All of them are amazing but he's just not as impressive

^ Just what I was going to say about Josh :)

Apparently with my actors list I just know exactly what you're gonna say, though with this one it was just a different actor lol!

That's hard!!!! I love them all!!! There are all very talented!

^^ Lol XD

Although it might just be his character thats holding him back. All are fantastic though.

They're all good actors...but I went with Jamie just because he sold his soul aka is going to be in that stupid Twilight fanfic movie *shudders*

I kind of think he's overrated.

I dont like that hes going to be in that shit either, but at least he's probably going to be naked. Thats one thing to look foward to right?

Sorry Jamie man!You are HOT,SEXY & everything but your acting is bad.(That doesn't mean I love you less though)

No doubt ;)

I don't remember who Jamie portrayed (my memory is pretty bad), so I chose Josh Dallas. It could just be the character, but when he plays Charming...it's just so...bland and plain. He comes out with some cheesy line in the typical fashion and I just sigh and roll my eyes. His facial expressions don't seem to change much either. But like I said, it could be the character. In which case, he portrays Charming perfectly. haha.

Jamie plays Graham/The Huntsman who Regina killed by crushing his heart

hahah nobody can hate robert carlyle hes wondereful

Or Colin, but they're all great.

Jamie is not a bad actor at all, he got a lot of praise from his performance in 'The Fall'. I'll go with Josh, but I like them all.

All of them are good but I think he is the worst of them

I guess with Josh it's just the character but I'll have to see him in something else:)

I thought Jamie did actually pretty well.:/ I loved him<3 I still think he's better than Josh though. xD Josh is fine at best.

All are amazing though!

I guess nobody has seen The Fall....