Ethan never dated Brooke.
Owen abandoned her.
Chase...no way.
Lucas would definetly be a worthy opponent,but he did cheat on her twice...

well i actually think chase would be worthy too...owen not at all...and ethan why is that even an option

Chase would win.
I wish.

no offense, but brooke had to tell luke to fight for her - hardly a worthy opponent. Chase treated brooke like a goddess. I'm not a fan of his, but he's good for brooke :)

lmfao omg i love how Dr.Copeland is on the list. but anyways Lucas forsure is the one whod be the biggest competition. Hes the only guy whos ever truly had her heart. Chase and Owen were just some random guys ther to fill the void. But BL and Brulian are the real deal. Plus the whole fighting for her thing was pretty kool IMO. and heck if lucas fought for her b4 then we know hes gotta be the best competition for Julian.

I would loove that :D

btw, wasn't the "doctor guy" on the show for just one or two episodes how hilarious haha lmfao;);)

agree with abs.

Even though Julian would beat him..Brase were so awesome together!

definitely lucas.