Гарри Поттер
Гарри Поттер Hp Contest / Pick your LEAST Избранное character / Round 4
This question is now closed
31 fans picked: |
Rita Skeeter
|
|||
Cornelius помадка, выдумка
|
|||
James Potter
|
|||
Cho Chang
|
|||
Ginny Weasley
|
|||
Percy Weasley
|
|||
Vincent Crabbe
|
|||
Bartemius Crouch, Jr.
|
|||
Dudley Dursley
|
|||
петуния Dursley
|
|||
Vernon Dursley
|
|||
Gregory Goyle
|
|||
Lee Jordan
|
|||
Lucius Malfoy
|
|||
Cormac McLaggen
|
|||
Северус Снегг
|
|||
Molly Weasley
|
|||
Hannah Abbott
|
|||
Ludo Bagman
|
|||
Katie колокол, колокольчик, белл
|
|||
Сириус Блэк
|
|||
Lavender Brown
|
|||
Colin Creevey
|
|||
Bartemius Crouch, Sr.
|
|||
Fleur Delacour
|
|||
Cedric Diggory
|
|||
Dobby
|
|||
Aberforth Dumbledore
|
|||
Albus Dumbledore
|
|||
Argus Filch
|
|||
Seamus Finnigan
|
|||
Mundungus Fletcher
|
|||
Filius Flitwick
|
|||
Гермиона Грейнджер
|
|||
Kreacher
|
|||
Rubeus Hagrid
|
|||
Angelina Johnson
|
|||
Grawp
|
|||
Viktor Krum
|
|||
Gilderoy Lockhart
|
|||
Neville Longbottom
|
|||
Полумна Лавгуд
|
|||
Xenophilius Lovegood
|
|||
Remus Lupin
|
|||
Драко Малфой
|
|||
Narcissa Malfoy
|
|||
Minerva McGonagall
|
|||
Alastor Moody
|
|||
Moaning Myrtle
|
|||
Garrick Ollivander
|
|||
Pansy Parkinson
|
|||
Padma Patil
|
|||
Parvati Patil
|
|||
мак Pomfrey
|
|||
Гарри Поттер
|
|||
Lily Potter
|
|||
Quirinus Quirrell
|
|||
Horace Slughorn
|
|||
Pomona Sprout
|
|||
Dean Thomas
|
|||
Nymphadora Тонкс
|
|||
Sybill Trelawney
|
|||
Arthur Weasley
|
|||
Bill Weasley
|
|||
Charlie Weasley
|
|||
Фред Weasley
|
|||
George Weasley
|
|||
Ron Weasley
|
|||
Oliver Wood
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
Tnx for voting and wait for the next rounds:
1.?????
2.?
3.?
4.?
5.?
6.?
7.?
8.?
9.?
10.?
11.?
12.?
13.?
14.?
15.?
16.?
17.?
18.?
19.?
20.?
21.?
22.?
23.?
24.?
25.?
26.?
27,?
28.?
29.?
30.?
31.?
32.?
33.?
34.?
35.?
36.?
37.?
38.?
39.?
40.?
41.?
42.?
43.?
44.?
45.?
46.?
47.?
48.?
49.?
50.?
51.?
52.?
53.?
54.?
55.?
56.?
57.?
58.?
59.?
60.?
61.?
62.?
63.?
64.?
65.?
66.?
67.?
68.?
69.?
70.Fenrir Greyback
71.Marge Dursley
72.Lord Voldemort
73.Peter Pettigrew
74.Bellatrix Lestrange
75.Dolores Umbridge
"I'm going to say James because we didn't get to know anything good about him. Maybe he was a good husband and maybe a good dad, but we only got to see him as a hateful bully."
@SherlockStark - we know he died trying to buy Lily and Harry time to escape.... we know he was a member of the Order....
@ginnyweasley8 you can see the characters who are out already in the first comment on the list Umbridge is the character number 75,THE WORST >:[]
James showed great bravery when he sacrificed his own life UNARMED against the most powerful Wizard in the World in order to save his wife and son. He was also a loyal friend - many people would have shunned Lupin for his 'furry little problem', but James along with the other marauders stuck by him. How are these things not considered good? I think many fans, generally-speaking, have an irrational, somewhat unwarranted hatred for James to the point where they can't see anything but bad in the character. I understand that he was a bully in his youth and his behaviour is rightfully criticised, I don't condone it, but he grew up, he matured. He was clearly a better person in the end. Also, since James is so hated for his bullying ways then I don't understand why Snape is let off for his treatment of some his students - most notably Neville, which was verging on bullying. Having a hard life is no excuse.
The series teaches us that there is shades of grey in everyone (except Voldemort) so it's odd to me that many people seem to view Snape as a saint with no bad qualities and James as the devil incarnate with no good qualities. That just goes against one of the themes of the book. Snape and James are ultimately both good people, in my opinion, but both have their own flaws.
I understand people have different opinions but how James is more hated than the likes of Vernon Dursley, who abused Harry for years and didn't change, is just completely beyond me.
Rita Skeeter annoyed me to no end.
Войди или зарегистрируйся для того, чтобы добавить свой комментарий