I LOVE P.Sawyer (and her career) but her life is way too complicated and Brooke's life is not my style. Haley's been through stuff but overall she's had a really comfortable and loving life and great husband.

Definitely not Peyton's, even though she's my favourite OTH character.

I love Peyton so much ,I admire her for her depth and for being a fighter but agree with Moosh ,she's been through everything ,Brooke no way ,especially in highschool years the way she was thinking and acting was/is so out of everything I look up to so Haley's ,actually I think there are some characteristics that we do have in common (concerning the personnality!)

Peyton is definitely my favorite but I would definitely have Haley's life! She has sisters and brothers, always had great parents there for her, she had Nathan + she sings amazingly and she's so intelligent !


Please Moosh do some more! It's so great :D

Definitely NOT Peyton's -too much psychos and life threathning situations- Haley had a great one: She has a good family, friends, she does what she likes...

I'm not a fan of any of the girls, or their lives, but if I had to pick..

Definitely! Even though her parents died when she was in her early/mid twenties, she still got to experience having loving parents for all of her formative years. She found the love of her life at the age of 16, and even though they had a fair share of drama and fights, they ALWAYS got through it and came out stronger. Haley was also a talented, successful musician, she was very intelligent and a beautiful women.