Ответить на этот вопрос

Гарри Поттер Вопрос

When did Lily and James outsmart, или cheat, Voldemort?

In the prophecy it сказал(-а) the parents will have thrice thwarted Lord Voldemort или defied him или something, but when did they do that?
*
Yes, thanks for your Ответы guys, but what I meant was about the prophecy - it сказал(-а) that Voldemort needed to kill the boy whose parents had thrice defied Voldemort - but when did they do that? And when did Nevilles parents thrice defy Voldemort?
Little_Cullen posted Больше года
*
voldemort had forgotten about a very powerful magic, love. when lily and james gave their life, they new that Voldemort could not touch him. They outsmarted him. But in the fourth one, he found a way around the curse that destoyed his body.
Shevasmygirl posted Больше года
*
The sear
dbaird posted Больше года
*
well they were part of the order and couldve done stuff before?
Cailyn192 posted Больше года
 Little_Cullen posted Больше года
next question »

Гарри Поттер  Лучший ответ

Visitor said:
The times Lily and James defied Voldemort as described in the Harry Potter books:

1. They defied him by joining Dumbledore and thus, the revolution against Voldemort's reign.

2. When Voldemort was on his quest to kill Harry they defied him by going into hiding.

3. The night Voldemort tried to kill Harry they defied him by choosing to stand between Voldemort and Harry, rather dying than handing Harry to Voldemort.

I imagine there have been many еще times Lily and James defied the Dark Lord during their time as members of the Order of the Phoenix. We can actually never be certain whether above defiances were the ones meant in the prophecy.


select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
did Ты look this up?
loonylovegood7 posted Больше года
*
yeah. did Ты look it up, или are Ты just that smart?!
Moonwatcher_123 posted Больше года
next question »

Ответы

soxowner32 said:
When the curse backfired on Harry I believe. Instead of it killing him, as it should have, it backfired and destroyed Voldemort's body.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
fanfly said:
Well, I'm not sure every time they defied them is named but Lily, James, Frank and Alice were all members of the Order of the Phoenix so it's obvious that just that act constitutes one defiance and I'm sure there were others during their membership in the order.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
EclecticFan said:
i'm pretty sure we were never told the three times...you might wanna try the lexicon...and i don't think it means Voldemort directly, but rather one of his Death Eaters
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
marie513 said:
They put a spell on their house so voldemort wouldn't know that it was theirs.The only reason he found them was because wormtail, the secret keeper, told him.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Rickrorschach said:
they outsmarted him Хэллоуин night when they were also killed my voldemort. they outsmarted him by protecting harry with their love.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
there was no way it could have been love. that was in there dieing moments. but they had already gone against voldy 3 times BEFORE that. the Вопрос is, what did they do to defy him. there must have been a reason that they were in hiding, while the other members of the order weren't. so obviously they must have done something to really piss voldy off.
slysav posted Больше года
rizzo123456 said:
voldemort had forgotten about a most powerful magic, love. when lily and james gave their life, they new that Voldemort could not touch him. They outsmarted him. But in the fourth one, he found a way around the curse that destoyed his body.
select as best answer
 voldemort had forgotten about a most powerful magic, love. when lily and james gave their life, they new that Voldemort could not touch him. They outsmarted him. But in the fourth one, he found a way around the curse that destoyed his body.
posted Больше года 
LabraLege said:
Well, Sirius once сказал(-а) that now they (Harry) are young, not him... We'll never know what was their fighting form (please, Rowling, tell us еще :))) but I can imagine that it was almost like trio's fighting, only without The Choosen One, hopeless... Really, let's write a petition to Rowling!
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
mark96 said:
12 years ago
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
hahahahha nice answer
jackie5starr posted Больше года
*
what do Ты mean by 12 years ago???????????????
vihangana1201 posted Больше года
Kronous said:
i know one: when lily sacerfied her self to protect him

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
dylin1 said:
I don't know... I'm just gonna agree with the best answer.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
hehe... same... :P
Moonwatcher_123 posted Больше года
loveizcool said:
the prophecy is true
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
summerlynn1978 said:
I do not know b4 the books
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
avada_kedavra said:
Well, don't forget Harry's parents where aurors, and that was probably part of their job. They must have faced Voldemort, since they where in the first order of the phoenix before they died.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
they are ?? i never know James n Lily are aurors !!
rheiicullen_78 posted Больше года
bambinabird said:
they were part of the order of the pheonix, so they probably did some blows to him, and when the did the charm that made it impossible for voldemort to find, then made wormtail secret keeper that was pretty tricky
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
TheLogicalwitch said:
There's no exact answer to this in the books. Dumbledore only says at the end of HP5 that both HArry & Neville's parents had defied Voldemort thrice. I suppose they did so when they worked for the order before Harry или Neville's birth. Not sure.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
RD_Blue_demigod said:
I never think that lily and james outsmarted voldemort.The only reason why voldemort killed harry's parents is because they stand and gave their loyalty to dumbledore and they remain as a good witch and wizard until the end.or maybe voldemort just like killing by then,,and the other reason is because lily and james stand to put a courageous fight for harry's survival,(because voldemort wanted harry to make himself str0nger)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
jaimiejo128 said:
when they died, because they outsmarted him because lily died for harry so that he would not die
select as best answer
 when they died, because they outsmarted him because lily died for harry so that he would not die
posted Больше года 
next question »