Ответить на этот вопрос

Властелин колец Вопрос

Could Sauron ever redeem himself and be good again, if he were дана the choice? (I want your opinion, not Tolkien's writing)

 DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
next question »

Властелин колец Ответы

redwallwriter said:
No, he could not. He was fully evil, and there was no turning back for him.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
NordicVeronica1 said:
No, Sauron had gone far beyond recall of good will when he first made the One Ring. He could not redeem himself now, after all this time.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
BlackHound said:
I find the idea ridiculous.

Sauron was the mightiest of the Maia. He knew Good and Evil, and he chose Evil. He had literally thousands of years to repent and redeem himself if he'd wanted to.

Clearly, he didn't want to. But your Вопрос was could he, and I will say no, absolutely not. The blood of millions was on his hands, millions he willfully slaughtered, either by order или by his own hand, and Ты can not be redeemed after that stain.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
hotsnowsels said:
I don't think so. Someone who had committed that fully to darkness could not just turn good again. He made a choice a long time ago, a choice that would stand for all eternity. He was still made by Iluvatar, and hence is good in the sense that he had a purpose, but he placed himself on the side of evil through his own grievous fault, and there is nothing in him now that would ever even compel him to think of fighting for good.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Эй, there, fellow fanguin! 8D
ImAnEasel posted Больше года
*
Heyyyyyy! ;D I found this spot because of you, actually. I followed the link from your profile.
hotsnowsels posted Больше года
twilightilove14 said:
Yes, I think he could. I think if he were дана the chance he could turn good, I don't really think hes evil Ты know he could be as good as Gandalf if he was дана the chance! He could get over the evil, power wanting and all that stuff and be good, you'd never even know he was evil. I think still hes not all bad, he just wants people to think that so hes "Powerful" Ты know, and, I bet hes good underneath it all. :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Judging by my name, I'd have to agree with you. Now I'll give Ты what I found. Sauron was corrupted and totally screwed over (in all senses of the word) by Morgoth. Now, THIS GUY is purely evil. But if Ты ask me, he sucks donkey butt. Любовь you, Sauron!!
DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
*
I think he Остаться в живых his chance to ever be good a looonngg time ago. :b
redwallwriter posted Больше года
*
LOL xD
twilightilove14 posted Больше года
lovingcookies9 said:
I don't think so. The ring is pure evil and corrupts the beholder. And since Sauron's life is connected to the ring techniqually a part of him will always be evil whether he chose to be good или not. So he will always be corrupt.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
lovedoctor_36 said:
No. he can never redeem himself. he can die alone for all i care. i aint good and never will be.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Ah, Ты might want to check your answer. The end says Ты aren't good and never will be.
DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
*
Lol!
twilightilove14 posted Больше года
ImAnEasel said:
Um... No.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Erowen99 said:
1 its SARUMAN
2 no he has tens of thousands of orcs IF Ты have seen the 2nd movie
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
No, I'm asking about Sauron. The dude who made the One Ring. My Иконка is a picture of him. No, Saruman the White is just a creeper.
DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
*
ok
Erowen99 posted Больше года
*
plus he is a soul i think he is freaky like the big brother eye
Erowen99 posted Больше года
CCGSDI said:
Personally, I believe that if Sauron was дана the choice to redeem himself, he would kill whoever gave him that choice, probably bringing on another war. Sauron's mind was penetrated and manipulated so much by the original dark lord, morgoth, that he would and will never be able to even think a kind thought, it's not possible for him.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Maybe. But it's still funny to picture the two of them in the Void and Sauron going ballistic raging at Morgoth for making him evil and screwing up his life.
DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
Alchir said:
Well there was the instance in the silmarilion when he сказал(-а) he had repented but when told to go back to valinor and await manwes trial he fled, but sauron in the third age could not redeem himself no matter what he was to steeped in evil and even Остаться в живых some powers to this. Just remembered that after the ring was destroyed he became a powerless spirit so hes got a lot of time thinking about what he had done

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
True, although knowing Sauron, he's еще likely to spend that time raging at Morgoth for making him evil.
DarkLordSauron posted Больше года
bibytuna said:
No he is the devil
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »