WHY DOES EVERYONE HATE THE MOVIE?

I hated it because,

1. Brom is not a storyteller.

2. Эрагон doesn't seem to have any weaknesses in the movie, unlike the book. It makes characters seem еще real when they have weaknesses.

3. Arya was BLOND, and she had ROUND ears.

4. Эрагон was not injured at the end when he defeated Durza, which plays a huge part in Eldest.

5. ORIK WAS NON-EXISTENT!!!

Most of the people who hate the movie are the ones who have read the book. I think the reason why is because they see what an amazing book Эрагон is (although it's a copy of Lord of the Rings) and then they see how crappy the movie is compared to the book and they hate it because if it had just followed the book еще it could have been amazing.

I saw the movie before I read the book and I liked it. Then I read the book a couple years later and loved it but when I watched the movie again I realized how much better the book was. The movie could have been amazing like the Lord of the Rings but instead they completely changed it and messed it up so that it skipped еще than half of the book.
So I think that's why a lot of people hate the movie but correct me if I'm wrong.

Because of how unlike the book it was, there was nothing in the film that made me think this is a good comparison to the book, everything was wrong in the movie, and the movie was short, but they didn't have to do about the whole book, they left out important things, that affect the секунда book aswell, so if they do a секунда movie (I doubt it) it wouldn't be Eldest, they might aswell give it a diffrent name.

The reason i didn't like this movie was because they left a bunch of city's in the movie and also,they had Arya black haired and also whats the deal with Arya, isn't she supposed to have pointed ears?. Also what gets me ticked is that Эрагон fights Durza in the dwarf kingdom were the dragon lair i s(sorry frogot the name of the dwarf fortress)not in the air!?.So man ythings were left out making Ты think i your really watching Эрагон , или some cheesy dragon movie. Also i think that why harry potter is so poplar in movies? because the directors are British and so is the cast. Sadly,American directors like to twist the story.They like to run away with their imagination and never come back, leaving the Автор silently fuming.

Because these books, while they have been called slightly amateur by some, are insanely insightful and well imagined by someone so young. Some of the concepts introduced by oromis' teachings are just beautiful and as a whole the Книги actually manage to standalone in terms of originality, despite what the LOTR bashers say. In terms of this type of fiction, its hard not to write something that has been done in some way before, its about dragons, magic and evil ffs, of course its been written about before. But Paolini STILL managed to write something that stands alone and is memorable and captivating. Now to the question....to have that movie come from these Книги is f*&#en disgusting. Not because its not accurate (which it bloody well ISNT! in the SLIGHTEST!), but because films are GENERALLY going to be seen by the masses еще so than the minority who would rather read it and it absolutely puts Paolini to shame. I feel so bad for him hearing people see the movie and hate on it (as well they should) because they see it as a reflection on his work, which it barely is. The movie should never have been made. If Ты cant do it properly then just don't do it, it is an insult to the Книги and one that tarnishes their memory forever. Oh and also, orcs aren't like urgals at all. AT. ALL...and if Ты think they are then even Tolkien (god rest his soul) would be shaking his head in disgust at you, urgals are like Beorn, if anything. They aren't evil AND THEY ARENT WHAT THE GODDAMN STUPID MOVIE MADE THEM AS! THEY DIDNT EVEN HAVE HORNS!.....god I hate it so much I cant even deal with it. If I ever see the filmmakers on the beat...Jierda theirra kalfis! Im so heartbroken for Ты Paolini, we Любовь ya shurt'ugal x

the movie was so far off from the book and it sucked

Im with Ты lama...I like the movie, even though some of the dialogue was corny. It doesn't matter to me how much unlike the book it is. Also,I doubt this movie had the incredible monetary backing that Lord of the Rings had in which they actually could afford to put every page of the book into a very LOOOOONG movie...And yet people unfairly compare everything to Lord of the Rings. I think this movie had it where it counts, a good story, character, and even heart. I really want to see this series continue on the big screen.

Because it sucks compared to the books. The movie has a completely different stroy line to the Книги because they changed it soooooo much!!!!!!

i dont hate it i lovee it its so goooooooooood

wow,lamadragon, how in the hell ru an Эрагон Фан if u Любовь the movie???? it was HORRIBLE. the worst. nothing was right. not evn going to go into the details. did u read the book at all? i guess not, cuz that movie really p-oed me. read the book, then watch the movie. thats all im gonna say.

Saphira looked great, but that's pretty much it. Angela was a short curled haird women in the book, but in the film she was (meant to be) pretty with jewls like an ordinary fortune teller.

Because the movie was almost nothing compared to the book and it wrapped up the entire series even though the 4th book isnt even out yet

? Nobody likes the movie?!! I Любовь the movie and the video game. even if some things are different it is still a good movie.

people dont like it because the director/producer/peopel cut and changed it so much. half the things which would be important in the Далее three Книги where cut out. they got the ending wrong. they should re-do it.
and what about the crazy witch child. i forgot her name but she is important

the movie is pretty good, but I dont like it as much as the Книги coz of:

1. Durza kills Brom in the movie, but its supposed to be the ra'zac

2. Saphira does the really retarted growing up all of a sudden

3. Эрагон doesn't Показать the traders the stone

4. Orik isn't in it

5. Arya has red hair in the movie and round ears, when she should have black hair and pointy ears

There is a lot more!!

I really liked the movie but maybe it's cause I haven't read the Книги :/

I actually Любовь the movie but the book was kinda better..

the movie is screwed up and is nothing like the book and what is suposed to b like the book is wrong. They couldn't even get a elf или a uragal right.

I actually Любовь the movie. I think that, as a movie, it wasn't so bad at all.
If we want to compare it with the book, it's completley different story. But they couldn't make a movie and keep everything from the book. Even Peter Jackson couldn't do that in trilogy LOTR.
Only thing I don't like is the fact that Saphira grows really fast in the movie, and it just doesn't go that way. They should've done a movie with еще baby Saphira scenes. She was so adorable. And Murthagh. Garrett was cute in that movie.
lol

i'm with Ты lama, i loved the movie, i don't really care that dialogue(sp?) wasn't in it, but i do think that the book was better

i dont i Любовь the Книги and the movie. they are both kool

Because Stupid 20th century лиса, фокс messed it up so that the only simelaritys were the names and the whole Riders thing.

I don't hate the movie as a movie, but compared to the book there are almost no similarities. And I think the book is better. And it does kinda seem like it copies off of other movies. The book doesn't, but the movie does. I really loved the book and the movie seperatly, though.

alot of things were left out wicth sucked

Dude, have Ты read the book?? The movie is crap compared to the book.1.The appearance of the characters was totally wrong 2. The events were mixed up and tons of them were missed out 3.Eragon had to name Saphira ( who had feathers!!! wtf!!)not she to tell him her name and they skipped off to a strong bond right away and it was not like that!!

So many things were wrong , they cannot make a sequel unless they make up a whole new story!!

It's nothing like the book. Эрагон never got captured, или meet Orik, and Arya doesn't leave in the end of the book. The book was so much better, and since the movie wasn't like the book at all, people don't like it.