fanpop's got talent Should Mock Entries Be Up For Voting?

This question is now closed
16 fans picked:
yes but in they&# 39; re own catagory
yes but in they're own catagory
   81%
yes
   19%
no
no votes yet
 amazondebs posted Больше года
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

13 comments

user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
amazondebs picked yes but in they're own catagory:
for yes- making them have a comedy value is a talent
against yes- people might not want them up to vote

for their own category- people still get regonition but it doesn't over shadow the 'proper talent'
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
johnminh picked yes:
If someone's talent is to mock others, then they should be judged accordingly with everyone else's entries.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
edennirvana picked yes:
I agree with John on this. I think that to 'mock' others or impersonating someone else has comedic value, therefore is a talent. That's my humble opinion. ;)
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
germany123 picked yes but in they're own catagory:
erm..why is this important if we are not voting by category but overall ? if you submit a mock entry and put that its not up for voting( which would be a pity really)...then that settles it!?

categories were important for the fanpoppies where there was a winner in each category..but here?
am i missing something? as bailey would put it- the big picture?
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
amazondebs picked yes but in they're own catagory:
it's not categories as such more like it's own little award
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
germany123 picked yes but in they're own catagory:
so mock entries get their own award apart from everything else!?

are we done with the special achievement award then!?

cause we might end up having more awards than entries ;D
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
amazondebs picked yes but in they're own catagory:
hmmm wasn't the special achievement award to go through till the next round? and we don't have rounds now *is confused*
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
germany123 picked yes but in they're own catagory:
just so i can take it oot of the soapbox..ok so ALL entries will be voted on by the fanpoppers! will edit that :)
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
amazondebs picked yes but in they're own catagory:
"oot" hehe

sorry will focus erm yes
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Shandiii picked yes:
How about whoever uploads a mock entry or whatever can choose whether they want it to be up for voting, or if it's just for fun?
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
claire-aka-bob picked yes but in they're own catagory:
but when they add an entry they should know it is most likely to be up for voting anyway, so if they dont want it to be up for voting there is not much point in them uploading it?

i think they will be in their own catagory looking at this pick debs, maybe you should put a closing date on it? ♥
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Wait so could I mock something famous in like, a poem let's say. Or a song? I don't get this exactly.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
yes but in they&# 39; re own...
amazondebs picked yes but in they're own catagory:
okay a mock entry is basically a mimic of those terrible auditions you get on these talent competitions that don't have a cat in hells chance of getting through but their fun to watch e.g. singing exceptionally badly or writing a comedy sketch that is just filled with bad puns
posted Больше года.