Диснеевские принцессы

Ответить на этот вопрос

Диснеевские принцессы Вопрос

Why do Фаны enjoy sucking the fun out of Дисней Фильмы by pointing out "plot-holes"?

I mean, seriously, I was watching Рапунцель - Запутанная история the other day, and some stupid woman was whining, "Why didn't Mother Gothel change the дата of Rapunzel's b-day? So many questions!" Эй, dumbass! Why don't Ты ask the directors yourself!! Also, Ты can't hate a movie just for one simple little mistake или so-called "plot hole"! I don't think it is possible for a movie to be 100% plot-hole free или not having the Ответы to every Вопрос out there. Everybody loved Beauty and the Beast despite its failure to tell us how long Belle stayed at Beast's castle. People enjoyed the Little Mermaid despite the movie not Показ us how Ariel got interested in humans. Everybody enjoyed the Toy Story 1-3 despite the Pixar guys not wanting to address what happened to Andy's father. So, why can't we enjoy Рапунцель - Запутанная история for what it is, despite its failure to address why Mother Gothel didn't change the дата of Rapunzel's b-day? Please stop randomingly pointing out flaws/plot-holes in movies. IIt takes out the joy out of someone's movie time. Nobody likes a kill joy! If Ты think Ты can make a movie better than Дисней или other movie studio, then why don't Ты do it yourself, Mrs. I'm-so-smarter-than-other-movie-studios?
*
Guys, I don't mean criticizing Дисней (and non-Disney Фильмы in general. I mean people who criticize Фильмы to the point where people who enjoyed them don't like them anymore. And to the point where the critic themselves, don't like the movie. The woman that asked the Вопрос wasn't being polite; she was whining. She was always complaining about any Дисней movies; so it is not like it was the first time it happened.
fahmad27 posted Больше года
 fahmad27 posted Больше года
next question »

Диснеевские принцессы Ответы

princesslullaby said:
Discussing how a Дисней movie could be improved isn't sucking the fun out of it. In fact, if you're not willing to criticize a Дисней movie and admit that it has flaws, then Ты don't really Любовь it. Blindly loving a film and trying to claim that nothing is wrong with it means Ты don't care about the improvement of the film, или of the company. If you're criticizing a movie, that means Ты want it to do better. You're not a real Дисней Фан if you're not able to discuss and point out the faults.
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I do not mean criticizing Дисней movie (and any other movie) in general. I meant people who judged a movie too much while watching it to the point where other viewers don't enjoy it.
fahmad27 posted Больше года
hajirah4 said:
RANDOMLY. I think fahmad27 meant when people RANDOMLY become kill-joys. I think that's what everyone else doesn't see as the key-word. I see it loud and clear, and I agree. Criticizing a Дисней movie while you're watching it is stupid in some cases. But I think you're (fahmad27) confusing curiosity with kill-joy questions.

In the first sentence Ты made a big tantrum over some little question. We don't do that here. We only do it at the perfect time. Like in Опросы that say "Do Ты Think Ariel Is Too Selfish?" etc...

So...your Вопрос is not really that valid....
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Wendy_Darling said:
I don't see how the birthday thing is even a plot hole. It was just Mother Gothel's mistake, a human mistake, not a flaw in the story. It makes her еще real :)
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TheCrystalRing said:
...We do not enjoy 'sucking the fun' out of Дисней films. Debating about how something could have been better is called constructive criticism , and if something или someone can't take it, then I don't see how they had survived so long in this world. The Earth is full of criticism! Some may disagree with others, but everyone has their opinions! Just take a look at all the Опросы on here; they're FULL of criticism! Criticizing something IS enjoying it! So if Ты want people to stop criticizing movies, then Ты should just leave this site; that's all that is on here!
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I am not accusing people here for doing that. I don't mean criticizing in general either. I am talking about people who criticized Фильмы to the point where other viewers cannot enjoy them. I judge other Фильмы too but at least I try to analyze it myself unlike the other girl.
fahmad27 posted Больше года
dimitri_is_hot said:
I agree with the 2 above. But I understand how some people take it too far and are just being biased.
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Snickerz911411 said:
Dude...I think your taking it a bit to far. Yeah I think it is stupid for some women to ask a Вопрос like that during a movie but not everyone is going to enjoy Tangled. I don't see any plot holes in the film. And sometimes I do point out some ACTUAL plot holes in films, not just Disney. Does that mean I hate them? Not really. I think Ты need to calm down. All that women did was ask a Вопрос during the movie. Some people do that. I have a bad habit of doing it but I do it as a movie critic.
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
The woman was really whining. It wasn't the first time she did this. She does this almost every time we popped a movie in.
fahmad27 posted Больше года
Jessikaroo said:
It's healthy to turn a critical eye towards the things we Любовь most, it's bad to blindly Любовь something. If we weren't critical of things, how would they improve?

PS - What did Andy's dad's absence have to do with the story? It was too expensive to render humans at the time.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I'm not blindly lovig something. I had a few complaints about Рапунцель - Запутанная история too. (Why do Rapunzel and Flynn talk like modern teenagers despite living in the early 18th century ?) I was just annoyed that some woman was hating one movie all because of one movie mistake.
fahmad27 posted Больше года
maryksand said:
Seeing as Ты don't mean constuctive criticism but blatant bias and nitpicking I actually do agree with Ты that it's an incredibly pointless activity that contributes to no productivity или detailed and insightful analysis. With that said, pointing at plot holes and inconsistency of certain storylines in order to address those issues so that Дисней would maybe learn and tries to get better later on with their newer Фильмы is definitely a positive way of going about criticism.

 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!