What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Гарри Поттер Who's to blame for Ginny not being punished after she hexed Zacharius Smith in front of Professor Slughorn on the Hogwarts Express?

33 fans picked:
Professor Slughorn
Professor Slughorn
   85%
Ginny
Ginny
   15%
 Pensieve_Seeker posted Больше года
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

7 comments

user photo
Professor Slughorn
zanhar1 picked Professor Slughorn:
He however is not responsible for her actions.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
blackpanther666 picked Professor Slughorn:
What kind of question is this? She hexed him, because he was being a jerk. He ultimately deserved it. Slughorn was simply interested in her talents.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
WinterAmari picked Professor Slughorn:
^...I don't remember him being a jerk so i checked ..and
"He saw me hex Zacharias Smith, you remember that idiot from Hufflepuff who was in the DA? He kept on and on asking about what happened at the Ministry and in the end he annoyed me so much I hexed him..."-Ginny
Okay now i don't think hexing (or punchin or using any type of violence) againts people who keep asking you the same thing over and over again and piss you off is right . I've never seen anyone try to punch/hurt someone for asking the same q way too much and being annoying , i've seen people snap or yell or insult , or just stand up and leave and tell the annoying person to "shove off' . So i honestly don't think what she did to him was deserved , he wasn't mocking her nor attacking her , he was being an annoying idiot ,do you punch/hex all people that piss you off? Maybe you would , Ginny would , and maybe even i would if i had magic abilities , but the right thing to do is ignore that person or just leave.

Ugh okay i am being annoying in all this trying to prove that Ginny's actions are wrong but i just want to show that she isn't a person that is that likable, but a sometimes very rude and the high school mean girl person, that still has some traits that are likeable- like bravery,loyalty to her friends and etc .
posted Больше года.
last edited Больше года
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
Flickerflame picked Professor Slughorn:
^We don't see the scene. Maybe she did initially keep asking Zacharias to shut up, did snap or try to walk off. And knowing Zacharias, he was probably quite insulting/insensitive in the way he questioned.

Obviously it was Slughorn's responsibility. Ginny didn't force him to invite her into the Slug Club instead of punishment. He was just interested in the cursing talent she'd displayed.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
Book-Freak picked Professor Slughorn:
Why would it be Ginny's fault?
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
zanhar1 picked Professor Slughorn:
^ Because she's the one who did the hexing. No one grabbed her wrist and forced her to do it.
posted Больше года.
 
user photo
Professor Slughorn
fhghu picked Professor Slughorn:
Exactly. It bothers me a lot that Ginny got rewarded for hexing a student rather than punished. She deserved a punishment.
posted Больше года.