Ответить на этот вопрос

Орудия смерти Вопрос

So... I've been Чтение reviews for the City of Кости movie... (be prepared for a rant)

...and there's a lot of criticism about it. I haven't seen the movie, but now I'm kind of scared that the Фильмы will ruin the books.

But, I have realised, that a lot of the negative criticism comes from people that already dislike the YA genre- so maybe the negative reviews are just bias?

A lot of them seem to complain that "it's unoriginal", a "jumble of other already famous YA Фильмы etc" "such as Twilight, Harry Potter and Percy Jackson."
Let me state something. Please do not even dare to call City of Кости a rip-off of Twilight.
What makes Ты consider that is it a "rip-off" of Twilight?
The "love triangle"? Don't almost all romantic stories have them?
The Волколаки and vampires? ...does that mean that the Волколаки and Вампиры originated from Twilight?
или is it because they are both of a YA genre? или maybe it's because there's a female heroine in both series? Honestly, someone help me understand why, just why people think that City of Кости is a rip-off of Twilight.
I actually read a review where the person described City of Кости as "the worst of all Twilight copies", "...that bunch includes The Host..."
The Host is a copy of Twilight? I'm not a Фан of Stephanie Meyer's works, neither have I read The Host, but even I know that they were written by the same author. Ты might want to check your facts, buddy.

Please, please, for the love of humanity, please do not compare Twilight to City of Bones.

Another thing is, people are complaining that it's 'incest'. Glad to know that the plot twist actually got to you. Although Ты don't seem to be aware that it is meant to be a plot twist.
And to clear it up (taking a quote I saw from tumblr): it's not incest, it's [complicated.

I think the thing that most people forget is that whilst romance is a hugely important factor to the plot, it is not the actually plot itself.

I know not seeing the movie might have effected my opi
 So... I've been Чтение reviews for the City of Кости movie... (be prepared for a rant)
*
OH GREAT IT CUT OFF
Lani27 posted Больше года
*
Continue on: I know not seeing the movie might have effected my opinion, but I realise I'm not really trying to defend the movie, but I'm just trying to defend Cassandra Clare and the series overall. I mean, insulting the movie's plot line is pretty much the same thing as insulting the Книги plot-line, right? I suppose I just really don't want it to become one of those 'the-movies-ruined-the-books-but-everyone's-opinions-are-based-on-the-movie-and-not-the-books' things. *takes a deep breath* So, what do Ты think? ((Sorry if Чтение all that was exhausting, I really just wanted to vent all my anger out by ranting. Also, I apologise if I got anything factually incorrect on here.))
Lani27 posted Больше года
*
Also, I just saw the movie recently. And I still think that my argument is completely valid. (I would also like to add some other things... but I'm too lazy ^^;)
Lani27 posted Больше года
 Lani27 posted Больше года
next question »

Орудия смерти Ответы

ally0128 said:
I think it really doesn't matter wat critics say cuz there critics they will always have a negative opinion about Фильмы it all that matters is wat Фаны think im mean do Ты think the twilight series became this huge phenomenon becuz of the critics nope they we're huge cuz it was thanks to the Фаны that made it this huge success n the same goes for mortal instruments the reason y the Книги did well was cuz of the Фаны n im sure the movie will too no matter if critics think its a big bowl of shit... I for one am a huge Фан of the series n luvs the movie no.matter wat any stupid critic says about it :)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Yes, you're right. I'm just a little worried, because I found out that CoB only made 3 million on the first день (as opposed to The Hunger Games's 60 million).
Lani27 posted Больше года
*
Negative critiques=less people want to watch it= produces less money=less chance that the other Книги will be made into a movie
Lani27 posted Больше года
Alchemistlover said:
Comparing Mortal instruments to Twilight is so stupid. T.M.I had actual meaning and character growth. I haven't seen the movie yet but i think critics are stupid to compare to Twilight. Oh and Ты may want to make this an Статья instead of a Вопрос
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Yeah, I agree. I think it's just mainly because most critics dislike the YA genre, so whenever they see a movie that is intended for YA, they would probably compare it to Twilight :/
Lani27 posted Больше года
*
Also, it WAS meant to be a question- "So, what do Ты think?" asking about what everyone else thinks of the critics, but I got a bit carried away, heh ^^; sorry
Lani27 posted Больше года
next question »