So this all happened when I made a post on specifically why I dislike Frozen.


Original post:
Ты know I know some people dislike Холодное сердце because it's overrated, but I just don't like Фильмы that are "made for their time" I like Фильмы that strive to be classic. It's one of the main reasons I dislike Aladdin, Hercules, Frozen, and, though I like Рапунцель - Запутанная история more, that as well. I don't know, I just felt like I should say that.


That being the reason I disliked Frozen, some people thought that it was еще timeless than what I was giving it credit for.

avatar_tla_fan commented…
I dislike Холодное сердце because of the story and the characters, although it is very overrated, that doesn't effect my decision as much.


Sk8er__grl commented…
Why is Холодное сердце and Рапунцель - Запутанная история only made for it's time? I understand Hercules and Аладдин because of pop cultural references all over the place, but I think that Дисней was trying to make Холодное сердце and Рапунцель - Запутанная история to last for a while. And Фильмы like Аладдин did last a long time with a big Фан base so. I don't now I'm probably way off.


misscindyspice commented…
Agree with Sk8er :3


KataraLover commented…
Аладдин is actually considered a timeless classic, I think Hercules is too but I'm not sure. I think Холодное сердце is just the product of the time. But Рапунцель - Запутанная история seems timeless to me.


BelleRose829 commented…
Pop culture references die after time moves on, frankly none of my little cousins get genies jokes. Hercules is a tad еще timeless, but if Ты can see something that relates to the now time and would be found say 50 или 100 years назад I wouldn't really like it. Холодное сердце is made for the time considering the whole "You can't marry a man Ты just met" thing. Also Anna is a ball of awkwardness that say modern things like "I won't judge" and general being. The fact that it's CGI as well, Ты wouldn't find that years назад and in the future it'll be outdated. Аниме eyes on the girls and not the boys is also a product of our time. All Ты need to do is look at all Genie's jokes in Аладдин and The way people speak and act in Hercules and Ты can see why it's made for its time. References Thebes as 1990's New York. I'm just not a particular Фан about that. Just as Your или our generation is for Аладдин Холодное сердце will become that for the younger kids and some in my generation. And then in the Далее 30 или so years when Холодное сердце is no longer "with it" there going to make another movie for the current time with better graphics and plot line или what have you. That's why I'm not interested in those.

Sk8er__grl commented…
Hmm, interesting. I can see where your coming from, really. A person can make the argument that neither is, "Snow white and the seven dwarves" because Snow gets married right away and waits for a prince and doesn't do anything feministy или whatever, yet the movie still stays with us and it's still marveled at for it's time. Time had gone by, and now Дисней is updating it to fit the now time. If Дисней went back and made SWTSD today it wouldn't be the box office success it was 70 years ago. So depending on how long Дисней stays the Фильмы will change and look different and have different messages, but the people from those days can still look back to Фильмы made today and still enjoy them and still Любовь them. In fact, if I was watching Холодное сердце in the future I'd probably like it еще than I do today, I know it wouldn't be up to what we would have then but I'd still appreciate it and when it came out. I should of let somebody else take this debate, sorry, I don't think I worded it well.
22 hours ago

BelleRose829 commented…
Actually the classics to some extent are made for their time. However they are call "classic" for a reason, not of their terminology pertains to the time. Their aren't any Madelyne Monroe jokes, no "Well gee willikers bobby" phrases. Nothing that says we are taking something from what is Популярное today. The Аниме eyes and the "I don't judge" from Anna are sources from today's pop culture. Genie makes several jokes about old Знаменитости and even though I know who they are (thanks to older kids) I still don't understand the reference as I wasn't born in that time and I don't understand how it could be funny.
If say Золушка made a reference to Gilagans island или quoted something from a black and white movie the majority of the world today wouldn't get it, или even understand it was a quote. Something that pertains to time is when it hasn't changed in centuries. The way women act HAS changed so Ты can't really say that the way they act is from the time. However the way we speak HAS'NT changed, we still use formal literature, something like YOLO would be a product of the time. Even the humor of something can be a "now" thing. Like in Рапунцель - Запутанная история how Flynn says "I don't sing" but then they point their knives at him and he sings, that too can be Остаться в живых to the future generation.
CGI, Big eyes and internet slang are from the current time. Even pawned Kristoff сказал(-а) about his sleigh "but I just paid it off" none of the classics make any reference to cars. Also how Anna says "foot size doesn't matter" and "all men do it" Ты don't see the classics doing that because it's set in the time period of the movie (1300's for Sleeping Beauty ect.) Why would Ты do anything that hints to the time it was made if Ты want it to be classic. We don't ride in wagons anymore so if SnowWhite were to say "But I paid 16 whole shillings for that" we don't know what shillings are или that she actually didn't have to pay it slowly over time. In the Далее 100 или so years I can assume we either won't being using cars или it'll be MUCH different. If Ты put any modern references in the mouth of a classic DP Ты can tell the difference and why one is classic and one is modern или revival или renaissance.


324anna commented…
I see what Ты mean, but those things never bothered me in the movies, I dislike how they've made Anna and Rapunzel еще modern though.

hajirah4 commented…
OH. We're getting DEEP here! :O This is a pretty awesome debate. I'm on BellRose's side, Дисней was a big competitor for... the cartoon that produced Betty Boop, (Warner Bros?) and their competitors weren't timeless, obviously. There were many adult jokes and extreme themes associated with them and the way Дисней beat their funny material was by making sure everything was classical- just like it came from a storybook. That's why we see Aurora being wakened up by the Phillip and not Tom and Jerry. That's what sets Дисней apart from, every other competitor it had. While a lot of it's Фильмы were kind of giving in to the competitor bowl, the classics are remembered and treasured today because they're timeless. They never get old. Frozen, Despicable Me, Rio, Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs? I don't think anyone will remember them. (I don't wanna be really harsh and say Brave, because it was a decent movie and did a great job at being timeless.
The story itself, wasn't that great imo.) And look at Wall-E, Up, Finding Nemo, Toy Story, Monsters Inc- everyone will remember them. And there were some sly modern jokes hidden amongst the ones I listed, but a fad will soon come to fade. Okay, where am I going with this? I'm not saying that Аладдин won't be remembered, heck Мулан is just growing from internet famous and the Black Cauldron has always stayed internet famous :( My point is, being timeless is what sets Дисней apart from Bluesky studious, Warner Bros, etc... Холодное сердце wouldn't even have to be classic for it to be a really huge hit like Toy Story, but when the story lacks depth and the modern jokes fill up for it, there's a problem. That's all I'm saying. I don't think that having modern jokes will make a movie forgettable in the future. I'm saying that an average story can get forgotten. Filler jokes only add in them. But look at ATLA. They're pretty modern, but aside, they have the 'normal' formula I was talking about.


MalloMar commented…
I really enjoyed Чтение everyone's opinions on this topic. I agree with a lot of/most of what hajirah and BelleRose said. There are some Фильмы that are made for a certain time period that I adore (Oliver & Company, A Goofy Movie, Aladdin), but the ones that aren't truly are classic. I actually think The Princess and the Frog was a pretty good effort toward "timelessness" Maybe I need to re-watch it, but I don't really remember anything that shouts "2000s"


dimitri_ commented…
I definitely see where you're coming and I do prefer timeless movies. Except if it just oozes the 90s, so bias of me :P and the reasons Аладдин and Hercules are considered classic is because they were in that hand-drawn area IMO.

BelleRose829 commented…
Yeah, basically there is the Museum of Modern Art in New York and there is the Louvre in Paris, the fact of the matter there are both master pieces in their own way, but one is еще traditional and one is expressing what it is in the now. Both are great, I just prefer the Louvre something classic (SnowWhite), but others can still like MoMA (Tangled). They are products of their time and that can last for some time, but it's going to fade. People don't really understand older slang, for a reason they are trends, none of us wear 1940's poodle skirts because that was Популярное then, not now. There is a traditional way of being and it's sticking to a specific time period, jumping in and out of the setting isn't.
The way the way Фильмы taken out of the time is ok this is the 1800's what was going on at this time? Ah right this this and this, oh let's throw in a modern joke about Michael Jackson. Even so they don't reference to famous actors in the 1800's because unless you're a history buff Ты aren't going to get the joke. All the same I can apprieate modern movies, but it's very easy to see that they are made for their time i.e. The Lego Movie, Aladdin, A Goofy Movie, High School Musical, Холодное сердце ect.



And we had a little debate, I thought why not make it formal so I could see what the vast majority thinks. So leave your Комментарии below. :3