Though I do really love the Marilyn Manson one

I LOVE THEM ALL!!!♥♥♥

As much as I luffed the Fall Out Boy version, nothing beats the original!

the marilyn manson one was good too but teh original is teh best, the panic! at the disco one wasnt very good

Marilyn Manson Made it so dark and sexy! Original is great too

i havent heard the other ones

the panick at the disco 1 is best

marilyn manson is da bomb!

It's creepy, but it fits.

ORIGANAL cause its a classic !!!!!!!!!

Though the others had merit, I do enjoy the classics.

the original is the best. i would say the second best is the p!atd one.

Manson's version just fits the song so well. I have to say that the original sounds kind of weak compared to his.

Fall Out Boy's version isn't too bad either.

i have it as my ring tone its so awsome i know almost the whole song

I prefer the origional to the other ones alone, but acctually (I saw on youtube) if u put the ones from Marilyn Manson and Panic at the Disco together, it sounds great...look for it on youtube...

Marilyn's is the best ever...

Loved it!

original is the best ever

I am by no means a Marilyn manson fan, but i love his cover.


P!ATD did a cover!?!

he made it much scarier

i loved the original, but Marilyn Manson did a good job. I think Panic! At The Disco's version was horrible.

His version was way better than Panic! At the Disco's. I is AWESOME!!!

although manson's was very good.
Panic's sucked.

Never to late for a classic lol def Original

i adore the original too!
i just think Manson did a great job with his cover.
...except the line that he says "Everyone hail to the Pumpkin King, now!" because it doesn't fit the music like it's supposed to!

This one is so better than the other ones.

I really like the others, but nothing can amount to the original.
"In this town, we call home, everyone hail to the pumpkin song." <3

i like how Marilyn Manson made it sound i dont realy like Marilyn Manson tho

i never heard of the disco thing, but iv heard the marilon manson one and the origanal, so i picked, you know.

I hate it when a bunch of heavy metal bands redid those songs!

I didn't like the Marilyn Manson's version of This is Halloween.

I love the original one too.

i love Marilyn Manson & the Original

MadamOcta13, I agree with you...

Of couse the original!!

^w^

I love the Original one better!!!!!

I love them all but of course without the original (by Danny Elfman :D) there wouldnt be all the others!

Mailyn manson made this song what it should be!!!

But I do love Marilyn Manson's as well. :D

Nobody can beat the Original.

though I do quite like Manson's version, it doesn't compare to the original.

no doubt

Original :)

I LUV MARILYN MANSONS!!!!!!!!!!
he made it seem dark and evil

I like them all :)

Huge manson fan, loved this cover the guitar made the song sound much darker.

I friggin LOVE him man XD

I love listening to both versions, and Marilyn Manson did an awesome job with the song, it was brilliant :)

i f***ing LOVE LOVE LOVE this version!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

manson, hands down!

MARILYN MANSON FTW. Love the original, but panic at the disco was a big fail for me.

But I do LOVE the Marilyn Manson version

I never heard other verions so

I love this! <3

The original has all the different voices which is awesome becuz the other versions don't.