Ответить на этот вопрос

Сумерки (серия романов) Вопрос

Do Ты think Edward was kinda being an asshole in some parts of Eclipse?

dont get me wrong im team edward and Любовь him but do Ты think he was being a jerk when he wouldnt let bella visit jacob and held her captive at his house when he went hunting?

just say your thoughts if Ты liked that he was being that protective или if u thought he was a little controlling.
*
i havent even readf that book j/k
alissa_kyo posted Больше года
 itailianjr120 posted Больше года
next question »

Сумерки (серия романов) Ответы

sapherequeen said:
Very interesting that you'd call him an asshole where millions of Edward fanatics will see it written in the question, haha :)

Hmmm...I wouldn't say he's being an asshole but he is kind of going over the line. Bella obviously didn't appreciate being locked away from the outside world because of Victoria, and the not-visiting-Jacob thing is just wrong. He says he's fine with Bella seeing Jacob, but he sure didn't act fine with it, he should have just admitted he didn't like it. Now, if Ты really want me to say the time I thought he was an asshole, it was when he wanted to kill Renesmee. I wanted to slap him at that moment for a handful of reasons...

Well, that's what I think :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I agree with u sapherequeen.. He was an a** when he wanted to give bella an abortion ...but he's still the sh**!!
twilightGGlost posted Больше года
*
that's soo true!
babina posted Больше года
shadowcullen09 said:
yes i think that.becuz @ da end of eclipse, he wanted to make bella a vampire @ da end n charlie juzt got серовато-коричневый, dun, дун tellin her if she gonna leve или sumdin she has 2 warn him b4 do n e thinf. so ......yeah
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
twilight1999 said:
no i think he's just trying protect bella
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
babina said:
noooppp!!! its in his nature 2 b overprotective so i can't blame him at all!! actual in some parts of that bk i think he was too patient! LOL if it was me i would have kicked some жопа, попка out of jake already!!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Thats true, Jake got out of hand quite a few times and Edward because of Bella behaved very well.
Dayli posted Больше года
lindashami said:
no, not at all! edward is completly right! bella is still too fragil and can get off guard easily!

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Dayli said:
I know that he was Актёрское искусство like very controlling over him but i understood the reason why... remember that Bella was only human and Jacob can be very dangerous when he is upset. Remember that if Jacob would have Остаться в живых control and hurt Bella, Edward would have killed Jacob. So i don't think he as being am a*s. I also read that some of Ты were upset that he wanted Bella to have an abortion, once again remember that Bella was human and she would have die if he wouldn't have acted so quickly after she gave birth, well Nessie rip herself out. So once again Edward was protecting Bella.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »