire For Crying Out Loud! How She Physically Make Him Do Anything? She Couldn't! She's Not That Strong! So It's Definantly Not Rape!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
loissss said:
wtf? your legal when your 16 anyways (well Ты are in the uk!), and she didnt force him to do anything did she?
and oh yeah, they're MARRIED :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Rape is sex with consent. It is completely possible to be raped by your husband.
Lunatic posted Больше года
*
yeah. i get that, but it is sort of obv that it wasent rape wasent it.
loissss posted Больше года
*
I Don't Get The Whole "Legal Age" Thing! I Know That If One Is Sixteen или Over And Has Sex With Someone Else At Least Three Years Younger Then It Could Get Them Arested! But There Are Twelve год Olds Out There Having Sex! So Quit Saying "Legal Age!" It Just Doesn't Make Since Anymore If Everyone Is Already Having Sex!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
katej1975 said:
How can she of raped him when they are MARRIED!!!!
thats just wierd asking that,,,,
the legal age in uk is 16,, whats it in america?????????
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Rape is sex without consent. It is completely possible to be raped by your husband.
Lunatic posted Больше года
*
when in any of the Книги did either of them say no!!!!! when they are doing it ....i know edward didnt want to at first but he agreed to it...
katej1975 posted Больше года
*
Lunatic we get it no offense oh and funny Вопрос i dont know if it was seriours или not but i still laughed.
jen929 posted Больше года
ladiid187 said:
no
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
babina said:
uurrrrggggg!!!!!!! the legal age 4 marriage is 16!!!!!!! and about raping him.. well duhhh!! they were married 4 crying out loud and he is older than her!(if he wasn't frozen)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
twilightfreak32 said:
You've got a dirty mind dude.Nah,Edward was 108,and Ты cant rape the willing.Oh and if any one is wrong in that relationship it is Edward.Hello,he's a 108 год old that goes for teh seventeen years old,pedo much?LoL
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
It Doesn't Count! LOL They Are Both Clearly Over Sixteen!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
wild-bby said:
No not at all. firstly Edward is older than her. secondly it's legal (at least in the UK not sure in America) to have sex when you're 16.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
wow Even if Neither Of Them Are Sixteen Yet It's Still Illegal?
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
mrscullenlol said:
no bcuz legaly hes one yaer younger than her. and they are married so yah good ? i never thouht of that
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
moonlightgirl said:
no, because Edward was willing to have it with her. people who are raped aren't usually willing to do the sex but Edward was willing even if he was 17 forever
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
greenteam said:
They were married, so no!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
ya, Ты can't rape the person your married to when Ты both agreed to do it.
Edward_Bella234 posted Больше года
*
But Ты Can Rape Your Husband/Wife If They Aren't Willing! Just Because They're Married Doesn't Mean Anything!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
bet-on-alice said:
just because they were married does not mean that they could not be raped as neither of them сказал(-а) no! also just becasue they were both over the legal age of having sex (16) does not mean Ты cant be raped! LOL a 60 год old could be raped! :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
and NO bella did not rape edward! LOL
bet-on-alice posted Больше года
Edward_Bella234 said:
Its not rape because he wanted to as well. Rape is when one of the people doesn't agree to it. He may not have WANTED to like Bella did but he agreed to try so, no that wasn't rape.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Ha! He Wanted It Alright! Have Ты Ever Read Midnight Sun? He Was Just Scared Of Hurting Her! But He Did Agree So. . .
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
sapherequeen said:
Not really. Considering that Edward has been 17 for centuries and is definitely еще intelligent then any Albert Einstein of the world, it doesn't count as rape really.
Now as for Jacob and Renesmee....
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Albert Einstein Was Only Smart In Math!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
Team_Edward95 said:
WHAT? ARE Ты INSANE? HOW DID SHE RAPE HIM! EDWARD CHOSE TO DO IT AND 16 IS THE LEGAL AGE TO HAVE SEX. HOW DID SHE RAPE HIM? HE IS TECHNICALLY 100 YEARS OLD! Ты HAVE MADE ME SO ANGRY
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
I_Love_Cullen said:
lol... but bella couldn't rape edward becuase he's like a 1000 times stronger than her. So no not really...
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Exactly!
shivers-zimmy posted Больше года
MissTwilight6 said:
edward is technicallly like 110 so who cares
if blla is 18 the r right 4 each other
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
brianacullen said:
not really
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
smilez12101 said:
I dont think so because he is realy like 100 years old. And every one thinks hes 18 also.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Dusty1212 said:
If Ты think about it logically she didnt, and besides its in the BOOK not REALITY so technically no 1 got raped in the process of the book...

(Don't flame thats my opinion we're all entitled to 1 ) :-)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
scarlet13 said:
NO SHE DIDNT TECHNICALLY HE IS 108 SO SHE DIDNT!!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
shivers-zimmy said:
Ты Are Practically Saying That If Someone Is Older Than It's Rape! No No No! If They Are Both Willing It's Not Rape! Plus In Real Life Someone Younger Can Rape Someone Older! How Is That Rape At All! This Вопрос Makes No Since To Me!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
AimeeSweetman said:
no of course not that is ridiculous
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Rosemmett said:
of course no
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
filand said:
edward's technically the pedo cos he's 108 или something isn't he? so i think it's weird that he went for bella anyway. Ты would have thought he'd have gone for someone еще maturely minded
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
carina1240 said:
no basically raping would be smeone forcing u and it was him tht raped her he is 109 shes 18
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Edward didnt rape Bella...you need to read the story again...rape is forcing someone to have sex against their will....just because Edward is "older" than Bella does not make him a rapist...
Hellohoudini posted Больше года
next question »