Why do Ты think Bella might be better off with Jacob? Why not?

Jacob is very sweet and would be great for bella because he allows her to have an adventure and protects her at the same time, unlike edward because her over-protects her and doesn't give her enough space! Also he does have a temper but from bella's vision with them together with kids i am sure that wouldnt be a problem because he wouldnt have anything to get angry about. Also he is waaaaay better looking than edward! I think if edward had died in italy by the volturi bella would of had a fantastic life with jacob but i suppose there would alawys be somthing missing because she would not be able to get over edward. She does Любовь jacob; but she likes edward better and even though i want to do somthing about it; i cant.
P.S I'm sorry i couldnt find a hotter picture of jacob on my computer so i used this smiley one!

× I think she should have been with Jacob, she is еще relaxed around him, he gave her freedom, and yet, he made sure she was safe, he loved her and made sure she never got hurt, he controlled his temper and around her so I would think that they are perfect together, but, Edward and Bella are soul mates, and Jake and Bella arn't, so, it wouldn't be possible to work out.

Well, I'm not going to say Edward is better или Jacob isn't good for Bella because not only am I respecting Ты this way, I really don't think either of these things are true.

I just simply think Edward and Bella were meant to be. Plus, without them being together, there wouldn't be sweet, gorgeous Renesmee ^_^

I just think Jacob and Bella are excellent, fantastic, great Друзья and I would Любовь to have one of them as a friend too :)

Bella SHOULD have stayed with Jacob.He's always there for her, he loves her too much, and he is not an overprotective geek like Edward.He's cute and funny, and he makes her laugh all the time.He is a great friend and obviously a great lover...That's why I think Bella should have stayed with him, and I'm really happy he eventually imprinted on someone who appreciates him and loves him as much as he deserves...Oh, and by the way, BELLA SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm not going to say that Edward is better или what..I'm a Team Switzerland....So, my answer is this....

Bella have the freedom to choose whoever she wants to be with. If she like Edward fine,If she chose Jacob then good. She loves them both and she doesn't want to hurt them. But from the start Bella already loves Edward Cullen. I would also Любовь Bella for Jake but I think Nessie's better for him. And they're good buddies, for me that's already nice. If she chose Jacob and have a baby with him it's fine with me. but I guess some Фаны will be angry and ask "Why didn't Bella choose Edward,why that Jacob?" so, it's just the same thing или I mean same thing will happen. So, it's just up to her.Let her see who's the right man for her. And besides,they're both a good man & a partner for Bella.So, whoever she chose I think she'll be безопасно, сейф and she will be in good arms. xD

Jacob is better for her because he´s sweet and cute and he would always bye her side[like a dog].
And Edawrd are so...[sorry]ugly!A time назад i liked him but now...Not really.
My answer is Jacob is better for her

definately not.. Jacob has too much of a temper.. Edward is so sweet and such a gentleman, he and Bella have a special connection, and they dazzle each other frequently =)

in my opinion whoever she chooses would be right for her. i think that they are both really good for her and that they would care for and Любовь her no matter what. so whether she chooses jacob или edward she would be in good care.

he is a better person and is HOT and he loves her a lot

Personally I Любовь jacob, and I think he should have been with Bella, but at the same time she doesn't deserve him, he would do anything for bella, anything in the world for her. Protect her, care for her, anything, and when she has an emotional breakdown who was there to drag her out of it, then she leaves him hurt in the end. Its all to sad for a jacob Фан like myself. BUt in my opinion jacob and bella should have ended up together.

bella gets еще from edward..he's made 4 her and she's made 4 him..jacob is younger and although he knows she's in Любовь with ed he's still stuck on her..he begs her,he promises never to hurt her..i get it he loves her but when Любовь is only one way it's not Любовь any more..does anybody gets what i'm saying....???

Bella won't have to change herself for Jacob. She could still see her family and friends. Besides, if she becomes a vampire, she might find Edward less attractive and he might find her less good-smelling.

sh seems better with jacob cuz it seems like she likes him еще nd she seems еще relxed...nd i think jacob is really cute nd they make a cute couple. i am just sayin i think they look better together (:

I guess she would be better of with Jacob, cause he was like not so over-protective and she could act еще free with him. He let her еще do her won things.
But I honestly feel, that bella and Edward are meant for each other.
So I sometimes didnt understand Bella actually, I know her сердце beats for Edward and NOT for Jacob, THATS why Bella HAS to be with Edward!!!
She would always regret if she wouldnt do so...!

Bella should have stayed with Jacob because he would always have been there for her, and her dad would have approved of him. Another reason is that he won't suck her blood! Edward is very dangerous and Bella should think of her well being before love.

because bella and jacob have each other since they were kids and he treats her with respect and realli luvs her when she's going edward a guy she barely knows.

well i think bella is better off with jacob because he's always there for her
they seem like they always have lots of fun together
they have a great bond
and when edward left, i think she said"jacob fills the hole in my heart. "

Bella should have gone off with Jake because he makes her happy, he's smart, handsome, he's kind, and courageous!!! They knew each other whe they were kids and when she broke off from Edward, they formed a strong, yet passionate friendship. He would do anything for her, even play секунда best!!! i mean the guy pulled her out of that darkness when Edward left and he helped fill the void in her heart!!!. If it weren't for Jacob, Bella would be dead!! Personally i think Bella was just too much of a coward to admit she had fallen in Любовь with Jake and felt obligated to stay with Edward when she rescued him in Italy. Now i do like Edward but Jake is a much better suitor in the sense she wouldn't have to give up her soul или humanity for him!!!

i completely agree with most other answers. bella and edwards relation is colder, yeah,maybe this is like this to emphasize that edward is a vampire.Jacob timidly falls in Любовь with Bella, he kinda venerates her as some sort of goddess and is happy to see her do what she wants while watching over her, whereas edward sometimes is overprotective, not to mention that due to some of edwards vampire traits Bella also has to herself, for example, by not going to La Push или to places with sunlight due to edward being exposed. in bella-edward relationship, bella has to sacrifice a lot for him, whereas jacob-bella they both get to enjoy their time together without worries. furthermore, Edward and Bella are not truly in Любовь but impulsed by their instincts and lust: Edward is infatuated with Bella's scent and intrigued that he cant read her mind, and Bella is Зачарованные by Edward's vampire charm, say, his looks,his voice and his smell. he himself told bella that as the ultimate predator everything in him was intended to lure her and make her vulnerable. bella and edward are еще obsessed with each other than truly in love. with jake on the other hand, there are no werewolf traits that lure one to each other. when it comes to being in Любовь they could just be like any average teenager. i really think Meyer was very unfair with jacob. and it doesnt give a nice message. lust and obsession overpower love.really...

hummm were do i start ok her it goes
well for a start jacob protects bella еще than edward. edwar alowed Вампиры to practicly kill her were as jacob was there in a flash to protect her
2ed edward left her n broke her сердце n jacob was there for her
so yea there some resons for jacob n bella

Jacob is wayyy better for Bella....Edward is selfish and way 2 obsessed with her even tho it is just a movie!!! :)

Because it always looks like "Edward" is going to puke EVERY time he kisses her, and Jacob actually strives for Bella's affections.