If you've never seen it, "Frozen - A Musical Feat. Дисней Princesses" is a Youtube video by Youtube user AVbyte. To form an opinion on it, Ты should watch it at this link: link

I already Опубликовано a not-so-popular Форум post about it, which I quote here: "Has anyone seen the video "Elsa- I Don't Need a Man"? In this video, Elsa sings to the classic-er princesses (Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora, Ariel, Belle, and Jasmine) It infuriates me for two reasons.

1. She shames the other princesses for falling in love/wanting to fall in love. For one, not all of them were lovesick ninnies- Belle and жасмин wanted adventure, Belle didn't let Gaston woo her, and жасмин didn't appreciate being treated like a prize. And is it really so bad that the others fell in love? They were classic fairytale Фильмы made in a classic time period. Their Любовь stories were unrealistic, yes, but Elsa should not shame them because they were products of their time.

2. If any princess should be Пение this song, it should be Mulan, Tiana, Merida (much as I hate her), Jasmine, или others. NOT Elsa! I'm sick of everyone Актёрское искусство like she's such a strong role model just because she has ice powers and doesn't get married. To me, she is a weak role model, weaker than Snow White, because at least Snow can stay positive and happy and make the best of a bad situation. All Elsa does is shut everyone out and run away from her problems, leaving the kingdom to freeze.

The one good thing about that video is that the vocals were really nice :)"

Well, Ты get most of the idea there, but now I'm doing an in-depth analysis:

First 6 секунды of video: Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora, Belle and жасмин are marveling as Ariel shows off, in a ditsy, nasal, "girly" voice, a fake hair цветок that Eric got her.

Just opening up to this video I am already annoyed. They are depicting all of these classic-er princesses as ditsy, annoying, cutesy girls. Not that there's really anything wrong with having a "girly" или "cutesy" personality, but this video inaccurately depicts them in a stereotypical way meant to degrade them. Now, Snow White или Aurora, POSSIBLY Золушка или Ariel, might act this way (although not exactly to the extent that this video shows), but since when do жасмин and Belle? In both of their films, especially BATB, other "ditsy" girls like the blonde sisters или the belly dancers were shown in a way that contrasts the female leads who we know and love.

0:06-0:12: Elsa, with a snooty expression on her face, sings: "Why does every princess need to have a prince? It's the same old story but I'm just not convinced"

Um, hello? Merida, anybody? (And it's not like they have the excuse of forgetting her, Холодное сердце was made after Храбрая сердцем came out, let alone all the strong princesses they're clearly forgetting about.) There are many other princesses, like Mulan, Tiana, Pocahontas, etc, who are strong enough to get along without their prince, but nope, they're in love, and that's clearly not strong enough for Elsa!

0:13: "Why keep on assuming men will save the day?"

Again, Elsa, we just went over how so many princesses don't need a man to save them. They often work together with their prince, или even save their prince. And for the classic princesses, they are products of their time. We have so many strong princesses now, and that doesn't mean the ones who got saved by a prince are bad.

0:17: "I can be the hero and do it my own way!"

Actually, Elsa, Ты were not the hero of your story! Elsa mainly created the problem in Frozen, and Anna's act of Любовь saved the day, but nooo, Anna fell in Любовь so she can't be Пение this! Again, another princess really should be Пение this.

0:20: "Why be confined to be hiding behind true love? Enough! I'm who I am, I don't need a man."

These princesses who Ты are mocking are not "hiding behind true love". What does that even mean? Each of the princesses Ты can pretty much describe without using the words "her prince" или something like that. And if Ты don't think Ты can, Elsa или anyone who thinks that, then maybe you're the offensive one.

0:33: "(to Snow White) Ты got slipped a roofie. (to Jasmine) Ты fell for a cheat. (to Cinderella) Ты got really lucky that you've got tiny feet. (to Belle) You've got Stockholm Syndrome. (to Aurora) You're a spoiled brat. (to Ariel) Ты had special talents but gave them up like that!"

This really bothers me. She is making fun of all the other princesses. For Snow White, she was tricked by the witch, and yes, she shouldn't have opened the door, but she was just being her kind, open-hearted self. жасмин fell for a man who really loved and admired her. He may have lied, but she saw past his flaws for who he really was. Золушка did get really lucky, but is there any еще recognized story than hers? As for Belle, I hate it when people say she has Stockholm syndrome! She fell for the Beast once he started being kind to her. Unrealistic, yes, but Elsa still has no right to put her down for a silly, inaccurate reason like that. How on earth is Aurora a spoiled brat? Really, tell me why, because that makes NO sense. And yes, Ariel did give up her voice for a kind of silly plan, but Elsa could certainly look up to how spunky and determined she is!

0:54: After repeating what she sang in 0:20, Elsa sings "Please understand Ты don't need a man". жасмин says "You haven't found him yet."

Would жасмин really say this? In her movie she сказал(-а) she didn't want to marry someone unless she was ready and truly loved the man. I'm sure she would say the same for women everywhere, but again, this video replaces their actual personalities with generic, stereotypical, ditsy princesses.

1:00: The Princesses sing: "When you're in love, head over fin, nothing else matters, nothing but him. Follow your dreams, odd as that seems to be."

This is yet another inaccurate stereotype. The princesses know how to follow their dreams, whatever those dreams happen to be. That's what they're known for! They did not abandon all other areas of life for their princes. For example, Belle was in Любовь with the Beast, but still tried to help her father.

1:11: The princesses sing "When you're in love, life is a song. All happy endings never go wrong. 'Cept when they do, sadly that's true. Who knew."

It's true that Любовь isn't always easy, and sometimes Дисней Фильмы have somewhat unrealistic relationships in them. However, true Любовь is one of the most beautiful things in life and the princesses Показать that Ты can follow your dreams, and Любовь can prevail. Besides, not all of the princesses have perfect relationships. Pocahontas had to leave her love, and Anna fell too soon for a man with dark intentions, but this video ignores both of them.

1:22: Belle: "I dreamed of daring quests" Ariel: "Seeing the world from east to west" Cinderella: "Instead we just sit inside" Aurora: "Stuck in this princess stereotype"

What?? Belle did get her daring quest, and Ariel finally saw the world (some of it, at least) once she got to land with Eric. They both fell in love, but that didn't mean they had to forfeit their dreams. "Just sit inside"? No way! When, in ANY of their movies, did the princesses sit around all day, at least by choice? The princess stereotype is what this video is inaccurately promoting, not the Дисней movies!

Basically the rest of the song is repeated other stuff and Elsa pretending to be some fierce girl-power goddess. I don't want to talk in circles so I'm just going to make my main points:

1. Stop pretending Elsa is so strong just because she has ice powers, sings "Let it Go" and doesn't fall in love. She is the main problem in Frozen, and she doesn't do anything to solve it. If Ты want a strong animated leading lady, look to some in the Далее point....

2. Again, if any of the princesses should sing this song, it would be Jasmine, Belle, Mulan, Tiana, Merida или others. Not that I support making fun of other princesses, but if it's going to happen it shouldn't be Elsa at all.

3. I wish people would appreciate the princesses' actual personalities instead of forgetting all of their wonderful qualities and forming them into a ditsy, cutesy, damsel-in-distress mold. жасмин was outspoken, Мулан was brave, Belle was smart, Merida could shoot a bow and arrow, Золушка was optimistic, and Snow White was cheerful and kind to all. That video somehow took those qualities away from all the other princesses and placed them onto Elsa, who had very little good quality like that.

Thank Ты for Чтение my article, if Ты have any ideas или opinions please Комментарий and tell me what Ты think!