i thought that was pretty obvious so far. Martha's cool... but its Rose we're tlking about - Rose!

I really like Martha, she has huge potential, but Rose is Rose. Although I would prefer to travel with the Doctor ;o)

I think Martha is much better then Rose - for a start she's not completely thick! I must admit Rose did grow on me by the end of series one but she always slightly annoyed me :/

Rose 100% Rose was my first assistant and I grew really attatched to her, I've tried to like Martha and almost did in the first 2 episode of Series 3 then she gradually just got worse and worse, boring to watch now

BRING BACK ROSE!!!!!!!

there's no-one but rose

Martha is a doctor (well almost) - that's a huge positive!

ROSE RULES I think that she was the best assistant ever and they should bring her back!

she was cool, loved her chemistry with both dr.'s

Martha, not by a country mile, but say the current 55%-45% in MARTHA'S favour

Yep; I gotta go with the competent companion.

Cap'n Jack or the Doctor ;)

I vote Martha. Rose is alright, but I always found her character to be a bit too fluffy, a bit too perfect, and naive.

Have to go for the intelligent, to repeat what people have already said, Rose was annoying and was really thick at times!

I love Martha, but Rose will always be my favourite. I really miss her! Freema's doing a great job though!

Martha - she just knows more. I'd be more safe with her as well, her being a doctor (albeit a trainee one).

I love 'em both, but I pick Martha because I like her intelligence. She has more maturity, and knows herself better than Rose did - given that she's a few years older, it makes sense. I think I'd get along better with Martha, too.

I am partial to rose and loved that she was so naive at times. I mean honestly if it were me i would be thick too...everything was so different and advanced for her...

Rose was sweet, but Martha holds her own with the Doctor. She's smitten, yes, but not in a mushy way.

i luv doctor who and rose was ok but i thoght she was sooo annoying i think martha is beta cuz she is alot smarter than rose and she aint setting the image of dumb blond like rose did and no offence cuz im blond

LONG LIVE MARTHA SHE ROCKS I H8RTED ROSE IVE BEEN ADDICTED 2 DOCTOR WHO NOW MARTHA IS IN IT

sorry all u rose lovers but martha is the best 4 me

Matha is much better...shes intelligent, funny and sexy!

rose, shes got the boobs, and she is the sluttiest :P

rose is sooo way better than martha cos in my opinion the doctor wastes time explaining stuff to martha :) and the episodes with martha in them arent as good, sorry, but thats what i think

Actually I think the new episodes were amazing! Such good stories! I think they're better than the last two seasons and that's partly why I like Martha so much! But I still adore Rose and miss her so much. :(

she is the best

I would prefer The Doctor or Captn Jack! Martha still kind of annoys me.

i like rose more but i would rather travel with martha

me too casspass i would rather travel with the doctor or captain jack

I prefer the Doctor.. and i like martha! But Rose is Rose i still miss her!

Bring back Roooose

i love martha she can actually do something as appose to rose; but for the doctor rose is better

i see theres no Captain Jack or the Doctor :(
oh well has to be Rose then :D
yeyy there all coming back for Series 4!!

Martha. She actually comes up with something intelligent in the episodes and doesn't just screw the Doctor and herself over :p

i dont get it (people choosing freema), but i HAVE to choose rose, of course. freema should be fired, i think she is horrible and cant wait for series four when rose RETURNS!!!!

I Like Rose, But I Got Into The Series When Martha Was In It :)

We are talking about Rose here! She was great!

i thought rose was died!!!??
oh...she is much better than martha OF COURSE!!!!
DANNEEL HARRIS AND ONE TREE HILL FOREVER!!!

martha! Rose was okay and i have nothing really against her but she was too hopeless, and acted like "I saved everyone." Hello you didn't the tardis did through you.

rose is sooo great i do like marther as well

How can ANYONE pick martha no offence but she was crap

Rose was bloody BRILLIANT

i like rose sooooooooooo sooooooooooooo so much i do like martha as well i like both of them

Marther? :')

I preferred Martha. I'm not a Rose-hater, but I just didn't think she was all that special. Martha is wittier and more intelligent and prettier and just all-around made of awesome. I mean, look at how mature she was in Reset in Torchwood. I prefer Martha as a companion to the Doctor and as someone to travel around with.

I love Martha, I really do. She's amazing and strong and her dedication to the Doctor makes a real hero. But Rose...Rose was more human for me. More real, and her relationship with the Doctor was sometimes mushy but you really got to watch her grow.

rose rocks...shes the best companion ever!!!!

martha is just better. her series was cut short. rose is bak on sat for all rose lovers!

Rose was a bit too chavvy and kinda dim... I loved Martha though.. and she seemed to do alot more important eg. single handedly saving the Dr and the world!!!

Martha would get on my nerves.

If I HAD to pick one of them, it would be rose,
but I would much rather travel with The Doctor, or Jenny.

It took so long for Doctor Who To come back. The first actors to me make a stronger lasting impression to me and that makes changes a little harder to get used to. Christopher and Billie made a great team.

rose because she has the style plus her and the doctor are in love

Martha owns Rose. I like them both but Martha is smarter, quicker, stronger (physically and in spirit) she's a real action figure. I liked Chris & Rose together it was great but with David it got too much with Rose going all gooey-eyed. Gotta admit thot she was more than that. Martha overall, is the companion I would feel safer with out of the two, she jus gives that vibe with like the Doctor. With Rose, she's more of a comforter - not always wise

Totally!!!
ROSE ROCKS!!!

Martha because she's no shrinking voilet!

rose just happens to be the worst chracter ever. shes a fake blond for onr, shes a whiny chav who wears way too much makeup. and shes too thick to have a good conversation with and she is a very mysoginistic character.

Rose seems so much more natural in the whole time and space travel, whereas Martha seems better suited to being totally kickass here on Earth. Plus, I have a major girl-crush on Rose.

Martha.She knows how to deal with danger without the Doctor being ready to save her.

can't choose. they are both so cool!

martha. shes a doctor. the medical sort so she could help if you were hurt. rose is nice and all. but she kinda annoys me :D

Rose. But not because the fangirl in me says so...but because I honestly feel that she would be a better companion. Especially now that she has had a few years to mature, I'm pretty sure that Rose would make a very competent companion. Though it would be lovely to throw Capt. Jack in there as well :)

Martha is miles betta than Rose. She spices up the series. rose just goes on an don and sterts to get annoying. And no Rose and the doctor do not make a good couple.

I picked Martha cuz she's smart, sweet and a doctor and she's not a complete drama queen because Rose would get on my nerves. But if I got to chose out of everyone... I would pick either Jack, Donna or the Doctor

I found Rose annoying in Series 2, so it would be Martha for me

rose. She had the strongest relationship with the doctor. They were match-made in heaven! haaa. lool.

If i was the Doctor, I'd pick Rose, but as for myself, Martha is just so clever :)

Rose is so awesome! I found Martha a bit annoying at first, but I got to like her.

Though by far my favorite companion was and always will be Donna Noble.

For one, I'd feel safer with her. Two, Rose kinda annoyed me at times. She was too much of a Mary Sue for my taste.

I'd kick Rose out the door into a supernova, I'm afraid.

I picked Rose cause shes my fav and Martha is just annoying. the only reason i wouldn't pick Rose is cause i would feel like a third wheel with the doctor and rose being in love and stuff.

i dont know why, cause i never stop talking about dr who, but i get bored of rose eps. plus, i think martha is a bit smarter. seen her save the docter in last of the time lords? i mean, what would the doctor do without a companion?

MArtha is terrible , she was nothing like rose !!! martha was the worst excuse for a companion , she never really helpped the doctor and just seemed to be the person to ask the questions!

they both had awesome potential, but Martha is a bit more resourceful, and that's what u need when dealing with novel senarios

Tough, but I choose Rose.

I don't like Martha.

Rose is better,i think
she`s the best assistant for Doctor and they seemed so lovely together
i still miss her

She's a bit whingey, but I prefer her to Martha, although Martha was cool. I admit, Rose was pretty awesome, even though she's not my favourite companion.

I love Rose and Martha

SO STICKING TILED OF ALL THIS ROSE VS MARTHA IT'S OVER MARTHA IS NO LONGER IN LOVE WITH THE DOCTOR GET OVER IT.

Rose is soooooo annoying!!!!!!!

I. Cannot. Stand. Martha.

rose because she is by far the best companion and she always picks up on what the doctor is thinking or saying a lot quicker than martha did. Although I must say martha just annoys me. In my head no-one can beat rose

Rose by far.Martha is a jealous idiot.

Martha :) Rose has been over used and done to death.

shes the best no dout

none. Amy

I like rose better than Martha, but I think Martha would be more fun to travel in time with, she just seems more adventurous.

Martha was so Independent and she travelled the world by herself for a year with the master trying to kill her, I would feel a lot safer with her. I loved Martha she has to be one of my favourite assistants ever just under the loveable gingers Amy and Donna :)

I love Martha and Rose, I really do, and I miss Rose SO much! But I love Rose... Well Martha too... Actually, I'm not picky, I'll just travel through time and space with anybody.

I think Jack should have been an answer.

Martha bugs me, and Rose is my favorite companion.

I loved Rose as a companion. I liked Martha, but unfortunatley I thought her character went a bit down hill when she was lovesick over The Doctor. But then she go over it and became cool again. But I still liked Rose better. I also love Donna and Amy. I would like to travel with The Doctor, Jack, Amy, Donna, Rose, Martha, Mickey and possibly Sarah Jane Smith. That way there would be a lot of people with a variety of skills to help me survive and enjoy traveling through space and Time. I didn't include Rory because he annoys me. :/

Ugh... Martha. She annoyed me to no end.

link

Haha, um yeah, I love Rose!

Rose is a lot cooler and martha WANTED to leave the TARDIS anyway

I love them both, the only one I really didn't like is Donna.

Ah come on, Rose ruled the universe (alongside the doctor)! And they had a THING!

(top secret)David Tennet used to hold his farts in the Tardis Box the fart when Martha came in

It took awhile for Rose to grow on me but once she did i really liked her.It was so hard to watch Rose & the Doctor seperated by that wall between the universes.The Doctor was just about to say "I love you too"& they were seperated.So very sad.

i dont really like Rose

Rose,Id rather be her though,Cos she traveled with the doctor (she never got killed like the last 2100 did) and when the doctor left him he made a another thing of himself so rose could have that doctor.And the doctor shes with gets older so he isnt always like that

Martha is not really my favorite but she was okay and all that. But Rose will be the one.

I love Martha!!! she is awesome